It’s sitting there on the shelf. Staring at you. Maybe it's a hand-painted Royal Doulton porcelain or a beat-up plastic figurine from a 1950s Marx Toys set. Whether it’s worth ten bucks or ten thousand, an Alice in Wonderland figure isn't just a toy. It is a tiny, physical anchor to a story that has been melting our collective brains since 1865.
People collect this stuff for a million different reasons. Some want the nostalgia of the 1951 Disney flick. Others are die-hard Lewis Carroll purists who only care about the original John Tenniel woodblock engravings. But here is the thing: the market for these figures is absolutely booming right now, and if you aren't careful, you’ll end up buying a "rare" knockoff that’s about as authentic as a Cheshire Cat's grin.
The weird history of Alice in Wonderland figures
Alice didn't start as a plastic toy. Obviously. Back in the Victorian era, "merchandise" wasn't really a word people used like we do today. But Lewis Carroll—real name Charles Dodgson—was actually a bit of a branding genius. He cared deeply about how Alice looked. When John Tenniel drew those first illustrations, he created a visual template that we still use 160 years later. The pinafore, the stockings, the blonde hair (which, fun fact, the real Alice Liddell didn't even have; she was a brunette).
Early figures were often "bisque" dolls or Staffordshire pottery. These weren't for kids to throw around in a sandbox. They were mantlepieces. Collectors today hunt for the Beswick England pottery line, which started producing these characters in the 1970s. They have this specific, creamy glaze and a weight that just feels right in your hand. If you find a Beswick "Alice" with the backstamp "Beatrix Potter" by mistake (it happens), you’ve found a weird manufacturing crossover that collectors go nuts for.
Everything changed in 1951. Disney released the animated film, and suddenly the Alice in Wonderland figure became a mass-produced phenomenon. This is where the "Classic Alice" look—the bright blue dress and white apron—became the law of the land. Before Disney, Alice wore yellow, red, or even green in different book editions. Now? Try selling a green-dress Alice. It’s a tough sell.
What actually makes a figure valuable?
Don't assume old means expensive. It doesn't.
📖 Related: Bates Nut Farm Woods Valley Road Valley Center CA: Why Everyone Still Goes After 100 Years
I’ve seen people drop five grand on a modern Medicom Toy "Ultra Detail Figure" from Japan because it was a limited run of 500. Meanwhile, a dusty porcelain figurine from the 1980s might struggle to clear twenty dollars on eBay. It’s about the "sculpt."
Look at the face. In low-end figures, Alice looks like a generic doll. In high-end figures—think Leblon-Delienne or the high-grade resins from Sideshow Collectibles—the facial structure captures that specific "curiouser and curiouser" expression. Collectors pay for the soul of the character, not just the plastic.
Then there’s the "Mad Hatter" factor. Funnily enough, Alice isn't usually the most expensive figure in a set. It’s almost always the Mad Hatter or the Caterpillar. Why? Because their designs are more complex. More bits to break. Fewer made. If you’re looking at an antique set, always check the ears on the White Rabbit. If they’ve been glued back on, the value drops by 70%. Easily. Honestly, it's brutal.
Identifying the real deal
- Check the base markings. Royal Doulton, Beswick, and Wade Whimsies always have a clear stamp. If it's blurry or missing, walk away.
- Weight matters. Resin feels cold and heavy. Cheap PVC feels light and "hollow."
- The "Tenniel" Test. Does the figure look like a cartoon, or does it look like a 19th-century sketch? The latter usually appeals to the "high-end" literary collectors.
- Box condition. For modern Funko Pops or Medicom figures, the box is 50% of the price. Rip the tab? You just lost half your investment.
Why we can't stop buying them
Maybe it’s because Wonderland is a nightmare we actually enjoy. It’s nonsense made manifest. Owning an Alice in Wonderland figure is like owning a piece of a dream that doesn't make sense. You’ve got the Red Queen screaming about heads and a cat that disappears. It's chaotic.
Psychologically, these figures represent a refusal to grow up. Or maybe they represent the realization that the adult world is just as nonsensical as Wonderland. Either way, they look great on a bookshelf next to a first edition.
👉 See also: Why T. Pepin’s Hospitality Centre Still Dominates the Tampa Event Scene
In the 1990s, American McGee’s Alice (a video game) turned the aesthetic on its head. Suddenly, Alice figures had blood on their aprons and carried butcher knives. It sounds edgy, but it opened up a whole new "Gothic" wing of the hobby. Now, you have "Dark Alice" collectors who wouldn't touch a Disney figure with a ten-foot pole. It’s a fragmented market. You have the "Grandma’s China Cabinet" collectors and the "Horror Gaming" collectors. They rarely talk to each other.
Spotting the fakes in 2026
The "Super-Fake" is real. With high-end 3D printing, people are churning out "vintage-style" figures that look sixty years old but were made last Tuesday in a garage.
How do you tell? Smell it. Old plastic has a specific, slightly sweet, or chemical degrade smell. New resin smells like a nail salon. Also, look at the paint. Vintage figures were hand-painted by people working long shifts; the lines aren't perfect, but they have a "flow." Machine-painted fakes are often too perfect, or they have "pixelated" edges from digital printing processes.
If you’re buying a "Pre-War" Alice, you need to see crazing. Crazing is those tiny, spider-web cracks in the glaze of ceramic. It’s hard to fake convincingly. If a 100-year-old figure looks shiny and smooth like a new iPhone, it’s probably a reproduction. Or it was kept in a vacuum-sealed chamber, which... let’s be real, it wasn't.
Starting your own Wonderland collection
If you're just getting into this, don't start by chasing the $2,000 rarities. You’ll get burned.
✨ Don't miss: Human DNA Found in Hot Dogs: What Really Happened and Why You Shouldn’t Panic
Start with the Wade Whimsies. They’re these tiny, solid porcelain figures that were originally given away in boxes of Red Rose Tea. They’re charming, they’re authentic, and you can usually find them for under $15. They give you a feel for the material and the history without requiring a second mortgage.
Another great entry point is the Disney Traditions line by Jim Shore. They mix the Disney designs with a "folk art" carved wood look. They aren't "rare," but they hold their value incredibly well because they’re sturdy and look fantastic under LED shelf lighting.
Basically, decide your "vibe" first. Are you a book person? A movie person? A dark-fantasy person? Once you pick a lane, the Alice in Wonderland figure world becomes a lot less overwhelming.
Essential next steps for collectors
- Join the British Alice in Wonderland Society. Even if you're in the US or elsewhere. They have the best archives on obscure merchandise history.
- Get a UV flashlight. Shine it on "vintage" porcelain. Modern repairs and glue glows differently than original 19th-century materials.
- Audit your shelves. Sunlight is the enemy. It will bleach the blue right out of Alice's dress in six months if you aren't careful. Use UV-protected glass cases if you're serious.
- Verify the "Limited Edition." If a company says "1 of 5000," that's not actually rare. If they say "1 of 50," that’s a trophy. Know the difference before you pay "trophy" prices.
The hobby of hunting for the perfect Alice in Wonderland figure is a rabbit hole in itself. You start looking for one little statue for your desk, and three years later, you're arguing with a stranger on a forum about whether a certain 1920s figurine used lead-based paint or not. It's a wild ride. Just remember: if the deal feels too good to be true, the Jabberwocky is probably lurking nearby.
Keep your eyes on the auction houses like Christie's or specialized toy auctions like Hake's. Sometimes, a piece of history slips through the cracks because it was labeled as "generic blonde girl figurine." That’s where the real wins are. Happy hunting.