It was the photo heard ‘round the world—or at least across every tabloid desk from London to Los Angeles. In October 2020, Dominic West, the man we all knew as the charmingly problematic Noah Solloway from The Affair, found himself living out his own script. But this wasn't a premium cable drama. It was real life, captured in grainy paparazzi shots on a sun-drenched street in Rome.
People lost their minds.
You probably remember the images. West, then 50, and his The Pursuit of Love co-star Lily James, then 31, were spotted getting very comfortable over a shared scooter ride and a lunch that looked a lot more like a date than a professional meeting. There was neck-nuzzling. There was hair-stroking. And most notably, there was a distinct lack of a wedding ring on West’s finger.
The internet did what it does best: it spiraled.
The Rome Photos That Sparked the Affair With Dominic West Rumors
Let’s be real for a second. Celebrity scandals are a dime a dozen, but the affair with Dominic West caught fire because it felt so brazen. This wasn't a dark corner of a nightclub. This was broad daylight in Italy.
The pair were in town filming an adaptation of Nancy Mitford's novel. Ironically, the story is all about the messiness of love and human desire. Life imitating art? Maybe. But for Catherine FitzGerald, West’s wife of ten years and the mother of four of his children, it was likely just a nightmare.
The optics were terrible. James and West were seen zooming through the streets on a single electric scooter, her leaning back into him, his arms around her. At lunch, photographers caught him leaning in close, kissing her neck. To the casual observer, it didn't look like two coworkers discussing their lines. It looked like a full-blown romance.
Then came the silence. For 24 hours, the world waited for the inevitable "we're just friends" PR statement. It didn't come. Instead, we got something much weirder.
The Note on the Lawn: A PR Move for the Ages
If the Rome photos were the inciting incident, the "front lawn photo op" was the climax.
📖 Related: Brandi Love Explained: Why the Businesswoman and Adult Icon Still Matters in 2026
Most celebrities hide when they get caught. They hire a crisis manager, stay indoors for three weeks, and release a typed statement on a black-and-white Instagram story. Not Dominic West and Catherine FitzGerald. They opted for the bizarrely traditional.
They stepped out of their home in the Cotswolds, stood in front of a swarm of reporters, and shared a stiff, awkward kiss. Then, they handed out a piece of paper. It was hand-written.
"Our marriage is strong and we're very much still together. Thank you. Catherine and Dominic."
It was fascinatingly old-school. It felt like something out of a 1950s playbook, a desperate attempt to reclaim the narrative through sheer physical presence. But the public wasn't buying it. People pointed out that West was wearing the same clothes he’d been spotted in recently. Others noted the body language—FitzGerald looked pained, her hand stuffed into her pocket, while West managed a shaky grin.
Honestly, it was one of the most uncomfortable things ever broadcast on the morning news. It didn't make the rumors go away; it just made everyone wonder what was happening behind the closed doors of Glin Castle.
Why Lily James Stayed Silent
While West was playing the "happy husband" on his driveway, Lily James took a very different path. She vanished.
She canceled scheduled TV appearances on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon and Today. She was supposed to be promoting Rebecca, her new Netflix film, but the questions would have been exclusively about her personal life. She knew it. Her team knew it.
She eventually spoke to The Guardian months later, but even then, she was incredibly guarded. When asked about being at the center of a media storm, she simply said, "I'm not really willing to talk about that. There is a lot to say, but not now, I'm afraid."
👉 See also: Melania Trump Wedding Photos: What Most People Get Wrong
It was a smart move, even if it frustrated the gossip-hungry public. By staying quiet, she allowed the heat to stay on West. After all, he was the one with the ten-year marriage and the "strong" union to defend.
The "The Affair" Irony and the Public Backlash
You can't talk about the affair with Dominic West without mentioning the show that made him a household name. In The Affair, West played a man who destroys his life and his family's peace for a fling with a younger woman in a seaside town.
The parallels were too juicy for the internet to ignore. Twitter was flooded with memes about "method acting."
But beneath the jokes was a real conversation about gender double standards. As is often the case, the "other woman" bore the brunt of the vitriol. James was labeled a "homewrecker" in the British tabloids, while West’s behavior was often framed through the lens of a "mid-life crisis" or a momentary lapse in judgment.
It’s a pattern we see constantly. The married man gets a pass or a "redemption arc" via a public kiss with his wife, while the single woman sees her reputation dragged through the mud and her professional work overshadowed by her dating choices.
The Aftermath: Did the Marriage Actually Survive?
Surprisingly, yes. Or at least, it appears so.
In the years since the Rome incident, West and FitzGerald have remained together. They are still seen at events. They still live at Glin Castle. In a 2024 interview with The Times, West finally addressed the scandal with a level of bluntness that took people by surprise.
He described the period as "absurd" and "deeply stressful" for his wife. He didn't deny what happened, but he didn't exactly offer a groveling apology either. He seemed more annoyed by the media's obsession with it than anything else.
✨ Don't miss: Erika Kirk Married Before: What Really Happened With the Rumors
"I hesitate to speak on behalf of my wife," he said, "but we do joke about it sometimes."
That's a wild thing to say to a reporter, isn't it? It suggests a couple that has moved past the crisis by leaning into a sort of dark, shared humor. Or perhaps it’s just the defensive mechanism of a man who has spent his entire career in the spotlight.
The Impact on Careers
Lily James’s career didn't miss a beat. She went on to star as Pamela Anderson in Pam & Tommy, a role that earned her critical acclaim and an Emmy nomination. If anything, the scandal proved that she could weather a massive PR storm and come out the other side as a powerhouse actress.
Dominic West moved on to play Prince Charles in The Crown. The irony of him playing another famous husband caught in a high-profile cheating scandal was lost on absolutely no one.
What We Can Learn From the Dominic West Scandal
Celebrity culture is a hall of mirrors. What we see—the photos, the lawn statements, the "no comments"—is only ever a fraction of the truth.
When you look back at the affair with Dominic West, the real story isn't just about a mistake made in Rome. It’s about how fame handles crisis. It’s about the performative nature of celebrity marriages and the brutal way the public treats women in these scenarios.
If you're following a similar story today, remember a few things:
- Photos don't tell the whole story, but they usually tell a story. A "neck kiss" is rarely a misunderstanding of perspective.
- PR moves are often transparent. If a couple who never posts about each other suddenly does a photoshoot on their lawn, things are probably not "fine."
- The "Other Woman" narrative is tired. Focus on the person who actually made the vows.
- Silence is often the best strategy. Lily James’s refusal to engage likely saved her career from being defined by a single weekend in Italy.
The saga of Dominic West and Lily James eventually faded, replaced by the next cycle of Hollywood drama. But it remains a fascinating case study in how to—and how not to—handle a very public mess. It was a moment where the line between television drama and reality blurred so much you couldn't tell them apart. And honestly? That's probably why we're still talking about it years later.
If you want to understand the modern celebrity landscape, look at the way this was handled. It wasn't about truth; it was about management. And in the end, everyone just went back to work.