Everyone told them it was a bad idea. "That will never work," Marc Randolph’s wife said when he pitched the concept of a DVD-by-mail service. It’s the title of his book for a reason. It’s also a sentiment that defines the very DNA of Silicon Valley. Back in 1997, the idea of taking on Blockbuster—a multi-billion dollar behemoth with a store on every corner—using the United States Postal Service seemed like a joke.
People forget how slow the mail was. They forget how fragile DVDs were. Most of all, people forget that Netflix almost died a dozen times before it ever streamed a single frame of video.
The Pitch Nobody Wanted to Buy
Marc Randolph and Reed Hastings weren’t just dreaming. They were looking for a way to use the emerging internet to disrupt a physical market. But the logistics were a nightmare. To test if a disc could even survive the mail, Randolph and Hastings bought a classic 1950s-era postcard and a used CD (since DVDs weren't widely available yet) and mailed it to Hastings’ house in Santa Cruz. It arrived unbroken for the price of a first-class stamp.
That was the "aha" moment.
But a successful test doesn't make a business. When Randolph went around trying to get people to buy into the vision of That Will Never Work, he wasn't met with open arms. He was met with laughter. Investors looked at the math and saw a sinking ship. Why would anyone wait three days for a movie when they could drive five minutes to Blockbuster?
It’s easy to look back now and say it was obvious. It wasn't. At the time, Blockbuster had 9,000 stores. Netflix had a website and a pile of red envelopes.
When Blockbuster Laughed in the Room
One of the most famous stories in business history happened in 2000. Netflix was struggling. They were losing money fast, and the dot-com bubble had just burst. Randolph and Hastings flew to Dallas to meet with Blockbuster CEO John Antioco. They offered to sell Netflix for $50 million.
Antioco reportedly had to struggle not to laugh.
He saw Netflix as a niche "dot-com" play that would never scale. He thought the mail-order business was too small to care about. This is the ultimate example of a legacy giant being blinded by its own success. Today, Netflix is worth nearly $300 billion, and Blockbuster exists as a single franchise in Bend, Oregon, mostly for the nostalgia.
Honestly, it’s a cautionary tale about ego. When you’re at the top, you stop looking at the horizon. You start looking at your quarterly dividends. Randolph mentions in his memoirs that the rejection was actually a turning point. It forced them to stop looking for an exit and start looking for a way to survive.
The Subscription Pivot That Changed Everything
Originally, Netflix worked just like Blockbuster but through the mail. You rented a movie, paid a fee, and paid a late fee if you kept it too long. It was okay, but it wasn't revolutionary.
The breakthrough came when they shifted to the subscription model. No late fees. Keep the movie as long as you want. When you're done, mail it back, and we send the next one on your list.
🔗 Read more: Live Streaming Apps to Make Money: What Most People Get Wrong
This changed the psychology of the consumer. Suddenly, the "That Will Never Work" mantra started to fade. People loved the "queue." They loved the lack of friction. You weren't paying for a movie; you were paying for a service that ensured you always had something to watch on a Friday night.
Why Logistics Beat Content (At First)
We think of Netflix as a content company now. Stranger Things, Squid Game, the Crown. But for the first decade, they were a logistics company.
- They built a network of 50+ distribution centers.
- They worked with the USPS to automate the sorting of those iconic red envelopes.
- They perfected the "overnight" delivery window.
If you lived in a major city, you could mail a movie Monday and have a new one Wednesday. That efficiency is what killed the local video store. It wasn't the selection; it was the fact that Netflix made it effortless.
The Cultural Impact of the Netflix Mindset
Randolph’s philosophy is basically "Nobody knows anything." You can't predict what will work. You just have to test it. This is a massive departure from the way traditional corporations work, where everything is focus-grouped to death.
Netflix’s "Culture Memo" became famous for this reason. They hire "stunning colleagues" and give them immense freedom. No vacation tracking. No rigid expense reports. Just results. It’s a high-pressure environment, sure, but it’s what allowed them to pivot from DVDs to streaming in 2007, even though streaming threatened to destroy their existing DVD business.
Most companies are afraid to cannibalize themselves. Netflix did it on purpose.
What We Get Wrong About Innovation
We tend to think of innovation as a lightning bolt. It's not. It's a series of small, often embarrassing failures.
Randolph had dozens of ideas before Netflix. Some were for personalized shampoo. Some were for custom dog food. Most were terrible. The "That Will Never Work" idea only worked because they were willing to iterate daily.
✨ Don't miss: The Most Expensive Item at Walmart: Why a Six-Figure Watch Is Even There
In business school, they talk about "the pivot." In reality, a pivot feels like a panic attack. It’s realizing your current path leads to a cliff and having the guts to turn the wheel at 80 miles per hour.
The Streaming Wars and the New Reality
Now, everyone is trying to be Netflix. Disney+, Max, Hulu, Paramount+. The market is saturated. We’ve reached "peak TV."
Interestingly, the criticisms Netflix faces today are the same ones they faced in 1997. "They’re spending too much." "The model isn't sustainable." "Competition will kill them."
Yet, they keep evolving. They added games. They added an ad tier—something they swore they’d never do. They started cracking down on password sharing, which everyone said would cause a mass exodus. Instead, their subscriber numbers went up.
Actionable Insights from the Netflix Journey
If you’re trying to build something or change your career, the story of Marc Randolph and the early days of Netflix offers some pretty concrete lessons that aren't just "believe in yourself" fluff.
Don't wait for the perfect idea. Randolph and Hastings didn't start with a masterpiece. They started with a postcard in the mail. If you have an idea, find the cheapest, fastest way to test the core assumption. If you want to start a bakery, sell one loaf of bread to a neighbor first. Don't rent the storefront yet.
Focus on the friction. Netflix succeeded because Blockbuster late fees were annoying. They solved a specific pain point. Look for what people are complaining about in your industry. That’s where the money is.
Be willing to be wrong. The DVD-by-mail business is basically dead now. Netflix still sends a few discs, but it’s a relic. If Netflix had stayed a DVD company, they’d be a footnote in history. You have to be willing to kill your darlings to stay relevant.
The "Nobody Knows Anything" Rule. This is a famous quote from screenwriter William Goldman, but Randolph lives by it. No expert can tell you for sure if a product will fly. The only "expert" is the customer's credit card. Stop asking for permission and start looking for data.
Build for the long haul. Netflix lost money for years. Amazon did too. If you’re looking for a get-rich-quick scheme, you’re going to fold the moment someone laughs at you. You need enough conviction to survive the "That Will Never Work" phase, which usually lasts longer than you think it will.
✨ Don't miss: 380 Dollars in Rupees: What You’ll Actually Get After Fees and Inflation
Success isn't about having the best idea from day one. It's about being the last person to stop trying when everyone else has already gone home.