You've probably heard the story. A massive military bomber, blinded by soup-thick fog, slams into the side of the world’s most famous skyscraper. It sounds like a Hollywood script or a fever dream from the height of the Cold War. But here’s the kicker: if you’re looking for the b52 Empire State Building crash, you’re actually chasing a ghost.
The plane wasn't a B-52.
Honestly, it’s one of those historical Mandela Effects. People hear "bomber" and "Empire State Building" and their brains jump to the massive, eight-engine Stratofortress. In reality, the B-52 didn't even take its first flight until 1952, seven years after the actual disaster. The plane that carved a hole in the Manhattan skyline on July 28, 1945, was a B-25 Mitchell.
It was smaller, sure. But the chaos it caused was anything but minor.
Why Everyone Gets the B52 Empire State Building Story Wrong
We live in an era of "big." When we think of bombers, we think of the giants. But back in '45, the B-25 was a workhorse. It was the same type of plane used in the Doolittle Raid.
On that Saturday morning, Lieutenant Colonel William F. Smith Jr. was piloting a B-25 named "Old John Feather Merchant." He was a decorated vet, 27 years old, with plenty of combat hours under his belt. He was just trying to get from Massachusetts to Newark.
The fog was brutal.
LaGuardia controllers told him to land. They literally told him, "We're unable to see the top of the Empire State Building." Smith, maybe a bit overconfident or just in a hurry to pick up his commanding officer, pushed on. He got disoriented over Queens. He thought he was over the East River, but he was actually over midtown.
📖 Related: The Galveston Hurricane 1900 Orphanage Story Is More Tragic Than You Realized
He dodged the Chrysler Building. He missed the New York Central Building. But at 9:40 a.m., he ran out of luck.
The Impact: 79 Floors Up
The B-25 wasn't crawling. It was hitting about 200 miles per hour when it struck the north side of the building. It tore an 18-by-20-foot hole right between the 78th and 79th floors.
Imagine being at your desk on a quiet Saturday. Suddenly, a twin-engine bomber is in your office.
The high-octane fuel exploded instantly. Flames licked down the side of the building and surged through the hallways. One engine did something truly insane: it punched clean through the entire building, exited the south side, and flew another block before landing on the roof of a penthouse on 33rd Street.
The other engine? It plunged down an elevator shaft.
The Miracle of Betty Lou Oliver
If you want to talk about "against all odds," you have to talk about Betty Lou Oliver. She was a 20-year-old elevator operator. It was actually her last day on the job—she was supposed to be moving to join her husband.
When the plane hit, she was badly burned on the 80th floor. Rescuers, trying to be helpful, put her on a different elevator to get her down to the ground for medical help.
👉 See also: Why the Air France Crash Toronto Miracle Still Changes How We Fly
They didn't realize the cables had been weakened by the crash.
As soon as the doors closed, the cables snapped. Betty Lou plummeted 75 stories in a free-falling metal box. That’s over 1,000 feet.
She survived.
Physics saved her, mostly. The severed cables coiled at the bottom of the shaft like a giant spring, and the air pressure building up in the tight shaft acted as a natural brake. She broke her back, her neck, and her pelvis, but she lived to be 74 years old.
Breaking Down the "B52" Misconception
Why does the b52 Empire State Building search term even exist? Usually, it's because of 9/11.
Whenever people discuss structural integrity or conspiracy theories, they bring up the 1945 crash. They argue that because the Empire State Building stayed standing, other buildings should have, too.
But comparing a B-25 to a modern airliner—or even a B-52—is like comparing a Vespa to a semi-truck.
✨ Don't miss: Robert Hanssen: What Most People Get Wrong About the FBI's Most Damaging Spy
- Weight: A B-25 weighed around 20,000 lbs. A B-52 weighs over 180,000 lbs empty. A Boeing 767? Over 300,000 lbs.
- Fuel: The B-25 had about 800 gallons of gasoline. Modern jets carry tens of thousands of gallons of jet fuel (basically kerosene), which burns much longer and hotter.
- Speed: Smith was doing 200 mph. The planes in 2001 were doing over 500 mph.
The Empire State Building is also built like a fortress. It's a "forest" of steel beams encased in heavy stone and concrete. It wasn't just the size of the plane that mattered; it was the fact that the building was over-engineered to a degree we rarely see today.
What We Can Learn From the 1945 Crash
This wasn't just a "freak accident" that we look back on for the trivia. It actually changed the law.
Before this, you couldn't really sue the federal government for negligence like this. The families of the victims pushed for change, leading to the Federal Tort Claims Act of 1946. It’s the reason citizens can now seek justice when the government or its employees (like a military pilot) mess up and cause harm.
Actionable Insights for History Buffs and Travelers:
- Check the 80th Floor: If you visit the Empire State Building today, you can still see where the repairs were made. The stone on the exterior is slightly different if you know where to look, though the interior offices have been renovated dozens of times.
- Verify the Model: If you’re ever in an argument about this, remember: B-25 is the "Mitchell." B-52 is the "Stratofortress." They aren't even from the same decade of design.
- The Fog Factor: Modern aviation uses ILS (Instrument Landing Systems) that make a 1945-style "blind flight" almost impossible for commercial or military craft over Manhattan. We have "hard floors" for altitude that weren't strictly enforced back then.
- Visit the Memorials: There isn't a massive plaque on the building, but the National Catholic Welfare Council (now the USCCB) still remembers the employees lost that day.
Fourteen people died that morning. Three in the plane, eleven in the building. It’s a somber reminder that even the "World's Greatest Building" isn't invincible, but it's also a testament to the incredible engineering of the early 20th century. Next time someone mentions the b52 Empire State Building crash, you’ll be the one to tell them what really went down.
To see the actual path of the flight, you can look up the original New York Times maps from July 29, 1945, which show how Smith's plane zig-zagged through the towers before the final impact.