Wrestling fans love a good "what if" story. If you were watching WWE back in 2008, you probably thought you were looking at the next decade of main events. Two kids with legendary last names, looking like they stepped off a movie set, holding tag team gold. It was a sure thing. Or so we thought. Ted DiBiase and Cody Rhodes weren't just a tag team; they were the blueprint for the "future" that never quite arrived for one of them, while the other literally became the face of the industry.
It’s wild to look back now. Honestly, if you told a fan in 2009 that Cody Rhodes would be the one to "finish the story" at WrestleMania 40 while Ted DiBiase Jr. would be largely out of the public eye facing legal hurdles, they wouldn’t have believed you. Back then, Ted was the "can't-miss" prospect. He had the size. He had the look. He had that "Million Dollar Man" swagger that seemed built for a world title run. Cody? He was the skinny kid with the boots that didn't quite fit his frame yet.
The Night Everything Changed at Night of Champions
The way they started was actually brilliant. Cody was already a tag champ with Hardcore Holly, who was playing the grumpy mentor role. Then came Night of Champions 2008. Ted DiBiase Jr. makes his debut, claiming he has a mystery partner. He walks out alone. It looks like a handicap match. Suddenly, Cody turns. He drops Holly, reveals he's the mystery partner, and just like that, Ted DiBiase and Cody Rhodes are the World Tag Team Champions.
They called themselves "Priceless." It was a cocky, second-generation heel duo that actually had chemistry. They didn't feel like two random guys thrown together. They felt like a unit. This eventually led them to join Randy Orton in The Legacy, a faction built entirely on the idea that their DNA made them better than everyone else.
📖 Related: Formula One Points Table Explained: Why the Math Matters More Than the Racing
Working under Orton was a masterclass in "sink or swim." Randy wasn't playing a nice mentor. In the storylines, he’d berate them, test them, and even punt Ted in the head to see how he'd react. It was brutal. But it worked. The trio feuded with the absolute biggest names in the business—Triple H, Shawn Michaels, and Batista. You can't buy that kind of education.
Why the Legacy Split Left One Behind
By the time 2010 rolled around, the wheels were coming off. The explosion at WrestleMania XXVI, where Orton faced both his protégés in a Triple Threat match, was supposed to be the launchpad. Orton walked away as the massive babyface. Ted DiBiase and Cody Rhodes were left to find their own identities.
This is where the paths diverged. Ted was handed his father’s Million Dollar Championship and a Virgil-like bodyguard. It felt like a re-run. He was playing a character that worked in the 80s but felt a bit hollow in the modern era. Meanwhile, Cody started experimenting. He became "Dashing" Cody Rhodes. He started giving grooming tips. Then he broke his nose, became "Undashing," and started wearing a clear protective mask and putting paper bags over fans' heads.
👉 See also: El Paso Locomotive FC Standings: Why the 2025 Surge Changes Everything for 2026
Cody was willing to be weird. Ted was trying to be his father.
- Ted’s peak: Winning the Million Dollar Title and a brief, underrated feud over the Intercontinental Championship in 2011.
- Cody’s evolution: Jumping from "Dashing" to the "Intercontinental Champion" who brought back the white strap, and eventually leaving to reinvent himself globally.
The 2011 Role Reversal
There was a brief moment where they reunited on SmackDown in 2011. Cody was the Intercontinental Champion and the clear alpha. He treated Ted like a lackey, a total flip from their early days in Legacy where Ted often felt like the one with the higher ceiling.
They eventually feuded, culminating in a match at Night of Champions 2011. It was a solid match—technically sound, good storytelling—but the crowd was starting to see Cody as a star. Ted, unfortunately, was starting to fade into the background. He eventually left the company in 2013, citing a desire to spend more time with family and pursue other ventures.
✨ Don't miss: Duke Football Recruiting 2025: Manny Diaz Just Flipped the Script in Durham
The Real Difference Between Success and Stagnation
People often ask why one made it and the other didn't. It wasn't talent. Ted was a great wrestler. He was smooth in the ring and a decent promo. The difference was the "hustle." When Cody felt he was hitting a glass ceiling as Stardust, he walked away. He bet on himself. He went to the indies, Japan, and helped start AEW.
Ted's journey went a different way. He stepped away from the spotlight entirely. In recent years, his name has popped up more in news cycles regarding legal issues in Mississippi than in wrestling discussions. It's a sobering reminder that the "Legacy" they touted on screen is a heavy burden to carry in real life.
What You Can Learn From the Legacy Era
Looking back at Ted DiBiase and Cody Rhodes, the takeaway for any fan or aspiring performer is about reinvention. You can't just rely on who your father was. You have to figure out who you are when the lights are the brightest.
- Don't fear the pivot. Cody's career survived five different character changes before he found "The American Nightmare."
- Chemistry is rare. Even though they went different ways, their run as a tag team remains one of the most cohesive "rookie" pairings in WWE history.
- The "It" Factor is evolving. What worked for the Million Dollar Man didn't necessarily work for his son because the audience changed.
If you want to relive the best of this duo, go back and watch their match against D-Generation X at Breaking Point 2009. It’s a Submissions Count Anywhere match, and it’s arguably the best thing they ever did together. It shows two young guys who absolutely belonged in the ring with legends.
To see how far things have come, compare that 2009 footage to Cody's main event at WrestleMania 40. The difference isn't just the pyro and the crowd size; it's the confidence of a man who finally outgrew the shadow of his own name. You might want to check out some of the old "Priceless" promos on the WWE Network to see just how much potential was there from day one.