Winning two Super Bowls in a row feels like a dream until you wake up and realize the guy who won them for you is gone. That was the reality for the Denver Broncos when 1999 rolled around. John Elway had finally hung up the cleats, and honestly, everyone in Colorado was kind of in a state of collective denial. The 1999 Denver Broncos roster wasn't just a list of names; it was a group of guys trying to prove they weren't just "John's supporting cast."
Spoiler alert: It didn't go as planned.
The drop-off was massive. We’re talking about a team that went 14–2 in 1998 and then basically fell off a cliff to a 6–10 finish. People always blame the quarterback change, but when you look at who was actually on the field that year, the story is way more complicated than just "No more Elway."
Life After the Duke: The Quarterback Room
Brian Griese was the guy. Imagine the pressure. You're following a legend who just walked off into the sunset with a second ring. Griese was only 24, a second-year player out of Michigan who had spent his rookie year watching Elway.
He wasn't terrible, to be fair. Griese threw for 3,032 yards and 14 touchdowns. But he also threw 14 interceptions. The "clutch" factor just wasn't there. When things got tight, the team didn't have that feeling that they’d always find a way to win.
🔗 Read more: Liverpool FC Chelsea FC: Why This Grudge Match Still Hits Different
The depth behind him was... interesting.
- Bubby Brister: The veteran who many thought deserved the start after going 4–0 as a replacement in '98. He barely saw the field in '99 and ended up with a passer rating that makes you want to look away (30.6).
- Chris Miller: A guy who came out of a three-year retirement because of concussions. He actually started three games.
The Terrell Davis Tragedy
If Elway’s retirement was the first blow, the Week 4 injury to Terrell Davis was the knockout. TD was the reigning league MVP. He had just come off a 2,000-yard season. In a game against the New York Jets, while trying to make a tackle after an interception (seriously, why was he the one tackling?), he tore his ACL and MCL.
His season was over. Effectively, his career as a dominant force was over, too.
The running game didn't die, though. That’s the wild part about the Mike Shanahan era. A rookie named Olandis Gary stepped in and actually put up huge numbers. He rushed for 1,159 yards in just 12 games. It turns out the offensive line was still elite, even if the guy carrying the ball didn't have a gold jacket yet.
💡 You might also like: NFL Football Teams in Order: Why Most Fans Get the Hierarchy Wrong
The Offensive Staples
The names on the outside were still familiar. Rod Smith and Ed McCaffrey both crossed the 1,000-yard mark. It’s kinda crazy that Griese had two 1,000-yard receivers and a 1,000-yard rusher and still finished with a losing record.
Shannon Sharpe was there too, but he missed a chunk of the season with an injury. When your Hall of Fame tight end only catches 23 passes all year, your third-down conversion rate is going to suffer. It did.
A Defense in Transition
The 1999 Denver Broncos roster had some legendary names on defense, but they were getting old. Fast.
Bill Romanowski was still out there playing like a madman, recording over 100 tackles and three interceptions. Neil Smith and Alfred Williams were still holding down the ends, but the pass rush wasn't what it used to be.
However, one bright spot was Trevor Pryce. The man was a beast. He recorded 13 sacks that year, earning a Pro Bowl nod and a First-Team All-Pro selection. He was basically the only reason opposing quarterbacks felt any sweat.
📖 Related: Why Your 1 Arm Pull Up Progression Isn't Working (And How to Fix It)
The secondary had some issues. They brought in Dale Carter, a huge free-agent signing at the time, to pair with Ray Crockett. Carter was talented, but he didn't quite provide the shutdown presence the Broncos paid for.
Why the Season Actually Failed
It wasn't just the roster. It was the schedule. After winning the Super Bowl, the Broncos were handed the toughest strength of schedule in the league. They started 0–4. You can't start 0–4 in the NFL and expect to do much of anything.
They lost close games. Five of their losses were by one score. If Elway is under center, maybe they win three of those? Probably. But the 1999 Denver Broncos roster was a shell of the 1998 version, not just because of the talent, but because the aura of invincibility was gone.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Historians
If you're looking back at this specific era of Denver football, here is how to view the 1999 roster without the rose-tinted glasses:
- Study the O-Line: If you want to understand why Olandis Gary succeeded, look at the tape of Tom Nalen and Mark Schlereth. Their zone-blocking scheme was years ahead of its time.
- The Injury Impact: Realize that the 1999 Broncos had 10 players on Injured Reserve, including cornerstones like Davis and Sharpe. It wasn't just a "bad" team; it was a decimated one.
- The Griese Era: Don't dismiss Brian Griese entirely. He actually made the Pro Bowl in 2000. 1999 was a "growing pains" year that paved the way for a playoff return the following season.
- Draft Value: Look at Al Wilson. The rookie linebacker from Tennessee was a hit right away. He became the heart of the defense for the next decade.
The 1999 season serves as a brutal reminder that in the NFL, your window can slam shut much faster than you think. One retirement and one knee injury turned a dynasty into a basement dweller in less than twelve months.