It’s basically just one woman on a stage with a suitcase and a lot of bad dating advice. No falling chandeliers. No cats in spandex. No rolling skates. When Andrew Lloyd Webber and lyricist Don Black first dreamed up Tell Me on a Sunday, they weren't trying to break the theater; they were trying to capture a specific kind of loneliness. It’s a "song cycle," which is just a fancy way of saying a story told entirely through music without any spoken dialogue to lean on.
The show follows "Emma" (though she’s often just called "The Girl"), a British expat who moves to the United States looking for love and success. She finds plenty of the former, though it’s usually the wrong kind. From New York to Hollywood and back again, she cycles through a series of men—a film producer, a software salesman, a younger man—only to realize that her self-worth isn't tied to a wedding ring. It’s simple. Maybe even a little dated if you look at the 1970s gender politics too closely. But the music hits a raw nerve that keeps it relevant.
The Weird History of a One-Woman Show
Most people don't realize this started as an album. In 1979, Marti Webb recorded the songs before the show ever saw a spotlight. It was a radio hit in the UK first. Honestly, that’s why the structure feels so episodic. You aren’t watching a linear play as much as you’re eavesdropping on a woman’s internal monologue over the course of a year.
Eventually, it was paired with another piece, Variations, to create the two-act show Song and Dance. The first half was Emma singing her heart out; the second half was a ballet. It was a weird experiment. Does it always work? Not really. But when it does, it’s because the performer is carrying the entire emotional weight of the room on her shoulders.
Why the 2003 Revival Changed Everything
For a long time, the show felt like a period piece. The lyrics mentioned things like sending letters (actual paper ones!) and long-distance phone calls that cost a fortune. When Denise Van Outen took over the role for the London revival in 2003, Lloyd Webber and Don Black actually went back into the lab. They updated the lyrics. They added new songs. They tried to make Emma feel less like a victim of her circumstances and more like a woman making choices—even if they were messy ones.
✨ Don't miss: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine
This version is usually what you see staged today. It’s snappier. It’s got a bit more "bite." You see, the original 1980 version had a certain fragility, but the modern iteration leans into the humor of dating in a foreign city. It’s less "poor me" and more "can you believe this guy?"
The "Tell Me on a Sunday" Vocal Challenge
You can’t just "sing" this show. You have to survive it. Because there are no other actors, the lead performer never leaves the stage. There is no intermission for her. There are no scenes where she can sit in the wings and sip tea while the ensemble does a dance number.
- The Title Track: "Tell Me on a Sunday" is the big one. It’s a breakup song about wanting a "civilized" ending. No screaming in the street. No fighting over the toaster. Just a quiet walk in the park. It requires incredible breath control and a vulnerability that feels real, not theatrical.
- Take That Look Off Your Face: This is the upbeat, angry opener. It’s iconic. If the singer pushes too hard too early, her voice is shot by the middle of the show.
- Unexpected Song: This is arguably one of the most beautiful melodies Lloyd Webber ever wrote. It’s about that moment when you realize you’re falling in love again, even though you promised you wouldn't. It's high, it’s light, and it’s terrifying to perform.
Bernadette Peters won a Tony for this on Broadway in 1986. She brought a specific, quirky vulnerability to it. Marti Webb brought a belt-heavy, British grit. Jodie Prenger and Stephanie Lawrence each put their own stamp on it. Every actress who steps into the suitcase has to decide: Is Emma a dreamer or a fool? Probably both.
What Most People Get Wrong About Emma
There is a common criticism that Tell Me on a Sunday is "anti-feminist" because the plot is driven by Emma’s relationships with men. That’s a surface-level take. If you actually listen to the progression of the songs, especially toward the end with "Capped Teeth and Caesar Salad" or "Unexpected Song," you see a woman losing her "greenness."
🔗 Read more: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
She starts the show naive. She thinks America is a movie set. By the end, she isn't crying because she's single; she’s acknowledging that she’s survived. She’s tougher. She’s learned that she can be alone without being lonely. It’s a coming-of-age story that just happens to take place in her twenties and thirties rather than her teens.
The men in the show don't even have names on stage. They are "The Producer" or "The Sheldon Bloom." They are sketches. Emma is the only 3D person in the room. In a way, the men are just props for her own self-discovery. That’s actually a pretty modern way to frame a narrative, even if the 80s synthesizers in the original orchestrations suggest otherwise.
The New York vs. London Divide
The show feels different depending on where you watch it. In London, Emma is the brave explorer. Her "Letter Home to England" songs feel nostalgic and sweet. When the show is performed in the U.S., she feels more like a fish out of water.
Interestingly, Lloyd Webber once considered writing a version about an American girl moving to London. It never quite took off. There’s something specifically "British" about Emma’s polite disappointment that makes the show work. An American Emma might just sue her boyfriends or start a podcast. The British Emma just writes a letter and moves to a different city.
💡 You might also like: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
Technical Nuances for Theater Nerds
If you’re looking at the score, you’ll notice that Lloyd Webber uses a lot of recurring motifs. The "Letter Home" theme isn't just a song; it’s a psychological anchor. Every time it returns, it’s slightly more cynical.
The orchestration is also surprisingly intimate. Unlike the massive pits for Phantom of the Opera, Tell Me on a Sunday thrives on a small band. You need a great reed player and a pianist who can handle the pop-rock sensibilities of the late 70s without making it sound like elevator music. It’s a chamber musical. It needs to feel like you’re in Emma’s studio apartment with her.
Actionable Steps for Exploring the Show
If you're new to the world of Emma and her suitcase, don't just jump into the first YouTube clip you see. The show has evolved so much that different recordings offer vastly different experiences.
- Listen to the Original Marti Webb Album (1979): This is the blueprint. It’s pure, it’s 70s, and it has the most heart. It feels like a concept album because, well, it was.
- Watch the Bernadette Peters Tony Performance: You can find clips of her performing "Tell Me on a Sunday" or "Unexpected Song." Pay attention to her acting between the lines. She shows you how to tell a story when there’s no one else to talk to.
- Compare the Lyric Changes: If you’re a writer or a lyricist, look at the 1980 lyrics versus the 2003 Don Black revisions. It’s a masterclass in how to update a property for a new generation without breaking the melody.
- Look for Local Productions: Because it only requires one actress and a small band, this show is a favorite for regional theaters and fringe festivals. It’s best experienced in a small, sweaty black-box theater where you can see the tears on the actress’s face.
The reality is that Tell Me on a Sunday isn't a masterpiece of plot. It’s a masterpiece of mood. It captures that specific Sunday afternoon feeling where the weekend is over, the house is quiet, and you’re wondering what you’re doing with your life. It doesn’t provide easy answers, and that’s why people are still performing it forty years later. You don't need a massive set when you have a melody that perfectly mimics a heartbeat. Emma keeps moving, and so does the audience.
To truly understand the show's impact, focus on the transition between "Married Man" and "I'm Very You, You're Very Me." It highlights the shift from desperation to a sort of weary, humorous acceptance of reality. This is where the "human" quality of the writing shines through, moving beyond the tropes of musical theater into something much more recognizable to anyone who has ever moved to a new city with nothing but a dream and a bad haircut.