College football has a weird way of making a single night feel like a decade. When Texas A&M and Notre Dame kicked off their 2024 season opener at Kyle Field, the atmosphere wasn't just loud. It was heavy. You could feel the humidity clinging to the 107,315 fans in attendance—a record-breaking crowd that showed up for one reason: to see if the Mike Elko era would start with a statement or a stumble.
Spoiler alert. It was a stumble. But not a simple one.
The game was a defensive slog, a 23-13 victory for the Fighting Irish that felt more like a chess match played with sledgehammers. It wasn't the offensive fireworks show the networks were hoping for. Instead, we got a masterclass in bend-but-don't-break defense and a stark reminder that winning on the road in the SEC requires more than just a blue-chip roster. It requires a specific kind of late-game execution that the Aggies just didn't have that night.
The Quarterback Contrast Nobody Saw Coming
Everyone wanted to talk about Riley Leonard. He was the Duke transfer following his old coach to South Bend, the dual-threat weapon meant to unlock Marcus Freeman’s offense. On the other side, Conner Weigman was the local hero, the kid with the high ceiling who was supposed to light up the scoreboard under Elko’s new regime.
The reality was messier.
👉 See also: Meaning of Grand Slam: Why We Use It for Tennis, Baseball, and Breakfast
Weigman struggled. Hard. He finished 12-of-30 for 100 yards and two interceptions. Honestly, it was painful to watch at points. The Notre Dame secondary, led by preseason All-American Benjamin Morrison and the opportunistic Xavier Watts, essentially turned the field into a no-fly zone. There were times when Weigman looked completely out of sync with his receivers, missing windows that should have been routine. It wasn't just the pressure from the Irish front four; it was a lack of rhythm that felt like a carryover from his injury-shortened 2023 season.
Meanwhile, Riley Leonard didn't exactly set the world on fire through the air either. He threw for 158 yards and no touchdowns. But he did something Weigman couldn't: he used his legs when the play broke down. Leonard’s ability to scramble for 63 yards kept drives alive. It wasn't pretty football, but it was winning football.
Why Kyle Field Didn't Break the Irish
People always talk about the 12th Man. They talk about the noise. They talk about the press box literally swaying during the "War Hymn." For a team starting several new faces on the offensive line, Notre Dame handled the environment with a poise that felt almost unnatural.
Marcus Freeman deserves a lot of credit for the preparation. The Irish didn't panic when the crowd got loud. They didn't fall apart when the Aggies tied the game at 13-13 late in the fourth quarter. Instead, they leaned on Jeremiyah Love.
✨ Don't miss: NFL Week 5 2025 Point Spreads: What Most People Get Wrong
Love is a special talent. With under two minutes left, he broke loose for a 21-yard touchdown run that basically sucked the air out of College Station. That run was the culmination of a physical game plan. Notre Dame knew they couldn't out-finesse the Aggies in that heat. They had to out-last them.
The Defensive Front Standoff
- Texas A&M's Edge: Nic Scourton was as advertised. The Purdue transfer was a nightmare for the Irish tackles, showing exactly why he’s a projected high NFL draft pick.
- Notre Dame’s Interior: Howard Cross III and Rylie Mills were absolute rocks. They didn't always get the sack, but they lived in the backfield, forcing Weigman to get rid of the ball faster than he wanted to.
- The Turnovers: In a game this close, the two interceptions thrown by Weigman were the difference. You can't give a Top-10 team extra possessions and expect to survive.
Mike Elko's Reality Check
Mike Elko is a great coach. He proved that at Duke and as a defensive coordinator at A&M. But the 2024 opener against Notre Dame was a "welcome back" moment that highlighted the massive gap between having talent and having a cohesive team.
The Aggies’ offense looked dated. Despite the change in leadership, the inability to create explosive plays downfield was a glaring issue. You’ve got to wonder if the play-calling was too conservative or if the execution was just that poor. Probably a mix of both. Texas A&M had chances. They were in the red zone and settled for field goals. In big-time college football, field goals are just slow-motion losses.
The Long-Term Impact on the CFP Race
At the time, this felt like a playoff eliminator. It wasn't, thanks to the new 12-team format, but it set the narrative for both programs. For Notre Dame, it was the "signature road win" they desperately needed to prove they belonged in the national title conversation. For A&M, it was a reminder that the Jimbo Fisher era hangover might take more than one offseason to cure.
🔗 Read more: Bethany Hamilton and the Shark: What Really Happened That Morning
The game also served as a data point for the SEC vs. Independent/National debate. Notre Dame walked into one of the most hostile environments in sports and physically matched the SEC's best. That matters. It changes how poll voters look at a schedule that doesn't have a conference championship game at the end of it.
Lessons from the 12th Man Stand
If you're looking at what this game taught us about high-stakes matchups, it's that the trenches still rule the world. Texas A&M’s defensive line is elite, but their offensive line is a work in progress. Notre Dame’s ability to rotate bodies and stay fresh in the Texas heat was the quietest, most important part of their victory.
Also, we need to talk about the officiating. Every big game has its "what if" moments. There were a few holding calls—or lack thereof—that had the Kyle Field faithful screaming for blood. But honestly? The Aggies didn't lose because of the refs. They lost because they couldn't convert on 3rd down. They were 4-of-13. You aren't beating the Fighting Irish with a 30% conversion rate. Period.
Moving Forward: Actionable Insights for Fans and Bettors
The Texas A&M and Notre Dame rivalry isn't a yearly occurrence, but when they meet, the betting lines and scouting reports usually overlook the psychological toll of the environment. Here is how to process these kinds of games in the future:
- Don't overvalue home-field advantage for elite defenses. A top-tier defense like Notre Dame's communicates through hand signals and instinct. The noise at Kyle Field affects the home team's offense (timing, snap counts) just as much as the visitors if the home team is playing a young quarterback.
- Look at the "Transfer Synergy" factor. Riley Leonard had been through the fire with Elko before. Weigman was learning a new system under Collin Klein. That familiarity matters more than raw stats in Week 1.
- Check the humidity. It sounds like a cliché, but northern teams playing in the South in August/September often struggle in the fourth quarter. Notre Dame's conditioning staff clearly won that battle, as the Irish actually looked faster in the final ten minutes than they did in the first ten.
If you’re tracking these teams for the rest of their schedules, watch the injury reports on the offensive lines. Both teams took a beating in this game. The physical toll of a game like this lingers. A&M has to find a way to make Weigman comfortable, or they risk wasting one of the best defensive fronts in the country. Notre Dame, on the other hand, just needs to find a way to be more explosive. Winning 23-13 is fine against A&M, but against a team like Georgia or Ohio State, they’ll need more than 300 yards of total offense.
The road doesn't get easier for either side, but for one Saturday night in College Station, we saw exactly what makes college football great: a collision of tradition, desperation, and a reminder that on any given night, the loudest stadium in the world can be silenced by a single well-timed run.