Oakmont Country Club is a monster. Ask any pro who has stepped onto those twitchy, lightning-fast greens in Pennsylvania, and they’ll tell you it’s probably the hardest test in the world. But back in June 2016, the course wasn't the only thing giving players a headache. The USGA—the guys who actually run the tournament—nearly turned the 2016 US Open golf championship into a total circus. It was messy. It was confusing. Honestly, it was a bit of a disaster for the sport's image, even if it did give us one of the most resilient major championship performances ever.
Dustin Johnson won. You probably remember that. But the way he won, with a looming penalty hanging over his head for the entire back nine, is something that still gets talked about in locker rooms today.
The Rule That Almost Broke the Tournament
Let's set the scene. It’s Sunday. The pressure is suffocating. Dustin Johnson, who at that point had a reputation for "choking" in big moments—think the 2010 US Open at Pebble Beach or the 2015 heartbreak at Chambers Bay—is finally looking like the alpha. He’s striking it pure. Then, he gets to the fifth green.
He’s standing over a par putt. He makes a couple of practice strokes. As he’s preparing to address the ball, it moves. Just a tiny, microscopic wiggle. DJ immediately steps back. He tells the walking official, "I didn't address it. I didn't cause it to move." The official on the ground agrees. Everything seems fine. Play continues.
But then, the USGA officials in the video booth started squinting at monitors.
About seven holes later, while DJ is on the 12th tee, a USGA official approaches him. They basically tell him, "Hey, we might penalize you a stroke for that ball moving on the fifth. We aren't sure yet. We’ll decide after the round."
Can you imagine?
Imagine playing the final six holes of the 2016 US Open golf championship not knowing what your actual score is. Are you up by two? Or just one? It was a psychological nightmare. Even the fans in the gallery were booing when they realized what was happening. It felt like the rulebook was being used as a weapon rather than a guide.
👉 See also: Sammy Sosa Before and After Steroids: What Really Happened
Why Everyone Was So Mad
The golf world went nuclear on social media. This wasn't just some niche controversy; it was a full-scale revolt. Legends of the game didn't hold back.
- Jordan Spieth called it a "joke."
- Rory McIlroy was even more blunt, tweeting that it was "ridiculous."
- Tiger Woods voiced his frustration with the lack of clarity.
The problem wasn't just the rule itself (Rule 18-2/0.5 for the nerds out there), it was the timing. By not making a definitive ruling right then and there on the 5th hole, the USGA put the entire leaderboard in limbo. Shane Lowry, who started the day with a four-shot lead and was struggling, didn't know how much ground he actually had to make up. Scott Piercy and Sergio Garcia were in the dark too. It felt amateurish for a "Major."
Honestly, the USGA looked out of touch. They were trying to be so precise with high-definition slow-motion replays that they forgot about the spirit of the game. If the player and the official on the spot said nothing happened, why go hunting for a crime 45 minutes later?
Dustin Johnson's Redemption
If there is a silver lining to the 2016 US Open golf saga, it’s that DJ proved he’s a machine. Most players would have crumbled. Most would have spent the rest of the round arguing with officials or venting to their caddie.
Dustin just shrugged.
He played some of the most clinical golf seen at Oakmont. On the 18th hole, facing one of the most difficult approach shots in golf, he striped a 6-iron to within a few feet. He made the birdie. He didn't just win; he won by enough that the inevitable one-stroke penalty the USGA slapped on him in the scoring tent didn't even matter.
His final score was 276 (-4). Without the penalty, it was -5. The next closest guys—Jim Furyk, Scott Piercy, and Shane Lowry—were all at -1. He beat the field and the officials.
✨ Don't miss: Saint Benedict's Prep Soccer: Why the Gray Bees Keep Winning Everything
The Oakmont Factor
We can't talk about the 2016 US Open golf tournament without mentioning the dirt. Oakmont is famous for its "Church Pews" bunker, but it’s the greens that really ruin lives. They are kept at a speed that would be illegal at your local muni. Because they were so fast and the weather had been hit-or-miss with rain delays, the surfaces were incredibly sensitive.
That’s likely why the ball moved on DJ in the first place. When greens are that slick, a heavy gust of wind or even a vibration can nudge a ball. The USGA’s insistence that DJ "caused" it was based on the idea that it happened right after he grounded his putter near the ball, but the footage was far from conclusive.
What Changed After 2016?
The backlash was so severe that it actually forced the hand of the R&A and the USGA. They realized they couldn't have another "DJ situation" happen on live television.
By 2017, they introduced a new local rule that eliminated the penalty for accidentally moving a ball on the putting green. If it’s accidental, you just put it back and move on. No drama. No post-round interrogations. It’s often called the "Dustin Johnson Rule." It’s rare that a single player’s misfortune leads to a fundamental shift in how the game is governed, but that's how big of a mess Oakmont was.
The Real Legacy of the Tournament
When people look back at the 2016 US Open golf results, they see DJ’s first major. They see a guy who finally got the monkey off his back. But for those who watched it, the memory is more about the tension between the players and the governing body.
It was the moment professional golf realized that technology (super-slo-mo replays) could actually hurt the viewer experience if not managed properly.
Key Takeaways and Facts from Oakmont:
🔗 Read more: Ryan Suter: What Most People Get Wrong About the NHL's Ultimate Survivor
- Dustin Johnson won with a total of 276.
- Shane Lowry blew a 4-shot lead in the final round, shooting a 76.
- Oakmont played as a Par 70, and only four players finished under par.
- The weather was a huge factor early on, with massive storms forcing a stop-and-start schedule for the first two days.
- Andrew "Beef" Johnston became a cult hero during this tournament, finishing T54 but winning over the fans with his personality.
How to Apply the Lessons of 2016 Today
If you're a competitive golfer or just someone who plays for stakes on the weekend, the 2016 US Open actually offers some pretty solid advice for your own game.
First, know the updated rules. You won't get penalized for an accidental ball movement on the green anymore—just make sure you replace it. If you don't replace it, that’s where the strokes start adding up.
Second, look at DJ’s mental approach. He didn't let the uncertainty of the penalty affect his swing. He focused on the next shot. In golf, as in life, you're going to get some "bad bounces" or unfair rulings from the universe. If you spend your energy complaining to the "official" (or your playing partners), you've already lost.
Lastly, if you ever get the chance to play Oakmont, bring your best putting stroke. And maybe don't ground your putter too close to the ball. Just in case.
To truly understand the impact of this event, you should watch the highlights of DJ’s final approach on 18. It’s a masterclass in ignoring the noise. The 2016 US Open wasn't perfect, but the right winner stood on the 18th green at the end.
For those looking to dive deeper into the technical changes that followed, check out the USGA’s official ruling updates on ball movement. It’s a dry read, but it explains exactly why what happened to Dustin Johnson will likely never happen to another pro golfer again.