It started with shoes. Or maybe it didn't. History is messy like that. You've probably heard the old story that Confederate troops marched into a sleepy Pennsylvania crossroads town just looking for footwear and accidentally tripped into the bloodiest battle of the American Civil War. Honestly, that’s mostly a myth. While Henry Heth’s division was definitely looking for supplies, the Battle of Gettysburg first day was the result of two massive armies blindly groping for each other in the dark until they finally collided on July 1, 1863.
It was hot. Humid. The kind of Pennsylvania summer morning where the air feels like a wet wool blanket. By the time the sun set, over 15,000 men were dead, wounded, or missing. And that was just the "prelude."
People usually focus on Pickett’s Charge or the struggle for Little Round Top. Those happened on days two and three. But if you really want to understand why the North won—or why the South lost—you have to look at those chaotic first twelve hours. It was a day of incredible gambles, missed opportunities, and a few guys in blue standing their ground when they probably should have run for their lives.
How the Battle of Gettysburg First Day Actually Began
General Robert E. Lee was in a bind. He was deep in enemy territory, his "eyes and ears"—J.E.B. Stuart’s cavalry—were missing in action, and he didn't know exactly where the Union Army of the Potomac was hiding.
Then came John Buford.
Buford was a Union Brigadier General with a keen eye for terrain. He arrived in Gettysburg on June 30 and saw the hills. He realized that if the Confederates took the high ground—Cemetery Hill, Culp’s Hill, and the Round Tops—the Union would be toast. He didn't have much. Just two brigades of cavalry. About 2,700 men. Against them? Tens of thousands of Confederates under A.P. Hill were rumbling down the Chambersburg Pike.
Buford decided to fight a delaying action. It was a gutsy move. His men were outnumbered, but they had Spencer repeating carbines. They could fire faster than the Confederates with their muzzle-loaders.
The first shot? It’s widely attributed to Marcellus Jones of the 8th Illinois Cavalry. He borrowed a carbine, rested it on a fence rail, and took a shot at a gray-clad officer about 700 yards away. He missed. But the war had found its way to Gettysburg.
The Death of Reynolds and the Shift in Momentum
The fighting intensified around McPherson’s Ridge. Buford’s men were hanging on by their fingernails. Then, the infantry arrived. Major General John Reynolds, one of the most respected officers in the Union army, rode up with the First Corps.
📖 Related: Bryce Canyon National Park: What People Actually Get Wrong About the Hoodoos
"Good morning, John. What's the matter?" Reynolds reportedly shouted to Buford.
"The devil's to pay!" Buford yelled back.
Reynolds rushed his men into the fray. It was a desperate moment. The "Iron Brigade," famous for their distinct black hats and fierce reputation, crashed into the Confederate lines in Herbst’s Woods. They actually captured Confederate Brigadier General James Archer—the first time a general officer from Lee's army had been captured since he took command.
But then, tragedy struck the Union.
Reynolds was shouting orders, turning in his saddle to check on his troops, when a bullet struck him in the back of the head. He died instantly. The Union had lost its best tactical commander within the first two hours of the real fighting.
The Afternoon Collapse
By noon, things looked okay for the North. They held the ridge. They had more men coming in. But then the "Fog of War" started to settle in.
Confederate reinforcements were arriving from the north and west. Richard Ewell’s Second Corps started screaming down the Harrisburg Road and Carlisle Road. This created a massive problem. The Union line was now shaped like a giant "L," vulnerable to being flanked.
Major General Oliver Otis Howard, who took command after Reynolds fell, placed his Eleventh Corps to the north of town. It was a bad spot. The terrain was flat. There were too few men to cover too much ground. When the Confederates under Jubal Early attacked, the Eleventh Corps folded.
👉 See also: Getting to Burning Man: What You Actually Need to Know About the Journey
It wasn't a retreat; it was a rout.
Soldiers were sprinting through the streets of Gettysburg. Imagine the terror of the townspeople. People like Elizabeth Thorn, the pregnant caretaker of the Evergreen Cemetery, watched as thousands of panicked men climbed over her fences. The Confederates were right on their heels.
Why Didn't Ewell Take the Hill?
This is the big "What If" of the Battle of Gettysburg first day.
The Union troops retreated to Cemetery Hill. It was a strong position, but they were disorganized and terrified. Robert E. Lee saw the opportunity. He sent a famous order to General Ewell: take the hill "if practicable."
In the military world, "if practicable" is a bit of a gray area.
Ewell looked at the hill. He saw Union artillery. He saw fresh troops (or what he thought were fresh troops). He decided it wasn't practicable. He waited.
That wait changed history.
By the time the sun went down, the Union had reinforced the "fishhook" line. They held the high ground. Lee had won the day on paper—he drove the enemy back and took the town—but he hadn't won the battle. He had pushed the Union into the best defensive position they could have asked for.
✨ Don't miss: Tiempo en East Hampton NY: What the Forecast Won't Tell You About Your Trip
The Human Cost of July 1
We talk about generals and maps, but the sheer violence of that Wednesday was staggering.
Take the 24th Michigan. They were part of the Iron Brigade. They went into the woods that morning with 496 men. By the end of the day, only 99 were left standing. That’s nearly an 80% casualty rate in a few hours of fighting.
The civilian experience was just as harrowing.
Gettysburg was a town of about 2,400 people. Suddenly, every basement, barn, and church was a hospital. The smell of blood and wood smoke filled the air. A young woman named Jennie Wade was staying at her sister's house, baking bread for the Union soldiers. She would become the only direct civilian casualty of the battle later on, but on day one, she—like everyone else—was just trying to survive the chaos.
Lessons from the First Day
What can we actually learn from the Battle of Gettysburg first day? It wasn't about superior numbers or better guns. It was about initiative.
- Buford’s Foresight: He recognized the value of the "high ground" before anyone else did. In any high-stakes situation, the person who secures the "terrain" first usually wins.
- The Danger of Vague Instructions: Lee’s "if practicable" is the ultimate cautionary tale in communication. If you want something done, be specific.
- The Power of Resilience: The Union Eleventh Corps got a bad rap for running, but their stand bought enough time for the rest of the army to dig in on Cemetery Hill. Sometimes, "failing slowly" is a victory in itself.
Visiting the Battlefield Today
If you're heading to Gettysburg to see where this all went down, don't just go to the High Water Mark. Start where the battle started.
- McPherson Ridge: Stand near the John Reynolds statue. You can see exactly how the Confederates approached and feel the vulnerability of the Union line.
- The Barlow Knoll: Go north of the town to see where the Eleventh Corps was overwhelmed. It gives you a great perspective on why the Union line collapsed.
- Cemetery Hill: End your day here. Look down into the town and imagine what Ewell saw. You’ll understand why he hesitated—and why that hesitation was a fatal mistake for the Confederacy.
The first day was a tactical victory for Lee, but a strategic disaster. He drove the Union into a fortress. He didn't know it yet, but the war had reached its tipping point on those dusty roads and blood-soaked ridges.
To dive deeper into the specifics of the units involved, check out the National Park Service records or read Stephen Sears’ Gettysburg, which is basically the gold standard for this stuff. Understanding the first day isn't just about history; it's about seeing how small decisions—a missed shot, a vague order, a stubborn general—can pivot the fate of an entire nation.
Actionable Insights for History Buffs:
- Map the Terrain: Use a topographical map when studying July 1. You'll see that the battle was entirely dictated by ridges and creek beds (like Willoughby Run).
- Read the Official Records: Look for the "ORs" (Official Records of the War of the Rebellion) online. Reading the actual reports from colonels and captains written days after the fight reveals the confusion that "polished" history books often smooth over.
- Walk the Town: Most people skip the town of Gettysburg itself, but the street fighting on the afternoon of July 1 was brutal. Look for the "bullet holes" still visible in some of the older brick buildings on Baltimore Street.
The story of Gettysburg is often told as a grand epic, but on July 1, it was a series of panicked, desperate, and incredibly brave moments that no one saw coming. It was the day the "shoes" myth was born and the day a republic was saved by a hair's breadth.