Tannersville is weird. I mean that in the best way possible.
You’re driving through the Catskills, surrounded by deep greens and rocky grays, and then—bam—you hit a Main Street that looks like a box of crayons exploded on a Victorian film set. They call it the Painted Village in the Sky. It isn’t just a marketing gimmick; the buildings are actually neon pink, turquoise, and canary yellow, complete with shutters painted with quirky little cartoons.
Most people just stop for a photo and a quick coffee before heading to Hunter Mountain, which is barely five minutes down the road. But they’re missing out. There’s a specific energy here that’s harder to find in the more "polished" parts of the Hudson Valley. It’s a mix of old-school mountain grit and a newer, sophisticated food scene that hasn't lost its soul yet.
If you are looking for things to do in Tannersville, you have to look past the bright paint.
The Morning Routine: Coffee, Donuts, and Quiet Meadows
Let’s be honest: your day should start with sugar and caffeine. If it’s a weekend, you’re going to Shandaken Bake. It’s tiny. It’s only open Saturday and Sunday. And yes, they will sell out of the good stuff by 11:00 AM. Their savory hand pies are basically a hug in pastry form.
If you want something faster, Fred’s Donuts is the local legend. It’s got a drive-up window which is incredibly convenient when you’re trying to beat the crowds to the trailhead.
Before the sun gets too high, head to the Mountain Top Arboretum. It’s about 178 acres of pure peace. Most people skip this for the more famous hikes, but that’s a mistake. The Spruce Glen section has these 150-year-old hemlocks that make the air feel different—colder, cleaner, older. There are boardwalks over wetlands and meadows that are usually dead quiet. It’s free, though they ask for a donation, and it’s arguably the best spot in town to actually hear yourself think.
💡 You might also like: Super 8 Fort Myers Florida: What to Honestly Expect Before You Book
Deep Woods and Vertical Drops: The Real Hiking Hits
Everyone goes to Kaaterskill Falls. It’s one of the tallest waterfalls in New York, and it is stunning. It’s also usually packed. If you go, go early. Like, 7:00 AM early.
But if you want to avoid the "Instagram queues," try Huckleberry Point.
It’s a 4.5-mile trek that isn't too brutal but gives you one of the most rewarding overlooks in the entire Catskill range. You’re looking out over the Hudson Valley from a jagged rock ledge, and half the time, you’ll have it to yourself.
For something a bit more diverse, North-South Lake is the heavy hitter. It’s the largest state campground in the Catskill Forest Preserve. You can:
- Rent a kayak or canoe.
- Hike to Artists Rock or Sunset Rock.
- Visit the site of the former Catskill Mountain House, where the 19th-century elite used to vacation.
- Just sit by the water and do absolutely nothing.
The Scutt Road Loop is about 5.5 miles and takes you through various terrains without making your knees scream. It’s the "Goldilocks" of local hikes—just right.
Shopping for Things You Didn't Know You Needed
Tannersville has a shopping scene that feels like a treasure hunt. Tannersville Antiques and Artisan Center is two floors of "what on earth is that?" and "I need that for my living room." It’s a collective, so you’ve got over 30 vendors. You might find a 1920s fly-fishing rod next to a mid-century modern lamp.
📖 Related: Weather at Lake Charles Explained: Why It Is More Than Just Humidity
Then there’s Camp Catskill. It’s an ethical outdoor shop. If you forgot your wool socks or need a high-quality map that won’t fail when your phone loses signal (and it will lose signal in the notches), this is the place. They’re super knowledgeable about the local trails too.
Don't skip Tannersville Works. It’s a newer vibe—vintage jewelry, art, and high-end candles. It feels like a piece of Brooklyn moved upstate but kept its manners.
Where to Eat When the Mountain Air Hits
By 4:00 PM, you’re going to be starving.
Last Chance Antiques & Cheese Café is the classic choice. It’s been around since the 70s. It’s part restaurant, part antique shop, and part candy store. They have over 300 beers and a massive selection of whiskey. Get the fondue. Seriously. It’s the law when you’re in Tannersville.
If you want something more "now," Tabla is the spot. It’s Spanish-fusion tapas and it’s honestly incredible. Think small plates, local ingredients, and cocktails that actually taste like they were made by a pro. It’s cozy, low-lit, and perfect for a long dinner after a day of hiking.
For the best burger in the mountains? Mama’s Boy Burgers. It’s a 1950s-style joint with bright colors and outdoor seating. The burgers are local, the milkshakes are thick, and it’s exactly what you want after burning 1,500 calories on the Devil’s Path.
👉 See also: Entry Into Dominican Republic: What Most People Get Wrong
The Culture Shock: Orpheum and Art
It’s not all mud and mountains. The Orpheum Film & Performing Arts Center is a world-class facility right on Main Street. They do everything from contemporary dance to indie film screenings. It’s worth checking their calendar before you arrive; sometimes you can catch a performance that you’d normally have to pay $100 for in the city.
Things to Do in Tannersville: A Quick Reference for Your Trip
| Activity | Why it's worth it | Pro Tip |
|---|---|---|
| Mountain Top Arboretum | Quiet, easy walking, rare trees. | Use the "Hidden Marsh" boardwalk for the best photos. |
| Hunter Mountain Skyride | Incredible views without the sweat. | Only runs seasonally; check the schedule for summer/fall. |
| Rip Van Winkle Lake | Great for kids and quick paddles. | There's a skate park and disc golf course right there. |
| Hathaway Trail System | Designed for mountain bikers. | "Thriller" is the trail to hit if you've got the skills. |
| Deer Mountain Inn | High-end fireside dining. | You need a reservation weeks in advance for a weekend slot. |
What People Get Wrong About This Town
The biggest misconception is that Tannersville is just a winter town because of Hunter Mountain.
Wrong.
The village actually peaks in the fall. The contrast between the neon buildings and the deep reds of the turning maples is something you have to see to believe. In the summer, it’s significantly cooler than the city or the valley floor because of the elevation (it's nearly 2,000 feet up).
People also think it’s just a "tourist trap" because of the colors. But talk to the people behind the counters at Lucky Catskills or Maggie’s Krooked Cafe. There’s a tight-knit community here that has been fighting to keep the village's unique identity alive since the tanning industry collapsed in the 1800s.
Actionable Next Steps for Your Visit
- Check the Orpheum schedule immediately. If there's a show during your visit, grab tickets before they're gone.
- Download offline maps. The "Notch" on Route 23A is a notorious dead zone for GPS.
- Book your dinner at Tabla or Deer Mountain Inn at least two weeks out if you're coming on a Saturday.
- Pack layers. Even in July, the temperature can drop 20 degrees once the sun goes behind the peaks.
Tannersville isn't just a place you pass through on your way to the ski slopes. It's a destination that rewards you for slowing down, looking at the weird shutters, and eating too much cheese. Get out there and see it for yourself.