Honestly, if you ask any serious sneakerhead to name the "Holy Trinity" of 1985 colorways, they’ll probably rattle off the Chicago, the Bred, and the Air Jordan 1 High Black Toe. It’s just how it is. But there is something inherently different about the Black Toe. While the Bred was "banned" and the Chicago was the on-court flagship, the Black Toe occupies this weird, legendary space in Nike's marketing history that feels almost more authentic because it’s the shoe Michael Jordan wore in the photos that eventually became the Jumpman logo. That’s heavy.
Most people don't realize how rare the original 1985 pair actually is compared to its siblings. It’s a masterpiece of color blocking. By swapping the red leather on the mudguard for black, Nike created a visual frame that makes the white mid-panel and red heel pop in a way that looks faster and sleeker. It’s a vibe. You’ve seen the iconic photo of MJ with his shoes slung over his shoulder—those were the Black Toes.
The 1985 Blueprint and Why It Hits Different
What makes the Air Jordan 1 High Black Toe so special is the balance. In the world of design, we talk about "weight." The "Bred" is heavy on the eyes because it’s so dark. The "Chicago" is bright and loud. The Black Toe is the middle ground. It uses the "Black Toe" color blocking—a term now used to describe any AJ1 with a black mudguard—to ground the shoe.
Back in '85, Peter Moore was basically guessing what would look good on camera. He nailed it. The leather quality on the original pairs was famously inconsistent, but the Black Toe always seemed to look the best with a bit of wear. It’s a shoe that demands to be creased.
Interestingly, there’s a historical quirk most people miss. In some of the earliest promotional shots, the shoe actually featured a black tongue instead of the white tongue we see on the retros. This "Black Tongue" sample is the white whale for collectors. It changes the whole dynamic of the shoe, making it look much more aggressive. However, the production version stayed with the white nylon tongue, providing that classic "Pop" that works so well with a pair of light-wash denim or track pants.
Tracking the Retros: 2013 vs. 2016 vs. Reimagined
If you’re trying to buy a pair today, you’re likely looking at the 2013 or 2016 releases. Or maybe you're eyeing the "Reimagined" rumors. Let’s get real about the differences.
The 2013 version was... fine. It had the "Nike Air" on the tongue, which was a big deal at the time because Jordan Brand had spent years putting the Jumpman logo there. But the shape? It was a bit boxy. The leather was a little synthetic-feeling. It didn't quite capture the soul of the 1985 silhouette.
📖 Related: Aussie Oi Oi Oi: How One Chant Became Australia's Unofficial National Anthem
Then 2016 happened.
The 2016 Air Jordan 1 High Black Toe is widely considered the gold standard for modern retros of this colorway. The shape was closer to the original "OG" cut. The leather was softer, tumbling slightly as you walked. If you look at the secondary market prices on platforms like StockX or GOAT, you'll see a massive gap between the '13 and the '16. Collectors know. They can see the difference in the heel curve and the height of the collar from a mile away.
Then we have the "Satin" version from 2019. It was a women’s exclusive that swapped the red leather for satin. People lost their minds. It was a polarizing move, but it showed that the Black Toe DNA is strong enough to survive even experimental material swaps.
The "Jumpman" Connection
You can't talk about this shoe without talking about the photo. Photographer Jacobus Rentmeester took a shot of Jordan for Life Magazine before he even signed with Nike. Jordan was wearing New Balance. Seriously.
When Nike signed him, they recreated the shot. This time, he was draped in Nike gear and laced up in the Air Jordan 1 High Black Toe. This silhouette—the legs spread, the ball held high—became the most famous logo in sports history. But the logo doesn't show the shoes. It’s a silhouette. Knowing that the shoes on his feet in that specific moment were Black Toes adds a layer of "if you know, you know" energy to the pair.
It’s the DNA of the brand. Every time you lace up a pair of Black Toes, you’re literally wearing the foundation of the Jordan empire. It’s not just hype. It’s history.
👉 See also: Ariana Grande Blue Cloud Perfume: What Most People Get Wrong
Style and Versatility: How to Actually Wear Them
The reason these stay in rotation while other shoes rot in boxes is the color palette. Red, white, and black. It’s the Chicago Bulls. It’s timeless.
Because the toe is black, the shoe doesn't look as "dirty" as a white-toed shoe might after a few wears. It maintains a crisp look.
- Casual: Baggy cargos or vintage-wash jeans. The Black Toe loves a wider leg opening that sits just at the top of the collar.
- Sporty: Classic mesh shorts and a white tee. Let the shoes do the talking.
- The "No-Go": Don't try to dress these up with a suit. It’s not 2011. Keep it authentic to the street heritage.
The Market Reality
Let's talk money. This isn't a cheap hobby. The Air Jordan 1 High Black Toe is a "blue chip" sneaker. It’s like buying gold or a vintage Rolex. It rarely goes down in value.
When rumors of a "Reimagined" Black Toe started circulating in 2024 and 2025, the market for the 2016 pairs took a slight dip, then stabilized. Why? Because purists want the classic leather. The "Reimagined" series often uses cracked leather or "aged" aesthetics to mimic a 40-year-old shoe. Some people love that "found in an attic" look. Others think it’s fake vintage.
Whatever your stance, the Black Toe remains one of the safest investments in footwear. It doesn't rely on a collaborator like Travis Scott or Virgil Abloh to be cool. It’s cool because it’s the Black Toe. Period.
Common Misconceptions
A lot of people confuse the Black Toe with the "Bred Toe."
They are not the same.
The Bred Toe has a red toe box. The Black Toe has a white toe box. It sounds like a small detail, but it completely changes how the shoe breathes visually. The white toe box makes the shoe feel more like a "sneaker" and less like a "boot."
✨ Don't miss: Apartment Decorations for Men: Why Your Place Still Looks Like a Dorm
Another myth? That Jordan wore these all the time. Actually, he didn't. He wore the Chicago and the Bred far more often in actual NBA games. The Black Toe was largely a promotional and photoshoot shoe. But because those photos were so ubiquitous on the walls of every kid in the 80s and 90s, the Black Toe became etched into our collective memory as the definitive Jordan 1.
What to Look For When Buying
If you're hunting for a pair right now, you need to be careful. The "replica" market has gotten scary good.
- The Wings Logo: On an authentic pair, the embossing should be deep and sharp. If it looks "puffy" or shallow, walk away.
- The Hourglass Shape: Look at the shoe from the back. It should swell at the top and bottom and pinch in the middle. Fakes are often straight and "boxy" like a brick.
- The Toe Box: It shouldn't be too thick. The "Swayze" or "thick toe" is a dead giveaway of a lower-quality production or a fake.
- The Tongue Tag: Check the font and the spacing of the "Nike Air."
Why the Black Toe Still Matters in 2026
We are currently in an era where "dad shoes" and technical runners are everywhere. Trends come and go. But the Air Jordan 1 High Black Toe is a constant. It’s a design that has survived four decades without looking dated.
It represents a moment in time when a skinny kid from North Carolina was about to change the world. It’s the intersection of basketball, hip-hop, and high-end design. Whether you're a 15-year-old just getting into shoes or a 50-year-old trying to reclaim your youth, this shoe works.
Actionable Steps for Collectors
- Check Your Size: AJ1s generally run true to size, but they are narrow. If you have wide feet, go up half a size, or you'll be in pain within an hour.
- Storage is Key: If you buy an older pair (like the 2013s), keep them in a cool, dry place. Humidity is the enemy of the glue.
- Authentication: Always use a secondary verification service. Don't rely on "receipts" from the seller—those are faked more often than the shoes themselves.
- Wear Your Shoes: The Black Toe looks better with age. The white panels will slightly yellow, the black leather will soften, and the shoe will develop a character that a brand-new pair just doesn't have.
There is no "perfect" sneaker, but the Black Toe is as close as it gets. It’s simple, historical, and looks good with almost anything. If you're building a collection, this isn't an option; it's a requirement.
Next Steps for Your Collection
If you are ready to pull the trigger on a pair, start by comparing the price points between the 2016 "OG" and the more recent "Reimagined" versions. If you prefer the pristine, classic look, save the extra cash for the 2016 release. If you like the "vintage" storytelling and the weathered aesthetic, the Reimagined series will provide a more "authentic" 1985 feel right out of the box. Always verify the seller's rating and ask for photos of the "Nike Air" tongue tag and the internal size stamp to ensure you're getting the real deal.