Books are weirdly powerful. It sounds like a cliché you’d see on a library poster, but honestly, people don’t try to set fire to things that don’t have teeth. Over the last few years, the concept of the Banned Book Club has shifted from a niche hobby for rebellious English majors into a full-blown national movement. It’s a reaction to a very real, very documented spike in challenges against literature in schools and public libraries across the United States.
You’ve probably seen the headlines. According to the American Library Association (ALA), 2023 saw the highest number of book challenges since they started compiling data over twenty years ago. We are talking about 4,240 unique book titles targeted for censorship. That isn't a typo. It’s a massive jump from the previous year. When you see numbers like that, the "club" part of the banned book club isn't just about tea and snacks anymore. It’s about defense.
People often think these clubs are just about reading "dirty" books. They aren't. Most of the titles on the chopping block—like Gender Queer by Maia Kobabe or All Boys Aren’t Blue by George M. Johnson—deal with identity, race, and the messy reality of growing up. A Banned Book Club is essentially a collective "no" to the idea that adults should decide what other adults (and their teenagers) are allowed to think about.
💡 You might also like: Why Braids at the Front are Actually the Hardest Part to Get Right
Why the Banned Book Club Movement Exploded Now
It’s about control. Plain and simple.
Historically, book banning happened in quiet boardrooms. Now, it’s a spectator sport. Groups like Moms for Liberty have standardized the process of challenging books, using spreadsheets and pre-written scripts to move through school districts. This organized pressure created a vacuum. Readers felt like they were losing their agency, so they started fighting back with the most basic tool available: a reading list.
The Banned Book Club became the standard-bearer for this resistance. Organizations like the Brooklyn Public Library launched "Books Unbanned," providing digital library cards to teens across the country so they could access restricted titles. This isn't just some underground, "hush-hush" thing. It’s a massive infrastructure project designed to keep information flowing when the local taps get turned off.
Honestly, the irony is thick. Nothing makes a teenager want to read a book more than telling them it’s dangerous. When a school board in McMinn County, Tennessee, removed the Holocaust graphic novel Maus from its curriculum in 2022, the book shot to the top of the Amazon bestseller list. Art Spiegelman’s work, which is a brutal and necessary look at genocide, suddenly had a massive new audience of young people who wanted to know what the fuss was about. The banned book club isn't just a group; it’s a market force.
The Real People Behind the Pages
Take a look at what happened in Kutztown, Pennsylvania. A student-led Banned Book Club formed specifically because they felt their education was being narrowed. They didn't just read; they organized. They met at a local diner. They talked about The Bluest Eye by Toni Morrison. They discussed why a story about a young Black girl’s struggle with beauty standards was considered "inappropriate" by people who had never lived that experience.
These aren't radical insurgents. They’re kids who want to see themselves in the stories they read.
Misconceptions About Censorship
There's this idea that banning a book is only about "removing it from the shelf." That’s only half the story. The real "ban" is the soft censorship that happens before a book even hits the library. It's the librarian who decides not to order a certain title because they don’t want to deal with a parent's email. It's the teacher who removes a classic from their syllabus to avoid a "controversy."
A Banned Book Club fights this by creating demand. If the library won't stock it, the club buys ten copies from an independent bookstore. If the school won't teach it, the club hosts a Zoom call with an expert.
- The "Pornography" Myth: Many challengers use the word "pornographic" to describe books that contain any mention of LGBTQ+ identity or sexual health. Experts and the ALA point out that these books rarely meet the legal definition of obscenity, but the label sticks in a soundbite.
- The Parental Rights Argument: This is the core of the conflict. One group says parents should curate their child’s intake. The other says one parent’s preference shouldn’t dictate what every other child in the district can access.
How to Actually Run a Banned Book Club That Works
If you’re thinking about starting one, don't just pick a book and talk about why it's "bad" that it's banned. That’s boring. You need to dive into the why. Why did this specific set of words scare someone?
First, get your hands on the ALA’s Top 10 Most Challenged Books list. It’s updated annually and serves as the perfect syllabus. Don't just read the "hits" like 1984 or Fahrenheit 451. Everyone knows those. Look at the modern stuff. Look at The Hate U Give by Angie Thomas. Look at Lawn Boy by Jonathan Evison.
You should also look into the legal side. Organizations like PEN America provide actual data on where these bans are happening. If you’re in a "red" state or a "blue" state, the challenges look different, but they’re happening everywhere. A Banned Book Club in Florida might be focusing on state legislation like the "Don't Say Gay" bill, while a club in a more liberal area might be discussing how to support authors who are being silenced elsewhere.
Essential Reading for Your Next Meeting
- Gender Queer by Maia Kobabe: This is currently the most challenged book in the US. It’s a memoir about non-binary identity. Reading it allows you to see past the "outrage" clips on the news and see the actual human story.
- The Bluest Eye by Toni Morrison: A perennial target. It’s dense, poetic, and uncomfortable. It deals with incest and racism. It’s also a masterpiece of American literature.
- Flamer by Mike Curato: A graphic novel about a boy at scout camp. It’s been targeted for its depictions of puberty and self-discovery.
The Future of Reading is Active
We are past the point where reading is a passive act. In 2026, picking up a book is a choice that has political weight. The Banned Book Club model is moving into a new phase: community resilience. We’re seeing "Little Free Libraries" filled specifically with banned titles. We’re seeing "Banned Book Nooks" in coffee shops.
It’s not just about the books. It’s about the right to be curious.
When you join or start a Banned Book Club, you’re joining a lineage of people who realized that the easiest way to control a population is to limit their imagination. If you can’t imagine a different world, you won't try to build one. Books provide the blueprints for those other worlds.
Honestly, the best thing you can do is just read. Don't wait for a formal meeting. Buy the book that people are shouting about. Read the passage they’re quoting out of context. Make up your own mind. That’s the whole point of a democracy, right? The freedom to be wrong, the freedom to be offended, and the freedom to keep reading anyway.
Actionable Steps to Take Right Now
- Check the Lists: Go to the PEN America or ALA website. See which books were challenged in your specific state over the last 12 months. The results might surprise you.
- Support Your Local Librarian: They are on the front lines. Send a thank-you note. Attend a library board meeting. You’d be shocked how much a few supportive voices can change the energy in a room full of angry protestors.
- Buy Banned: If you have the means, purchase banned books from independent sellers. This keeps the authors in business and ensures the stories stay in circulation.
- Host a "Silent" Banned Book Club: If you don't want the drama of a formal discussion, just get five friends together in a park, everyone bring a different challenged book, and read in silence for an hour. It’s a powerful visual statement.
- Check Your Own Bias: We all have "the line" we don't want books to cross. Use a club to read something that makes you uncomfortable. Growth doesn't happen in the comfort zone.
The conversation around the Banned Book Club isn't going away. As long as there are people who want to narrow the world, there will be people who want to crack it back open. Be the person with the crowbar.