The image is grainy. It’s blurry, dark, and shot from a distance that feels uncomfortably cold. But it’s him. In 1865, as the nation literally tore itself apart at the seams, a single photograph was snapped of the 16th President of the United States lying in state. It shouldn't exist. Secretary of War Edwin Stanton had explicitly banned any photography of the fallen president. He wanted the nation to remember the man as he was—the orator, the leader, the face on the penny—not a pale, lifeless body in a suit.
Yet, because of a rogue photographer and a stroke of historical luck, we have the abraham lincoln death photo. It stayed hidden for decades. It was locked away, forgotten, and then rediscovered in a basement like something out of a movie.
Most people think there are dozens of these photos. There aren't. There is exactly one confirmed photo of Lincoln in his casket. Everything else you see online is usually a recreation, a fake, or a photo of a different guy who just happened to have a beard in the mid-19th century.
Why the Only Confirmed Photo Was Hidden for 87 Years
The story behind this image starts on April 24, 1865. Lincoln’s body was in New York City's City Hall. Thousands were lining up to pay their respects. Jeremiah Gurney, a well-known photographer of the era, managed to get his equipment into the building. He had permission from the local authorities, but he definitely didn't have it from the federal government.
Gurney set up his camera on a balcony. He took a shot from a distance, showing the elaborate catafalque and the body of the president resting within it. When Stanton found out, he was livid. Honestly, "livid" is an understatement. He ordered the plates destroyed immediately. He wanted no record of the "theatre of death" to circulate among the public.
The Survival of the Glass Plate
You'd think that would be the end of it. It almost was. A single print survived because it was sent to Stanton himself to show him that the order had been carried out. That print eventually wound up in the hands of John Nicolay, Lincoln's former secretary. Decades passed. Generations changed. The photo sat in a box in the Illinois State Historical Library until 1952.
💡 You might also like: Wisconsin Judicial Elections 2025: Why This Race Broke Every Record
A 14-year-old boy named Ronald Rietveld found it. He was researching the Nicolay papers and stumbled upon a small, faded print. That discovery changed everything we knew about the visual history of the Lincoln assassination.
Dissecting the Visuals: What We Actually See
When you look at the abraham lincoln death photo, don't expect a high-definition portrait. The lighting in City Hall was terrible. The technology of 1865 required long exposure times. Because of this, the features of Lincoln’s face are soft and indistinct.
- The perspective: It’s an "aerial" view from a balcony.
- The subject: You can see the dark suit, the white shirt, and the signature beard.
- The atmosphere: The room is draped in heavy black mourning cloth, which swallows the light.
If you see a photo where Lincoln’s eyes are closed and he looks like he's sleeping in a high-res close-up? That’s not him. It’s usually the "Hoffman" photo or a well-known fake. People love to share those on social media because they’re more "shocking," but they lack the historical weight of the Gurney original.
The "Other" Photo: The Controversy of the 1991 Discovery
In the early 90s, the history world got rocked again. A new image surfaced, claiming to be a second, much closer death photo. This one shows a man who looks remarkably like Lincoln, lying on what appears to be a bed or a low table, with a visible head wound.
It was found by a man named Gene Smith in an old family album. He claimed it was taken by a photographer named Henry Ulke, who lived in the boarding house where Lincoln died. This is where things get messy. Historians are split. Some, like the famous Lincoln scholar Harold Holzer, have been deeply skeptical. They point out that the facial structure doesn't perfectly match the life masks taken of Lincoln just months before his death.
📖 Related: Casey Ramirez: The Small Town Benefactor Who Smuggled 400 Pounds of Cocaine
Others argue that the trauma of the gunshot and the subsequent medical "probing" by doctors would have distorted his features enough to explain the discrepancies. Honestly, we might never know. Without a clear chain of custody—what historians call "provenance"—it remains a fascinating "maybe."
Why We Are Still Obsessed With This Image
Lincoln was the first "photographic" president. We have dozens of photos of him throughout the war. We see him age a decade in four years. We see the lines deepen around his eyes. Because we feel like we "know" his face, seeing it in death feels like a voyeuristic intrusion. It’s the final frame of a tragedy we've all studied since second grade.
The abraham lincoln death photo represents the end of an era. It’s the literal end of the Civil War captured on a piece of light-sensitive glass. It wasn't meant to be seen, which of course makes us want to see it even more.
Authenticating Civil War Era Photography
If you ever find an old "death photo" in an attic, don't just assume it’s a president. Authenticating these things is a nightmare. Experts look at:
- The type of photo: Is it a daguerreotype, an ambrotype, or a salted paper print?
- The clothing: Does the lapel width match the specific year?
- The furniture: Can we identify the room based on the wallpaper or the chair legs?
In the case of the Gurney photo, the furniture was the smoking gun. The elaborate catafalque matched the sketches and descriptions of the New York City viewing exactly. That’s how we know for a fact it's him.
👉 See also: Lake Nyos Cameroon 1986: What Really Happened During the Silent Killer’s Release
Practical Steps for Researching Lincoln History
If you want to see the real deal, don't rely on a Google Image search. Most of the top results are incorrectly labeled.
- Visit the Abraham Lincoln Presidential Library and Museum: They hold the original Gurney print found in 1952. Their digital archives are the gold standard for accuracy.
- Read Harold Holzer’s work: Specifically, "The Lincoln Image." He is the leading expert on how Lincoln used photography to build his political brand.
- Check the provenance: If you find a "new" photo online, ask where it came from. If it doesn't have a direct line back to a known historical figure or archive, take it with a massive grain of salt.
The reality is that we only have one confirmed glimpse of Lincoln after he died. It's a haunting, distant, and lonely image. It perfectly captures the somber mood of a country that had just lost its "Father Abraham." It’s a reminder that even the most powerful figures in history are, in the end, just flesh and bone.
To truly understand the impact of Lincoln's image, look at his final studio portraits taken by Alexander Gardner. Compare the man in those photos—full of life and weariness—to the dark shape in the Gurney photo. The contrast tells the whole story of the American Civil War better than any textbook ever could. If you're looking to dive deeper, your best bet is to look into the National Archives' Civil War collection, where the official records of the funeral train and its stops are meticulously documented, providing the context that the abraham lincoln death photo alone cannot give.
Focus your research on verified institutional archives like the Library of Congress rather than speculative history forums. Verified provenance is the only way to separate historical fact from the sea of digital hoaxes that have circulated since the early days of the internet. By examining the Gurney photo through the lens of Secretary Stanton's censorship, you gain a clearer picture of the tension between public grief and the government's desire to control a leader's legacy.