You ever buy a high-end cast iron skillet and then spend three hours googling whether a single drop of Dawn dish soap will strip the seasoning into oblivion? It’s a pan. It’s a chunk of pre-heated ore meant to sear steaks at temperatures that would melt a plastic spatula. Yet, we treat it like a delicate Victorian heirloom. We do this with everything. We buy "rugged" iPhones and then wrap them in three layers of polycarbonate until they look like bricks. We buy off-road SUVs with locking differentials and 35-inch tires just to crawl over a speed bump at the local Costco.
Honestly, we’ve lost the plot on utility. That’s what it’s made for—that simple phrase used to be a badge of honor for products that could take a beating. Now? It’s a reminder of the gap between a product’s potential and how we actually use it.
The Psychology of Over-Protection
Why are we like this? Psychologists often point to "loss aversion." The pain of scratching a $1,200 phone feels way worse than the joy of actually feeling the glass and steel the engineers spent years perfecting. We’re obsessed with resale value. We treat our lives like we’re just temporary stewards of objects for the next guy on eBay.
It’s kinda sad.
Take the Porsche 911. There are thousands of these machines sitting in climate-controlled garages right now with 400 miles on the odometer. They have flat-six engines capable of screaming at 7,000 RPM for hours. They have brakes that can stop time. But they’ll never see a track. They’ll never even see a rainy commute. When a mechanic sees a dirty, high-mileage 911, they usually smile. Because that’s what it’s made for. It’s made to be driven, not curated like a museum piece.
The "Workwear" Paradox
Look at Carhartt or Dickies. Twenty years ago, if you wore a chore coat, it was because you were actually doing chores. Like, fixing a fence in freezing rain chores. Today, the "workwear" aesthetic is a multi-billion dollar pillar of the fashion industry. You’ll see guys in Brooklyn wearing $300 selvedge denim jeans that have never touched dirt.
✨ Don't miss: The Long Haired Russian Cat Explained: Why the Siberian is Basically a Living Legend
There is a specific kind of "stolen valor" in clean gear.
- The Overbuilt Boot: Red Wing Heritage boots are designed to be resoled over decades. They’re stiff, heavy, and require a brutal break-in period. If you’re just wearing them to a climate-controlled office, you’re basically wearing lead weights for no reason.
- The Dive Watch: The Rolex Submariner is rated for 300 meters of depth. Most owners get nervous if they wear it in the shower.
- The Tactical Backpack: 1000D Cordura nylon can survive being dragged behind a truck. We use it to carry a MacBook Air to a coffee shop.
We love the idea of capability. We want to know that if a flash flood hits or we suddenly need to trek through the Alps, our gear won't fail. But by shielding our stuff from any hint of wear and tear, we miss out on the soul of the object. A scuffed-up tool has a story. A pristine one just has a price tag.
Breaking the "New Stuff" Anxiety
If you want to actually start living with your things, you have to embrace the first scratch. It’s liberating. Ask anyone who mountain bikes. That first rock strike against the carbon fiber frame is heartbreaking. But the second one? You don’t even notice. You start riding faster because you aren't worried about the paint anymore. You’re focused on the trail.
The same applies to professional creative tools. I know photographers who won't take their cameras out if there's a 10% chance of drizzle. Meanwhile, National Geographic shooters like Jimmy Chin are out there dangling off Everest with gear covered in ice and duct tape. Why? Because that’s what it’s made for. The camera is a means to an end, not the end itself. If the gear dies getting the shot, the gear did its job.
The Sustainability of Using Things Hard
We talk a lot about "buy it for life" (BIFL). But buying for life implies a contract. The manufacturer builds something sturdy, and you promise to actually put it to work. When we over-protect products, we often end up replacing them anyway because they become "obsolete" before they ever get "worn out."
🔗 Read more: Why Every Mom and Daughter Photo You Take Actually Matters
That’s a waste of resources.
Think about the old-school KitchenAid mixers. Those things are tanks. People inherit them from their grandmothers. They have grease stains, chipped paint, and they weigh more than a small child. They work because they were used constantly. Constant use keeps the internal lubricants moving. Letting a machine sit idle is often worse than running it every day.
How to Reclaim Your Gear
It starts with a mindset shift. You have to stop seeing your belongings as investments. Unless you are a professional art flipper, your shoes, your car, and your phone are depreciating assets. Their value isn't in what you can sell them for in three years; it's in the utility they provide right now.
- Strip the "Safety" Layers. Take the case off your phone for a day. Feel how thin it actually is. Use that fancy notebook you’ve been saving for "perfect" ideas to just scribble a grocery list.
- Push the Limits. If you bought a waterproof jacket, go for a walk in the rain. Don't carry an umbrella. See if the Gore-Tex actually works. (Spoiler: It’s kinda fun).
- Ignore the Resale Value. Stop worrying about the "next owner." You are the owner. Use the serrated knife on the crusty bread. Take the SUV on a dirt fire road.
- Maintenance over Protection. Instead of hiding your tools, learn how to fix them. Learn how to sharpen the knife, wax the boots, and change the oil. Maintenance is the middle ground between abuse and babying.
The Beauty of Patina
There is a Japanese concept called Wabi-sabi—finding beauty in imperfection and the natural cycle of growth and decay. In the world of high-end denim, this is called "fading." In the world of leather goods, it’s "patina."
A leather wallet that has turned dark and shiny from years in your pocket is objectively more beautiful than a new one in a box. It has shaped itself to you. It has become a unique object that couldn't belong to anyone else. When you see a tool that is worn down in exactly the spot where a human hand grips it, you’re looking at a successful product.
💡 You might also like: Sport watch water resist explained: why 50 meters doesn't mean you can dive
Everything we own is eventually going to end up in a landfill or a recycling center. That’s just the reality of entropy. In the meantime, the best thing you can do for the planet—and for your own sanity—is to use your stuff until the wheels fall off.
Next time you’re worried about getting a smudge on your "nice" gear, just remember: that’s what it’s made for. It’s not a tragedy when a tool gets used; it’s a tragedy when it stays perfect and forgotten.
Go out and make a mess. Scuff the boots. Use the "good" china for a Tuesday night frozen pizza. The gear can handle it. The question is, can you?
Actionable Next Steps
- Identify one "precious" object: Find something you've been "saving" for a special occasion or protecting too fiercely.
- Put it into the rotation today: Use that specific item for its intended purpose, regardless of how mundane the task is.
- Perform "Active Maintenance": Instead of buying a protective cover, buy a cleaning or repair kit (like leather conditioner or a whetstone) to ensure the item lasts through its actual use.
- Document the wear: Notice how the object changes over a month of real use. You'll likely find that the "damage" actually makes the item more comfortable or functional.