You’re standing in line at a local coffee shop. The person in front of you is wearing a faded olive-drab jacket with a unit patch on the shoulder. Maybe they have a "Veteran" hat on. Without thinking, you lean in and say, "Thank you for your service." They nod, give a polite, practiced smile, and move on. You feel like you’ve done something good. They feel... well, that’s the part we don't usually talk about.
Honestly, saying thank you for your service has become the default setting for American civilian-military interaction. It's the "How are you?" of the post-9/11 era. It is ubiquitous. It’s on billboards, whispered in airport terminals, and shouted at football games. But for a huge segment of the veteran population, those four words carry a weight that most civilians never stop to consider. It’s not that they aren't grateful for the support. It’s just that the phrase often feels like a conversation stopper rather than a bridge.
The Gap Between Intent and Impact
Most people mean well. Truly. When you say thank you for your service, you’re trying to acknowledge a sacrifice you didn't have to make. You’re recognizing that someone signed a contract that potentially required their life. That’s a big deal.
✨ Don't miss: Why Racist Jokes About Mexicans Still Poison the Online Landscape
But here is the catch.
For many veterans, the phrase feels hollow. Some feel it’s a "drive-by" gesture that allows the civilian to feel patriotic without actually engaging with the reality of what military service looks like. It’s easy to say. It’s much harder to ask about the transition back to civilian life, the struggle with the VA, or the difficulty of finding a job where your skills as a fire team leader don't seem to translate to a corporate spreadsheet.
Take the perspective of Sebastian Junger, author of Tribe. He’s spent years documenting the return of soldiers to society. Junger argues that our modern society is profoundly lonely compared to the tight-knit "tribal" units of the military. When a soldier returns and receives a polite thank you for your service, it can reinforce the feeling that they are an outsider being observed, rather than a member of the community being welcomed back in.
Is It a "Civilian Guilt" Reflex?
There is this theory floating around veteran circles. It’s the idea that the phrase is actually for the person saying it, not the person hearing it. We live in a country where less than 1% of the population serves in the military. That’s a massive divide.
If you didn't serve, you might feel a lingering sense of "I should have" or "I'm glad it wasn't me." Saying thank you for your service acts as a release valve for that tension. It’s a quick transaction. You give a compliment; they give a "you're welcome," and the social debt is paid.
But many vets would tell you they don't want your thanks. They want your understanding. They want you to know that "service" isn't always a series of heroic moments. Often, it’s years of boredom, followed by moments of intense stress, followed by the crushing realization that the world moved on while you were gone.
When the Phrase Becomes Awkward
Imagine being a veteran who walked away from the military with a less-than-stellar opinion of the missions they were sent on. Or someone who feels deep moral injury over things they saw or did. To that person, a chipper thank you for your service can feel like an endorsement of things they are still trying to process.
Then there’s the "hero" narrative.
When we use this phrase, we often project a specific image onto the veteran. We see a hero. But most veterans don't feel like heroes. They feel like people who did a job. Some did it well; some just tried to survive it. When you put someone on a pedestal with a blanket thank you, you're making it harder for them to be human, to be flawed, or to talk about the parts of the job that weren't so noble.
What to Say Instead
If thank you for your service feels a bit tired, what are the alternatives? Is there a better way to show respect without making things weird?
Actually, yeah.
- Ask about their job. Instead of the blanket thank you, try: "What did you do while you were in?" This treats them as an individual with a specific history rather than a mascot for the military.
- Acknowledge the transition. "How has the adjustment been since you got out?" This shows you realize that leaving the military is often harder than being in it.
- The "Welcome Home" approach. For Vietnam veterans especially, "Welcome home" carries a profound emotional weight that a standard thank you never will. It acknowledges the debt of the past without the political baggage.
- Do something. If you see a vet struggling with a heavy bag or if you're a business owner looking to hire, actions speak louder. Hire them. Mentor them. Don't just thank them.
The Commercialization of Gratitude
We’ve all seen the "Military Appreciation" nights at baseball stadiums. The jumbo-tron lights up, the music swells, and everyone stands to clap. It’s a nice moment. But if that’s where the support ends, it’s just performance.
Veterans see the disconnect. They see the "we support our troops" bumper stickers on cars that cut them off in traffic on the way to a VA appointment that’s been delayed for six months. They see companies using thank you for your service as a marketing slogan to sell trucks or insurance while those same companies have zero veteran outreach programs.
This isn't to say we shouldn't have public displays of gratitude. We should. But they need to be backed by something tangible.
Real Stories, Real Nuance
I remember talking to a former Marine who told me he hated the phrase because it reminded him of the friends he lost. To him, the "service" being thanked was a period of his life defined by grief. Every time a stranger said it, he was flashed back to a funeral in North Carolina.
On the other hand, some older veterans—especially those from the Korean War or WWII—genuinely appreciate the recognition. For them, it represents a shift in how the country treats its soldiers compared to the cold reception many received in the 60s and 70s.
The point is: it’s complicated.
💡 You might also like: New Jersey Weather: What Locals Know That Your App Probably Misses
Moving Beyond the Script
So, should you stop saying it? Not necessarily. If it’s coming from a place of genuine sincerity, most veterans will appreciate the sentiment even if the wording is a bit cliché. But don't let it be the end of the interaction.
The goal should be integration. We want veterans to feel like they are part of the fabric of our society, not a separate class of people we occasionally acknowledge with a verbal tip of the hat.
If you’re going to use the phrase thank you for your service, be prepared to follow it up. Be prepared to listen. If they don't want to talk, that’s fine too. But offering the space for a real conversation is a much higher form of respect than reciting a script.
Actionable Ways to Actually Show Support
If you want to move past the words and into actual support, here is how you do it. These aren't just feel-good suggestions; these are ways to bridge the civilian-military divide.
Educate yourself on the issues.
Read up on what’s actually happening with veteran healthcare and the PACT Act. Understand the challenges of "toxic exposure" and why so many veterans are fighting for benefits. When you know the issues, your "thank you" has teeth. You aren't just thanking them for the past; you're supporting their future.
Look at your hiring practices.
If you're in a position of power at work, look at how your company vets candidates. Many military resumes get tossed because HR software doesn't recognize "NCOIC of Logistics" as "Project Manager." Be the person who advocates for translating those skills.
Support local veteran-owned businesses.
Instead of just saying thank you for your service, put your money where your mouth is. Find the local coffee roaster, the mechanic, or the contractor who served and give them your business. This helps build the very community stability that many veterans miss when they leave the service.
Listen without judging.
If a veteran does decide to open up to you, don't feel the need to "fix" their experience or compare it to your own. You don't need to have an opinion on the war they fought in. You just need to hear them. Sometimes, being heard is the greatest "thank you" a person can receive.
Be specific in your gratitude.
If you know someone was a medic, thank them for the lives they saved. If you know they were a mechanic, thank them for the long hours in the heat. Specificity shows you’ve actually paid attention to who they are as a person.
The phrase thank you for your service isn't going anywhere. It’s part of our cultural lexicon now. But we can make it better. We can make it the beginning of a conversation instead of the end of one. Next time you see a vet, maybe start with a "Hello" or a "How’s your day going?" and see where it leads. You might find that a genuine human connection is worth a thousand scripted slogans.