You just finished a $100 dinner. The service was decent—not life-changing, but the server remembered you wanted the dressing on the side. You scribble a $20 tip on the line. In your head, that’s a direct gift from your pocket to theirs. A little thank you. But the IRS sees it differently. They see it as a line item on a balance sheet. Honestly, the tax on tips law is one of the most misunderstood corners of the U.S. tax code, and if you’re working in hospitality or just trying to be a decent human being who tips well, the reality is a lot messier than "keep the change."
Taxes are annoying. Everyone knows that. But tip taxes are unique because they involve three different parties: the customer, the worker, and the employer. Each has a different stake in that twenty-dollar bill.
Why the IRS is obsessed with your tips
The government doesn't view a tip as a gift. Under the Internal Revenue Code, specifically Section 61, gross income includes "all income from whatever source derived." That includes the five bucks you left on the bar. For decades, the tax on tips law was a bit of a "honor system" situation. Servers would walk out with a pocket full of crumpled ones and fives, and maybe, just maybe, they’d report half of it at the end of the shift. Those days are basically dead.
Digital payments killed the cash-under-the-table era. When you tap your phone or swipe a card, that tip is logged instantly. It’s hard data. The IRS knows exactly what was paid, and they expect their cut of the Social Security, Medicare, and income tax.
There’s also this thing called the FICA Tip Tax Credit (Section 45B). It’s a weirdly specific bit of business law that allows employers—usually restaurant owners—to get a tax credit for the Social Security and Medicare taxes they pay on employee tips. It’s supposed to encourage businesses to make sure their staff reports every cent.
The $20 threshold you probably didn't know about
Most people think you report everything, and technically, you should. But the law actually says if an employee receives less than $20 in tips in a single calendar month while working for one employer, they don't have to report those tips to that employer.
Does that mean it's tax-free? Nope. It’s still taxable income you’re supposed to put on your 1040, but you don't have to tell your boss about it for payroll purposes. Once you hit $21? The paperwork starts.
💡 You might also like: Dealing With the IRS San Diego CA Office Without Losing Your Mind
The "No Tax on Tips" movement of 2024-2025
If you’ve been watching the news or scrolling through social media over the last couple of years, you’ve probably heard politicians on both sides of the aisle promising to kill the tax on tips law entirely. It became a massive campaign talking point.
The idea is simple: let service workers keep 100% of their gratuities without the federal government taking a bite. Sounds great, right? Who wouldn't want a waitress to take home more money? But when you peel back the layers, it gets complicated. Economists at places like the Tax Foundation and the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget have pointed out some pretty glaring "what-ifs."
If tips aren't taxed, what stops a high-priced lawyer from charging a $10 hourly fee and "suggesting" a $500 tip?
That’s the loophole problem. To make a "no tax on tips" law actually work, the government would have to write thousands of pages of regulations to define who counts as a "tipped worker." Is it just servers? What about hair stylists? Uber drivers? Croupiers at a casino? The definition matters because it shifts billions of dollars in tax revenue.
How tip pooling changes the math
Tip pooling is legal under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), but it’s a minefield for business owners. Basically, a restaurant can require all servers to put their tips into one big pot to be split with the "back of house" (the cooks and dishwashers).
However, there are strict rules:
📖 Related: Sands Casino Long Island: What Actually Happens Next at the Old Coliseum Site
- Managers and supervisors can never keep any part of a tip pool. Ever.
- If an employer takes a "tip credit" (meaning they pay the server less than the standard minimum wage, usually $2.13 at the federal level), they can generally only pool tips among employees who "customarily and regularly" receive tips.
- If the employer pays the full minimum wage, they can include the kitchen staff in the pool.
When the tax on tips law intersects with pooling, the record-keeping becomes a nightmare. Every single dollar must be tracked as it moves from the customer to the pool and then to the individual paycheck. If a restaurant messes up the math, they don't just owe the IRS; they could face massive lawsuits for wage theft.
The dark side of the tip credit
We need to talk about the tip credit because it’s the most controversial part of this whole ecosystem. Under federal law, an employer only has to pay a tipped worker $2.13 per hour as long as that worker’s tips bring them up to the standard federal minimum wage of $7.25.
If the server doesn't make enough tips to hit that $7.25 mark, the employer is legally required to make up the difference.
Does this always happen? Honestly, no. Many workers don't know their rights, or they're afraid that asking the boss for the "make-up" pay will get them fired or given the worst shifts. This is where the tax on tips law feels less like a revenue generator for the government and more like a burden on the lowest earners.
Real-world example: The Friday night rush
Imagine a server named Sam. On a busy Friday in 2026, Sam clears $300 in tips.
- The Old Way: Sam walks out with $300 cash. Maybe $100 gets reported.
- The 2026 Reality: $280 of that was on credit cards. The POS system automatically logs it.
The restaurant’s payroll software calculates Sam’s share of FICA (7.65%) and federal income tax withholding. By the time Sam gets their actual "paycheck" for their hourly wages, the check is often for $0.00. Why? Because the taxes owed on the $300 in tips were higher than the $2.13/hour base wage could cover. Sam isn't working for free—they have the tip money—but the government took its "fair share" directly out of the base pay before Sam ever saw it.
👉 See also: Is The Housing Market About To Crash? What Most People Get Wrong
States are doing their own thing
While we talk about federal tax on tips law, you have to look at the state level too.
- California, Oregon, and Washington: These states have abolished the tip credit. Servers get the full state minimum wage (which is often $15-$19/hour) plus their tips.
- The Southern Strategy: Many states in the South still cling to the $2.13 federal floor.
This creates a massive disparity in how much a tipped worker actually takes home. A bartender in Seattle is living a very different financial life than a bartender in Mississippi, even if they both collect the same amount in gratuities.
What you should actually do: Actionable steps
If you are a tipped worker or a business owner, navigating the tax on tips law isn't just about being "honest"—it's about protecting yourself from an audit or a lawsuit.
For Workers:
- Keep a daily log. Don't rely on your employer’s software. Use a notebook or an app to track every dollar of cash and credit tips. If the IRS ever flags your return, your personal contemporaneous log is your best defense.
- Understand Form 4070. This is the official document for reporting tips to your employer. You’re supposed to submit it by the 10th of the month following the month the tips were received.
- Watch your pay stubs. Make sure your employer isn't "rounding down" or taking illegal deductions for "breakage" or "walkouts" from your tipped income.
For Business Owners:
- Standardize your tip policy in writing. If you use a tip pool, every employee should sign a document stating they understand how it works.
- Claim the 45B Credit. If you’re a food and beverage establishment, make sure your accountant is maximizing this credit. It’s literally free money from the government to compensate you for the taxes you pay on employee tips.
- Audit your POS settings. Ensure the system correctly distinguishes between "service charges" (which belong to the house and are subject to different tax rules) and "tips" (which belong to the staff).
The landscape of the tax on tips law is shifting. With constant political pressure to change how service work is compensated, the rules you follow today might be different by next tax season. Staying informed isn't just a "good idea"—it's the only way to make sure that $20 tip actually stays in the right hands.
Next Steps for Compliance:
- Download IRS Publication 1244, which includes a template for a daily tip record.
- If you're an employer, review the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) fact sheets regarding tipped employees to ensure your tip credit usage is legal in your specific state.
- Consult a tax professional specifically about the FICA Tip Tax Credit to see if your business qualifies for retroactive claims from previous years.