Terry McLaurin: Why He Is Still the Most Underrated Receiver in the NFL

Terry McLaurin: Why He Is Still the Most Underrated Receiver in the NFL

You’ve seen the highlight reels. The one where he climbs the ladder against two defenders or snagging a ball that has no business being caught. Yet, somehow, when people list the top five wideouts in the league, the name Terry McLaurin often gets buried under the hype of younger, flashier players. It’s honestly kind of exhausting at this point.

Basically, "Scary Terry" has been doing the impossible for years in Washington. He survived a revolving door of quarterbacks—eleven of them, to be exact—before Jayden Daniels arrived to finally give the man some stability. Think about that. Most elite receivers have a "guy." Rice had Montana and Young. Davante Adams had Rodgers. McLaurin had... well, a lot of guys whose names are now trivia questions.

The Jayden Daniels Effect and the 2024 Breakout

The 2024 season was supposed to be the year everything changed. And in many ways, it was. With Jayden Daniels under center, Terry McLaurin didn't just play well; he looked like he was finally unlocked. They finished the year with a 130.4 passer rating when Daniels targeted him, which was the second-best duo in the entire NFL behind only Jared Goff and Amon-Ra St. Brown.

But here is where it gets interesting. Even with a rookie quarterback, McLaurin put up a career-high and franchise-record 13 touchdown catches. People forget that before 2024, his high was only seven. He was always the guy moving the chains, but he wasn't the guy finishing the drives. That changed. He became a red-zone monster.

🔗 Read more: Inter Miami vs Toronto: What Really Happened in Their Recent Clashes

Last season wasn't without its speed bumps, though. If you followed the 2025 campaign, you know it was a bit of a rollercoaster. McLaurin dealt with a persistent quadriceps strain that cost him games and definitely sapped some of that explosive vertical speed. When he was on the field, he was still the alpha, but the yardage totals dipped from his usual 1,100-yard standard down to the 900s for the first time in forever.

What Most People Get Wrong About His Game

The biggest misconception about Terry McLaurin is that he’s just a "speed guy." Sure, he ran a 4.35 at the combine years ago, but that's not why he's still elite at age 30. It’s the contested catches.

In 2024, McLaurin recorded 34 contested targets. That is the most in a single season since 2014. He didn't just receive them; he hauled in 70.6% of them. According to PFF, he earned a 93.9 receiving grade on contested targets that year, which is the highest mark they’ve ever recorded for any player since 2019.

💡 You might also like: Matthew Berry Positional Rankings: Why They Still Run the Fantasy Industry

  • Elite Body Control: He can adjust to back-shoulder throws better than almost anyone in the NFC.
  • Late Hands: He doesn't show his hands until the last possible second, which prevents defensive backs from playing the ball.
  • Route Savant: He uses subtle hesitations at the break point to create three yards of separation where there should only be one.

Honestly, he’s a technician. You can see it in the way he sets up cornerbacks on those deep posts. He'll lean into the defender's hip, force them to turn their back, and then snap the route off. It’s veteran stuff that doesn't always show up on a box score but makes life a whole lot easier for his quarterback.

The $96 Million Question

Washington finally paid the man. On August 25, 2025, McLaurin signed a three-year extension worth up to $96 million. It was a long, messy process that included a trade request and a holdout from training camp. But let’s be real—the Commanders couldn't afford to lose him.

The deal includes $44 million fully guaranteed. It basically ties him to the D.C. area through his prime years. For a guy who has been the team's leader in receptions and receiving yards for six straight years, it was a move that had to happen to keep the locker room from revolting. He is the culture in that building.

📖 Related: What Time Did the Cubs Game End Today? The Truth About the Off-Season

Why 2026 is the True Test

Going into this current season, the stakes have shifted. The "quarterback carousel" excuse is officially dead. Jayden Daniels is the franchise, and the chemistry they built during that 12-5 run in 2024 needs to return to that elite level.

We saw flashes of it late in 2025 when McLaurin came back from the quad injury. In a Week 15 win over the Giants, he hooked up with Marcus Mariota for a 51-yard score that looked like the Terry of old. Then he followed it up with a five-catch, 63-yard performance against the Cowboys on Christmas Day. Even when the team was struggling, he was the only one getting open.

The challenge now is age and health. McLaurin is 30. In NFL years, that's when the "cliff" starts to loom for some receivers. But look at guys like Keenan Allen or even Davante Adams; they’ve aged gracefully because they win with their minds and their footwork, not just pure raw athleticism. McLaurin falls into that same category.

Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts

If you're trying to figure out if Terry McLaurin is still "that guy," stop looking at the total yardage and start looking at the high-leverage situations.

  1. Watch the 3rd Down Targets: When the Commanders need six yards, look at where the ball goes. McLaurin's first-read target share remains one of the highest in the league at over 30%.
  2. Monitor the Injury Report: That quad injury from last season was no joke. If he’s fully healthy, expect a return to the 10-touchdown range.
  3. Check the Matchups: He has historically struggled against physical, press-heavy corners like Patrick Surtain II, but he destroys teams that try to play soft zone against him.

Terry McLaurin is the rarest kind of superstar—the kind who produces regardless of the chaos surrounding him. Whether he’s catching passes from a Heisman winner or a backup-level journeyman, the results are almost always the same. He’s going to win his route, he’s going to catch the ball, and he’s going to be the most professional person on the field. It’s time we stop calling him underrated and just call him what he is: a cornerstone of the league.