Fog so thick you couldn't see your own hand. That was New York City on July 28, 1945. People on the ground heard a roar. It wasn't the usual city noise. It was the screaming engine of a B-25 Mitchell bomber. Then, a bone-shaking thud. The airplane crash Empire State Building disaster wasn't a thriller movie plot; it was a horrific accident that happened right in the heart of Manhattan.
Most people today think of 9/11 when they imagine a plane hitting a skyscraper. But this was different. It was wartime. The pilot, Lieutenant Colonel William F. Smith Jr., was a decorated combat veteran. He wasn't a terrorist; he was just a guy trying to get to Newark Airport in a "pea soup" fog that should have kept every bird on the ground. He was warned not to land. He tried anyway.
He missed the turn.
The Moment of Impact at 79 Stories Up
The B-25 crashed into the north side of the building. Specifically, it ripped into the 78th and 79th floors. Imagine working at your desk, maybe sipping a coffee, and suddenly an 11-ton bomber enters your office at 200 miles per hour. That is exactly what happened to the people working for the National Catholic Welfare Conference.
One engine flew straight through the building. It came out the other side, sailed across the next block, and landed on the roof of a penthouse on 33rd Street. It started a fire that gutted a sculptor’s studio. The other engine? It did something even more terrifying. It plummeted down an elevator shaft.
The building didn't fall. It didn't even lean. The Empire State Building was built with massive amounts of steel and limestone, designed to be the "Eighth Wonder of the World." While the impact was devastating, the structural integrity of the skyscraper held firm. It’s a testament to the engineering of the 1930s that a direct hit from a medium bomber couldn't bring it down.
👉 See also: What Really Happened With the Women's Orchestra of Auschwitz
The Miracle of Betty Lou Oliver
You can’t talk about the airplane crash Empire State Building story without mentioning Betty Lou Oliver. Her story sounds fake. It sounds like one of those "urban legends" your uncle tells at Thanksgiving. But it is 100% verified.
Betty Lou was a 20-year-old elevator operator. She was already injured from the initial crash—suffering from severe burns. Rescuers, trying to be helpful, put her in an elevator to get her down to the ground floor for medical attention. They didn't realize the cables had been weakened by the crash and the fire.
The cables snapped.
She fell 75 stories. Let that sink in. Seventy-five floors in a free-falling metal box. Most people would die from the shock alone, let alone the impact. But she survived. The air pressure in the shaft and the "spring" of the coiled cables at the bottom acted like a literal cushion. She had a broken back and broken legs, but she lived. She holds the Guinness World Record for the longest survived elevator fall. Honestly, it's the kind of luck that makes you wonder if some people just have a guardian angel on permanent duty.
Why the Pilot Didn't See the Building
Colonel Smith was a pro. He had flown dozens of missions in Europe. He wasn't some rookie. But the fog in NYC that day was deceptive.
✨ Don't miss: How Much Did Trump Add to the National Debt Explained (Simply)
He was flying from Bedford, Massachusetts. When he reached the New York area, the weather was abysmal. Air Traffic Control told him to stay put, but he requested clearance to continue to Newark. He was told, basically, "If you can see the ground, go for it." He thought he was over the East River. He was actually over Midtown.
- He was flying too low.
- He was disoriented by the "canyon effect" of the streets.
- He turned right instead of left after passing the Chrysler Building.
By the time he saw the Empire State Building loom out of the grey mist, it was too late. He tried to climb, but a B-25 isn't a fighter jet. It’s a heavy, sluggish beast at low speeds. He hit the 79th floor dead center. Fourteen people died that day—three in the plane and eleven in the building. It could have been hundreds if it had been a workday during a non-war year, or if the building hadn't been partially empty due to the Saturday schedule.
Engineering Lessons from the 1945 Crash
Following the airplane crash Empire State Building event, architects had to rethink everything. They looked at how the fire spread. Gasoline from the plane's tanks had cascaded down the stairwells and elevator shafts. This "firefall" was a nightmare for rescuers.
Actually, the fire was extinguished in about 40 minutes. That remains one of the highest structural fires ever successfully fought by the FDNY. They didn't have high-tech pumps back then; they had to rely on the building's own standpipe system.
It's kind of wild that the building opened for business on the floors not affected by the fire just two days later. On Monday morning, people were back at their desks, even with a gaping hole in the side of the skyscraper. They just boarded it up and kept moving. That’s New York for you.
🔗 Read more: The Galveston Hurricane 1900 Orphanage Story Is More Tragic Than You Realized
Modern Misconceptions and Comparisons
People often compare this to 9/11, but the physics are completely different. A B-25 Mitchell is tiny compared to a Boeing 767.
- B-25 Weight: ~20,000 lbs empty.
- 767 Weight: ~180,000 lbs empty.
- Fuel Capacity: The B-25 had about 800 gallons; the 767 had nearly 20,000.
The Empire State Building survived because the "fire load" wasn't enough to melt or significantly weaken the heavy steel girders. The World Trade Center towers were a different design entirely—"tube-frame" structures that reacted differently to intense, sustained heat.
Also, the Empire State Building is built like a fortress. Its stone cladding adds a layer of protection that modern glass-curtain walls just don't have. If you look at the photos from 1945, the hole looks like a clean puncture wound. The building just swallowed the plane.
What This Means for You Today
If you're a history buff or just someone visiting NYC, you can still see where the repairs were made if you look closely at the masonry, though it’s mostly seamless now. The tragedy led to the passage of the Federal Tort Claims Act of 1946. Before this, you couldn't really sue the federal government for accidents like this. The families of the victims pushed for change, and now citizens have a legal path to hold the government accountable for negligence.
Actionable Steps for History Enthusiasts:
- Visit the 86th Floor Observatory: While you're there, look at the historical exhibits. They often have photos of the 1945 damage.
- Check the FDNY Medal Gallery: The bravery of the firefighters that day is legendary. Seeing the equipment they used in the 40s gives you a real sense of how difficult that "40-minute knockdown" really was.
- Read "The Sky Is Falling" by Arthur Weingarten: If you want a deep, minute-by-minute account of the crash, this is the definitive book. He was a kid when he saw it happen, and he spent years researching the details.
- Research the Federal Tort Claims Act: If you're into law or civil rights, studying how this crash changed the legal landscape of the United States is fascinating. It’s one of those rare moments where a tragedy led directly to a major legislative shift.
The airplane crash Empire State Building incident serves as a reminder of both human error and human resilience. We often think our modern skyscrapers are invincible, or conversely, that they are incredibly fragile. The truth is usually somewhere in the middle, buried in the fog of a July morning in 1945.