You remember that 2015 feeling, right? The "Save the Cheerleader" nostalgia was hitting hard. NBC decided to bring back its most chaotic superhero franchise with a miniseries that promised to fix the messy ending of the original show. But when people tuned in, the first thing they noticed wasn't just the updated special effects—it was the faces. The actors in Heroes Reborn were a weird, fascinating mix of "Who's that kid?" and "Wait, isn't that Chuck?"
Honestly, the casting was a gamble. You had Jack Coleman holding down the fort as the legendary Noah Bennet, but the rest of the ensemble was basically a blank slate for a new generation. Some of these actors went on to huge things, while others kind of vanished into the TV ether. Let’s get into who actually made the cut and why the cast list looks so different from the 2006 glory days.
The Man in the Horn-Rimmed Glasses is Back
If Jack Coleman hadn't signed on, this show probably wouldn't have made it past the pitch meeting. He’s the glue. As Noah Bennet (HRG), Coleman had to carry the emotional weight of a world that had moved on from his daughter, Claire.
It’s actually pretty wild when you think about it. The original show was built on the back of Hayden Panettiere, but she’s nowhere to be found here. The story says Claire died in a terrorist attack in Odessa a year before the show starts. So, Coleman is playing this version of Noah who’s half-grieving and half-clueless because his memory has been wiped. It’s a lot of brooding in dark rooms. He still wears those iconic glasses, though, which basically makes the character.
Why Zachary Levi Swapped Comedy for Killing
The biggest "get" for the new cast was definitely Zachary Levi. Most of us knew him as the lovable, bumbling nerd from Chuck. In Heroes Reborn, he did a complete 180. He played Luke Collins, a guy who—along with his wife Joanne (Judith Shekoni)—was literally hunting and murdering "Evos" (evolved humans) for fun and revenge.
💡 You might also like: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
Seeing Levi play a cold-blooded killer was jarring.
Luke was fueled by the loss of his son at the Odessa summit. But the twist? He eventually discovers he’s an Evo himself. He starts glowing. Literally. He has the power of heliokinesis, which is a fancy way of saying he’s a human solar battery. Levi’s performance was one of the few things critics actually liked. He brought a sense of genuine self-loathing to a guy who realized he had become the very thing he hated.
The New Generation: Tommy and Malina
Since the show was a "rebirth," they needed teenagers. Enter Robbie Kay and Danika Yarosh.
Robbie Kay played Tommy Clark. You might recognize him as the creepy Peter Pan from Once Upon a Time. Here, he’s a socially awkward kid who can make things disappear just by touching them. Except, he doesn't just make them vanish—he teleports them. Later, we find out he’s actually Nathan Bennet, the secret son of Claire Bennet. Yeah, the family tree in this show is a total nightmare to map out.
📖 Related: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
Then you have Danika Yarosh as Malina. She’s Tommy’s twin sister. While Tommy is hiding out in high school, Malina is up in the Arctic Circle training to save the world from a massive solar flare. Her power is basically "everything elemental." She controls the wind, the Northern Lights, and even trees.
Other Key Players in the Ensemble
- Kiki Sukezane (Miko Otomo): She was easily the coolest part of the show. She played a girl who could literally jump inside a video game called Evernow to rescue her father. She was "Katana Girl."
- Ryan Guzman (Carlos Gutierrez): He played a former soldier who takes up the mantle of a masked vigilante called El Vengador. Unlike most of the cast, Carlos didn't actually have powers at first—he just used a high-tech suit.
- Henry Zebrowski (Quentin Frady): He provided the conspiracy theorist energy. Quentin was the guy who badgered Noah Bennet into finding out what really happened on June 13th.
- Gatlin Green (Emily Duval): She was the "normal" person in the group, playing Tommy’s girlfriend and the moral compass of the show.
Where are the Original Heroes?
This is where fans got a bit salty. The actors in Heroes Reborn didn't include most of the heavy hitters. No Milo Ventimiglia (Peter Petrelli). No Zachary Quinto (Sylar).
We did get some cameos, though. Masi Oka returned as Hiro Nakamura for a few episodes, which was a huge deal because Hiro is the heart of the franchise. Jimmy Jean-Louis popped up as The Haitian, and Greg Grunberg did a brief stint as Matt Parkman. But the focus was clearly on the new kids.
According to creator Tim Kring, they wanted the show to be "elastic." He wanted it to be able to survive without the original stars. Whether that actually worked is still debated in fan forums today. Most people felt the absence of the old guard was a bit too noticeable.
👉 See also: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
The Legacy of the Cast
So, what happened after the 13 episodes ended?
Zachary Levi went on to become a literal DC superhero in Shazam!. Robbie Kay continued to work steadily in indie films and TV. Jack Coleman is still a king of the "Hey, it's that guy!" guest spots on procedural shows.
If you're looking to dive back into the series, don't expect a perfect continuation. Think of it more as a weird, experimental side quest. The actors did the best they could with a script that was trying to juggle about 50 different timelines at once.
If you want to track down what the cast is doing now, your best bet is to follow their social media or check out their recent projects on IMDb. Many of the younger actors like Danika Yarosh and Gatlin Green have moved into more grounded drama and film work. It’s always interesting to see how a "failed" or "limited" series like this acts as a springboard for talent.
Keep an eye on Zachary Levi’s upcoming projects if you want to see how much his range has expanded since his days as a sun-powered vigilante. You can also rewatch the original 2006 run to see just how much the tone shifted between the two iterations of the show.