The ice axe didn’t kill him instantly. That’s the first thing people usually get wrong about the assassination of Leon Trotsky. When Ramón Mercader drove that shortened mountaineer's pick into the back of Trotsky’s skull on August 20, 1940, the Old Revolutionary didn't just drop. He let out a "terrible, piercing cry"—those are Mercader's own words from his later confession—and actually grappled with his killer.
He bit Mercader’s hand. He held him off.
Trotsky remained conscious long enough to tell his bodyguards not to kill the assassin. He wanted him to talk. He lived for another 26 hours in a Mexican hospital before his brain finally gave up. It was a messy, brutal, and surprisingly loud end for a man who had spent years looking over his shoulder, waiting for Stalin’s shadow to finally catch up with him.
Why Stalin Couldn’t Let Trotsky Live
To understand why this happened in a leafy suburb of Mexico City, you have to understand the level of petty, murderous grudge Joseph Stalin held. By 1940, Trotsky was a man without a country. He had been kicked out of the Soviet Union in 1929, bounced around Turkey, France, and Norway, and finally landed in Mexico thanks to the muralist Diego Rivera. He had no army. He had no real power.
But he had a pen.
Trotsky was writing a biography of Stalin. And he wasn't being nice. He was meticulously documenting how Stalin had, in his view, betrayed the Bolshevik Revolution. To Stalin, Trotsky wasn't just a political rival; he was a living breathing contradiction to the official Soviet narrative. As long as Trotsky breathed, the "Great Helmsman" in the Kremlin felt like a fraud.
The NKVD (the precursor to the KGB) was given a clear mandate: eliminate the "Old Man."
🔗 Read more: When is the Next Hurricane Coming 2024: What Most People Get Wrong
The Failed First Attempt: A Movie-Style Raid
Most people don't realize the assassination of Leon Trotsky almost happened months earlier, and it was way more chaotic. In May 1940, a group of twenty gunmen, led by the painter David Alfaro Siqueiros (a staunch Stalinist), stormed Trotsky’s compound in Coyoacán.
They went in with Thompson submachine guns. They fired over 200 shots into the bedrooms. They even set off small explosives.
Trotsky and his wife, Natalia Sedova, survived by diving under their bed in a dark corner of the room. It was a miracle, honestly. But it also served as a massive wake-up call. Trotsky turned his house into a fortress. He added steel shutters, thicker walls, and more guards. He knew they’d be back. He just didn't expect the killer to walk through the front door with a smile and a raincoat.
Enter "Frank Jacson": The Long Game
Ramón Mercader didn't just show up with an ice axe. He spent two years infiltrating Trotsky’s inner circle. This is the part that feels like a spy novel but is 100% historical fact.
The NKVD used a "honey trap" or sorts. Mercader, using the alias "Jacques Mornard" (and later "Frank Jacson"), began dating Sylvia Ageloff, a Brooklyn-born social worker and devoted Trotskyist. He played the part of a wealthy, somewhat apolitical businessman. He was charming. He drove a nice car. He did favors for the household.
He never showed interest in meeting Trotsky. That was the trick.
💡 You might also like: What Really Happened With Trump Revoking Mayorkas Secret Service Protection
By being the "boyfriend who hangs around," he became a fixture. The guards got used to him. Natalia liked him. Eventually, he started bringing Trotsky's articles to "critique." He built a bridge of mundane familiarity. By the time August 20 rolled around, "Jacson" was such a common sight that no one bothered to frisk him, even though he was wearing a heavy raincoat on a sunny Mexican day.
The Weapon Choice: Why an Ice Axe?
You’ve probably seen the weapon in museums or photos. It’s often called an ice pick, but it’s technically a mountaineer’s ice axe. Mercader had shortened the handle to hide it under his coat.
Why didn't he use a gun? Noise.
The plan was to strike Trotsky while he was reading a manuscript at his desk. A silent kill would allow Mercader to walk back out the door, get into his waiting car (where his mother, Caridad, and his handler, Nahum Eitingon, were watching), and vanish.
But the axe didn't penetrate deep enough to cause instant death. The "terrible cry" Trotsky let out alerted the guards immediately. When they burst in, they found the two men struggling. Trotsky was covered in blood, but he was pointing at Mercader, ensuring the world would know exactly who had done this.
The Aftermath and the "Hero of the Soviet Union"
Mercader got 20 years in a Mexican prison. For a long time, he refused to admit he was a Soviet agent, sticking to a cover story that he killed Trotsky over a personal dispute. Stalin, meanwhile, publicly denied any involvement, though the Soviet press celebrated the death of the "counter-revolutionary spy."
📖 Related: Franklin D Roosevelt Civil Rights Record: Why It Is Way More Complicated Than You Think
When Mercader was finally released in 1960, he made his way back to the USSR. There, in a private ceremony, he was awarded the Hero of the Soviet Union medal—the highest distinction in the land. It was the ultimate "thank you" for a job that took two years of deception and one bloody afternoon.
Why the Assassination of Leon Trotsky Still Lingers
Honestly, it’s about the "what ifs."
Historians like Isaac Deutscher or Robert Service have spent decades debating whether a Trotsky-led USSR would have been any different from Stalin's. Some argue Trotsky was just as authoritarian; others see him as a lost chance for a more intellectual, internationalist socialism.
The assassination of Leon Trotsky didn't just kill a man; it ended the last major internal challenge to Stalin’s absolute power. It signaled that the Soviet reach was global. If they could get you in a fortified house in Mexico, they could get you anywhere.
How to Explore This History Today
If you find yourself in Mexico City, don't just do the Frida Kahlo house. Go to the Museo Casa de León Trotsky in Coyoacán. It is preserved almost exactly as it was that day.
- Look at the bullet holes: You can still see the marks from the May raid in the bedroom walls.
- Check the desk: The desk where he was sitting when Mercader struck is still there, covered in books and papers.
- Walk the gardens: Trotsky loved his rabbits and his cacti. He was actually tending to them just before he went inside for that final meeting.
- Read the primary sources: Look up the "Dewey Commission" report. It’s a fascinating look at how Trotsky tried to clear his name against Stalin's "Show Trials" before he was silenced.
The house feels heavy. It’s a small, claustrophobic space that held one of the 20th century's most significant geopolitical dramas. Seeing the physical reality of the steel doors and the guard towers makes the desperation of his final years much more real than any textbook ever could.