Texas football is a religion, and the quarterback is the high priest. But if you think Texas Longhorns quarterback history is just a highlight reel of Vince Young running past USC defenders, you’re missing half the story. Honestly, the lineage of the "Signal Caller" in Austin is a chaotic, brilliant, and sometimes heartbreaking journey that stretches back over a century. It's about more than just the five-star recruits.
It’s about the guys who nobody expected to win.
Most fans today focus on the modern era. They see Quinn Ewers slinging it or Arch Manning waiting in the wings and think the program has always been this pass-heavy machine. It hasn't. For decades, the quarterback at Texas was basically a glorified fullback who happened to occasionally toss a "forward pass" to keep the defense honest.
The Pioneers and the Wishbone Wizardry
Before the glitz of the SEC, Texas was the king of the Wishbone. People forget that James Street, who played from 1967 to 1969, never lost a game as a starter. Not one. He went 20-0. Think about that. In an era where you were lucky to see five passes a game, Street was the ultimate floor general. He wasn't a stat stuffer. He was a winner who navigated Darrell K Royal’s complex triple-option with surgical precision.
And then there’s Bobby Layne.
If you want to talk about the true "Original" of Texas Longhorns quarterback history, it’s Layne. He played during the 1940s when players still wore leather helmets without face masks. He was a four-year starter—rare for that time—and led Texas to wins in the Cotton and Sugar Bowls. Layne wasn't just a football player; he was a legendary pitcher for the Longhorns baseball team too. He had that "it" factor before we even had a name for it. He eventually went on to win NFL titles with the Detroit Lions, proving the Texas QB pedigree was elite long before the modern draft era.
The Vince Young and Colt McCoy Peak
We have to talk about the mid-2000s. It was a fever dream for Longhorn fans. Vince Young wasn't just a quarterback; he was a force of nature. In 2005, he became the first player in FBS history to pass for over 3,000 yards and rush for over 1,000 in a single season.
📖 Related: Ryan Suter: What Most People Get Wrong About the NHL's Ultimate Survivor
That 2006 Rose Bowl against USC?
It’s still the greatest game ever played. Young’s 4th-and-5 scramble into the corner of the end zone is the defining image of the program. He finished his career 30-2. That’s a 93.8% winning percentage, which is just stupidly good.
Then came Colt McCoy.
A lot of people think Colt was just "Vince Lite." Wrong. Colt was a completely different animal. He was an absolute technician. While Vince beat you with pure athleticism, Colt dismantled you with accuracy. He still holds the record for most career wins by a Texas QB with 45. He won or shared the team MVP award all four years—the only player in school history to do that. His career passing total of 13,253 yards is a mountain that most current QBs can’t even see the top of.
The tragedy, of course, is the 2010 National Championship. Colt gets hit early, his shoulder goes numb, and Garrett Gilbert is thrust into the fire. Fans still wonder "what if" McCoy had stayed healthy for those four quarters against Alabama. It likely would have changed the entire trajectory of the program for the next decade.
The Dark Years and the Sam Ehlinger Grit
After McCoy left, the "Quarterback History" at Texas got... murky. There was a revolving door. David Ash had talent but couldn't stay healthy. Tyrone Swoopes and Jerrod Heard had moments but lacked consistency.
👉 See also: Red Sox vs Yankees: What Most People Get Wrong About Baseball's Biggest Feud
Then came Sam Ehlinger in 2017.
He wasn't the most polished passer, and he certainly wasn't the fastest. But he was a local kid who would run through a brick wall for the burnt orange. He brought respectability back. From 2017 to 2020, Ehlinger put the team on his back during some of the most "identity-less" years in Austin. He finished second only to McCoy in almost every major passing category. His 2019 Sugar Bowl performance against Georgia remains a high-water mark for a generation of fans who never saw Vince Young play.
The Sarkisian Era: Quinn Ewers and the Arch Manning Hype
Now we’re in the Steve Sarkisian era, and the vibe has shifted. It’s professional. It’s NFL-lite. Quinn Ewers arrived with the bleached mullet and the "perfect" recruiting rating, and honestly, he delivered. Leading Texas to the College Football Playoff in 2023 and a Big 12 title wasn't easy.
Ewers finished his college career with 9,128 passing yards and 68 touchdowns.
What's fascinating is how his game evolved. In 2022, he was a gunslinger. By 2024, he became a master of the short game. Statistics show that in his final year, nearly 28% of his passes were 2 air yards or less. He became a high-percentage distributor, which is exactly what Sark’s offense needs to hum.
And now? We have Arch Manning.
✨ Don't miss: OU Football Depth Chart 2025: Why Most Fans Are Getting the Roster Wrong
The weight of the Manning name is heavy, but the kid has looked the part. In the 2025 season, Arch took the reins and showed he’s more than just a famous last name. He threw for 3,163 yards and 26 touchdowns while adding 10 scores on the ground. He’s got the Manning brain but arguably more athleticism than his uncles Peyton and Eli.
Texas QB Career Leaders (By the Numbers)
- Career Passing Yards: Colt McCoy (13,253) leads the pack, followed by Sam Ehlinger (11,436) and Quinn Ewers (9,128).
- Career Passing TDs: McCoy again (112), with Ehlinger (94) and Ewers (68) trailing.
- Career Rushing Yards (QB): Vince Young is the king here with 3,127 yards. For context, most modern QBs don't even break 1,000.
- Winning Percentage: James Street (100% at 20-0) and Vince Young (93.8%).
What Most People Miss
The "secret" to Texas Longhorns quarterback history isn't just the stars; it's the depth. It's the guys like Peter Gardere, who went 4-0 against Oklahoma. He might not have the NFL stats, but in Austin, "Peter the Great" is a legend because he owned the Red River Rivalry.
It’s also about the coaching. AJ Milwee, the current QB coach, has been instrumental in the development of Ewers and Manning. Sarkisian’s system is notoriously difficult to learn, which is why we’ve seen fewer "true freshman" starters lately. They’re being groomed for the NFL from day one.
Texas is no longer just a "running back school" that happens to have a quarterback. It has become a premier destination for elite arms. Whether Arch Manning leads them to a national title in 2026 or another name emerges, the foundation built by guys like Layne, Street, and McCoy is what keeps the expectations so high.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Historians:
- Watch the 1969 "Game of the Century": If you want to understand James Street and the Wishbone, find the footage of Texas vs. Arkansas. It’s a masterclass in option football.
- Study the "Sark" Offense: To predict Arch Manning's success, look at how Sarkisian utilizes "shallow crosses" and "RPOs." The stats show the QB is now a point guard, not just a deep-ball threat.
- Respect the Red River Stats: When evaluating a Texas QB, always check their record against Oklahoma first. In Austin, a 10-win season with a loss to OU is often considered a failure.
The history of the position at Texas is a cycle of legendary peaks and frustrating valleys. But right now, with the talent in the room and the move to the SEC fully cemented, the "Golden Age" might actually be just beginning.