September 11, 2001, wasn't just about the smoke and the steel. It was about the symbols that rose out of the dust when everything else was falling apart. You’ve seen the photo. It’s iconic. Three firefighters—Dan McWilliams, George Johnson, and Billy Eisengrein—hoisting a 9 11 American flag over the twisted wreckage of the World Trade Center. Thomas E. Franklin captured that moment for The Record, and suddenly, that specific piece of fabric became the soul of the country.
But here is the thing most people don't realize. The flag in that photo? It vanished.
It literally disappeared for over a decade. While the world looked at posters and postage stamps of that flag-raising, the actual physical object was gone, replaced by a fake that sat in plain sight for years. It’s a wild story involving a yacht, a mysterious man named "Brian," and a forensic investigation that felt more like a cold-case murder mystery than a search for a piece of nylon.
Where did the original flag actually come from?
Most people assume the flag was some official government property or part of the Port Authority’s kit. Nope. It was actually stolen—well, "borrowed"—from a yacht. Specifically, a 130-foot yacht named the Star of America, owned by Shirley Dreifus and her late husband, Spiros Kopelakis. The boat was docked at North Cove Marina.
McWilliams just saw it, took it, and brought it to the site.
He didn't ask. He just knew they needed something to show they were still standing. The yacht was covered in soot, and the flag was one of the few things that looked right. When they raised it on that pole, it wasn't a ceremony planned by a PR team. It was raw. It was messy. The pole wasn't even a flagpole; it was just a piece of debris sticking out of the ground at a weird angle.
The Great Switcheroo
By the time the flag was supposed to be returned or put in a museum, something felt off. On September 23, 2001, the city held a massive prayer service at Yankee Stadium. They brought out "the flag." But when Shirley Dreifus saw it later, she knew immediately.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Air France Crash Toronto Miracle Still Changes How We Fly
"This isn't my flag," she said.
The original flag from the yacht was 5 feet by 8 feet. The one being paraded around at the World Series and the Super Bowl was significantly larger. Nobody listened to her at first. People thought she was just grieving or confused. But she was right. For years, the "official" 9 11 American flag that people were saluting was a 10-by-19-foot impostor.
How the 9 11 American flag finally came home
For thirteen years, the real flag was just... gone. It probably would have stayed that way if it weren't for a TV show. In 2014, the History Channel aired a program called Lost History. They did a segment on the missing flag.
A few days later, a guy walked into a fire station in Everett, Washington.
He called himself "Brian." He had a plastic bag. Inside that bag was a flag. He told the firefighters he had seen the show and thought he had the real thing. He claimed he’d been given the flag by a National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) employee who had received it from a 9/11 widow.
The story sounded shaky. "Brian" disappeared and was never heard from again, but the flag remained.
🔗 Read more: Robert Hanssen: What Most People Get Wrong About the FBI's Most Damaging Spy
Proving the impossible
The Everett Police Department didn't just take his word for it. They treated it like a crime scene. Detective Jim Massaro and his team spent months on this. They brought in a forensic scientist named William Randle.
They did things you wouldn't believe:
- They analyzed the dust.
- They looked at the chemical composition of the grit embedded in the fibers.
- They compared it to the "Ground Zero dust" samples.
- They checked the hardware.
The Star of America had specific brass snaps on its halyard. The flag Brian turned in had those exact snaps. But the clincher was the photo itself. Using high-resolution scans of Thomas Franklin’s original 2001 photograph, they matched the weave and the specific way the flag had been tethered.
It was a match. The 9 11 American flag had traveled 3,000 miles across the country and sat in someone's house for a decade before finally being identified.
Why we still obsess over this piece of cloth
Symbols matter because they give us a place to put our feelings. On 9/11, everyone was feeling a million things at once—fear, anger, total confusion. That flag gave people a focal point. It was a visual "we're still here" message.
If you go to the 9/11 Memorial & Museum in Lower Manhattan today, you can see it. It’s behind glass. It looks a little worn, a little faded, but it’s there. It’s not just about the fabric; it’s about the fact that it came back. It was lost, just like a lot of our sense of security was lost that day, and finding it felt like a tiny, necessary win.
💡 You might also like: Why the Recent Snowfall Western New York State Emergency Was Different
Common Misconceptions
- Myth: The flag was destroyed in the collapse. Truth: It was raised after the towers fell, taken from a nearby boat.
- Myth: Rudy Giuliani knew it was a fake. Truth: There is no evidence of a conspiracy; in the chaos of the weeks following the attacks, items were moving fast and records were terrible.
- Myth: The original flag is at the Smithsonian. Truth: It is permanently housed at the National September 11 Memorial & Museum in New York City.
Technical Details of the Flag
The original flag is a standard 5'x8' outdoor nylon flag. It’s surprisingly lightweight. When you see it in person, the first thing you notice isn't the size—it's the texture. It still carries the weight of that day, quite literally, in the form of microscopic debris that couldn't be cleaned off without destroying the integrity of the artifact.
Preserving the legacy
If you're looking to honor the history of the 9 11 American flag or educate others about it, there are better ways than just buying a commemorative sticker.
First, visit the 9/11 Memorial website. They have an incredible digital archive that tracks the movement of various artifacts from the site. It’s not just the flag; they have fire trucks, personal belongings, and even the "Survivor Tree."
Second, read The 9/11 Commission Report. It sounds dry, but it provides the necessary context for why these symbols became so vital. It explains the failures and the heroism in a way that makes the flag's presence at Ground Zero even more meaningful.
Third, if you’re a teacher or a parent, focus on the story of the recovery. The fact that the flag was lost and found is a lesson in forensic science and persistence. It shows that history isn't just something that happened in the past—it's something we are constantly rediscovering and verifying.
Real-world steps for remembrance
To truly engage with this history, you should consider these actions:
- Support the 9/11 Memorial & Museum: They are a non-profit. They rely on donations to keep these artifacts preserved in climate-controlled environments so they don't rot away.
- Research Local Tributes: Many towns across the U.S. have pieces of World Trade Center steel or local versions of 9/11 flags. Go find yours. See the names attached to it.
- Verify your sources: When buying "commemorative" items online, check if the proceeds actually go to first responder charities or the memorial itself. A lot of people profit off the 9 11 American flag without giving anything back to the community that bled for it.
- Watch the documentary "The Flag": This film by Michael Tucker and Petra Epperlein goes deep into the hunt for the missing flag. It’s the best way to see the forensic process in action.
The flag isn't just a decoration. It’s a witness. It saw the worst day in modern American history, went on a weird 13-year road trip, and finally found its way back to where it belongs. That’s a story worth remembering every time you see those stars and stripes.