You think you know the story. You probably picture a long table, some buckled hats, and a peaceful hand-off of maize. Honestly, though? The reality of Thanksgiving Day in US history is much messier, more political, and significantly more interesting than the construction paper cutouts we made in second grade.
It wasn't a holiday for a long time. It was a series of sporadic "days of thanks" that didn't even involve turkey half the time.
👉 See also: The Real Story Behind Beautiful Women on Beach Photography and Why It Still Dominates Our Feeds
Most people point to 1621. That’s the "First Thanksgiving," right? Well, sort of. The Pilgrims at Plymouth and the Wampanoag people did share a harvest feast, but they didn’t call it Thanksgiving. To the Pilgrims, a "Day of Thanksgiving" was a somber religious event involving fasting and prayer, not a three-day party with venison and fowl. They were actually celebrating a successful harvest after a year of brutal starvation and death. It was a survival feast.
The Political Tug-of-War Over a National Holiday
For over two hundred years, Thanksgiving was a regional New England thing. Southerners basically ignored it. They saw it as a "Yankee" imposition. If you lived in Virginia in 1820, you weren't roasting a bird in late November; you were just working.
Enter Sarah Josepha Hale.
You might know her as the woman who wrote "Mary Had a Little Lamb," but she was also a powerhouse editor at Godey’s Lady’s Book. She spent 36 years—yes, nearly four decades—campaigning to make Thanksgiving Day in US calendars a permanent fixture. She wrote letters to five different presidents. She saw it as a way to stitch a fractured country back together as the Civil War loomed.
Abraham Lincoln finally listened in 1863. He didn't do it because he loved pumpkin pie. He did it because the Union was bleeding out, and he needed a national moment of "humiliation, penitence, and prayer." He set the date as the last Thursday in November.
Then came FDR.
In 1939, the country was still shaking off the Great Depression. That year, November had five Thursdays. Retailers freaked out. They told Roosevelt that if Thanksgiving stayed on the 30th, the Christmas shopping season would be too short. So, FDR moved it up a week. People were livid. They called it "Franksgiving." For a couple of years, the country was split—half the states celebrated on one day, and the other half celebrated on the original date. Eventually, Congress stepped in and fixed it to the fourth Thursday of November in 1941.
The Myth of the Menu
Let’s talk about the food. Everyone assumes the 1621 menu was a precursor to our modern spread. It wasn't.
- Turkey: Might have been there, but wild fowl like duck or goose was more likely the star.
- Potatoes: Nope. They were still considered weird tubers from South America and hadn't made it to New England gardens yet.
- Cranberry Sauce: Not a chance. Sugar was way too expensive and scarce for that kind of luxury.
- Pumpkin Pie: They had pumpkins, sure, but no butter or flour for a crust. They probably hollowed them out and filled them with milk and spices to make a sort of custard.
Edward Winslow, an actual attendee of the 1621 event, wrote in a letter that the Wampanoag brought five deer. So, the "First Thanksgiving" was mostly a venison barbecue.
Why the Wampanoag Perspective Matters
We can't talk about Thanksgiving Day in US culture without acknowledging that for many Indigenous people, this isn't a day of celebration. It’s a National Day of Mourning.
Since 1970, protesters have gathered at Cole's Hill in Plymouth to remind people that the arrival of Europeans signaled the beginning of a centuries-long genocide, land theft, and the erasure of culture. The 1621 alliance was a strategic political move for both the Wampanoag leader Massasoit and the Pilgrims. It wasn't about friendship; it was about survival in a shifting power landscape.
When you look at the primary sources, like William Bradford’s Of Plymouth Plantation, the tone is much more transactional than the storybooks suggest. Understanding this nuance doesn't mean you have to throw away your turkey, but it does add a necessary layer of honesty to the holiday.
Football, Floats, and the Consumer Machine
How did a day of prayer become a day of pass interference?
💡 You might also like: Short Shorts and Heels: Why This Polarizing Combo is Making a Massive Comeback
The first intercollegiate Thanksgiving football game happened in 1876. By the 1890s, it was a tradition. The Detroit Lions have played every Thanksgiving since 1934, thanks to a marketing stunt by owner George A. Richards who wanted to build a fan base in a baseball-obsessed city.
Then there’s the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade. It started in 1924, but back then, it was mostly Macy’s employees dressed in costumes with live animals from the Central Park Zoo. No giant balloons. Just lions and tigers and bears walking down 34th Street. It was purely a giant ad for the "World's Largest Store."
Modern Realities: The "Black Friday" Creep
For a long time, Thanksgiving was the "safe" holiday—the one that hadn't been totally bought by corporations. That changed with the rise of Black Friday.
The pressure on retail workers to show up on Thursday evening has sparked a massive counter-movement. We’ve seen a shift lately. Large retailers like REI and even Target have started closing their doors on the actual holiday again, realizing that "doorbusters" at 6:00 PM on a Thursday were destroying the very point of the day.
Health and the "Turkey Coma" Science
You’ve heard it: "The tryptophan in the turkey is making me sleepy."
It's basically a myth.
👉 See also: Why Your Box for Jewellery Storage is Probably Ruining Your Best Pieces
While turkey does contain tryptophan (an amino acid that helps produce serotonin), it doesn't contain more than chicken or beef. The reason you're passed out on the couch after the game is actually the massive load of carbohydrates. Stuffing, mashed potatoes, rolls, and pie cause a spike in insulin, which then allows that tryptophan to enter the brain more easily. Plus, most people are drinking wine and overeating. It’s the total caloric intake, not the bird.
Making the Day Mean Something
If you’re looking to get more out of Thanksgiving Day in US traditions, it helps to move beyond the superficial.
- Read the actual journals. Check out Mourt’s Relation or Bradford’s writings. It’s eye-opening to see the world through their eyes—the fear, the confusion, and the genuine desperation.
- Acknowledge the land. Use resources like Native-Land.ca to find out which Indigenous groups originally lived where you are currently sitting. It’s a small gesture that builds a more complete picture of history.
- Audit your food waste. The average American household throws away an incredible amount of food on this day. Planning better isn't just "green"—it's respectful to the effort that went into the harvest.
- Volunteer, but not just on Thursday. Shelters are often overwhelmed with volunteers on Thanksgiving Day but have no one the following Tuesday. If you want to help, sign up for a regular shift in December or January.
- Skip the "forced" gratitude. Instead of going around the table for a one-word answer, try writing a letter to someone who actually changed your life this year. Send it.
Thanksgiving is a complicated, beautiful, tragic, and deeply American mess. It’s a reflection of who we were and who we’re trying to be. Whether you're there for the cranberry sauce or the family drama, understanding the "why" behind the "what" makes the whole experience feel a lot less like a cardboard cutout and more like real life.