If you were watching the Tampa Bay Buccaneers vs Atlanta Falcons game on Thursday Night Football this past December, you probably still have a headache. I know I do. It was one of those games that makes you wonder if the NFC South is actually just a simulation designed to punish kickers and reward chaos.
The Falcons won 29-28 on a walk-off field goal by Zane Gonzalez. But that’s such a boring way to describe what actually happened.
Basically, the Buccaneers had a 14-point lead in the fourth quarter. They were dominating. Baker Mayfield was throwing dots, Mike Evans looked like his old self after coming back from that clavicle injury, and the defense was making life miserable for Kirk Cousins. Then, everything just... melted.
This isn't just about one game, though. This rivalry—often called the I-75 rivalry—is basically a coin flip every single time these two teams step on the turf. Honestly, the all-time series is so close it’s ridiculous. After that 2025 thriller, the Falcons now lead 33-32. One game. That is all that separates decades of history.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Bucs-Falcons Rivalry
People like to talk about the Saints or the Panthers when they think of "nasty" NFC South rivalries, but the Buccaneers and Falcons have a weird, quiet intensity. It’s a proximity thing.
You’ve got two fanbases that genuinely believe they are the "class" of the division, yet they both spent the last few years trading blows like two tired heavyweights in the 12th round.
Kinda funny, right?
The biggest misconception is that the "Tom Brady Era" ended the competitive nature of this matchup. Sure, Brady was 6-0 against Atlanta as a Buccaneer. He haunted them. But since Baker Mayfield took over in Tampa and Kirk Cousins arrived in Atlanta (following the brief Marcus Mariota/Desmond Ridder/Michael Penix Jr. experimental phases), the gap has vanished.
👉 See also: Why the Marlins Won World Series Titles Twice and Then Disappeared
The Kyle Pitts Problem
Let’s talk about Kyle Pitts. For years, fantasy football managers have been screaming into their pillows about his lack of usage. Then, on December 11, 2025, he decides to turn into prime Rob Gronkowski.
- 11 catches
- 166 yards
- 3 touchdowns
It was the most receiving yards by a Falcons player in a single game against the Bucs since Julio Jones was teleporting across the field. He was basically unguardable. The Bucs tried putting Zyon McCollum on him; didn't work. They tried bracket coverage; Cousins just waited for the window.
The most insane part? Atlanta had 19 penalties for 125 yards in that game. 19! You aren't supposed to win NFL games when you're moving backward that much. But the Buccaneers’ defense, which has been the backbone of their four straight division titles, just couldn't get a stop when it mattered.
The Baker Mayfield Interception That Changed Everything
Baker Mayfield is a "ride the lightning" kind of quarterback. When it's good, he’s planting flags and firing up the crowd. When it’s bad, it’s a soul-crushing turnover at the 33-yard line.
With under ten minutes left and the Bucs up 28-14, Baker threw a pass toward Evans that Dee Alford snagged. You could feel the air leave Raymond James Stadium. Honestly, you've seen this movie before if you're a Bucs fan. It’s that feeling of "Oh, here we go again."
"This one is gonna haunt me. It falls on my shoulders," Mayfield said after the game.
He wasn't lying. That pick set up a touchdown drive, and suddenly a blowout turned into a one-possession sweat-fest. The Bucs’ offense went stagnant, and the Falcons—who had no business being in the game—found their rhythm.
✨ Don't miss: Why Funny Fantasy Football Names Actually Win Leagues
Why the 2025 Season Shifted the Power Balance
For the last four years, the NFC South has belonged to Tampa Bay. They’ve been the "kings of the trash pile," as some snarky national media members like to say. But the 2025 campaign showed that the Falcons have finally figured out their identity.
While the Buccaneers were dealing with a rotating door of injuries—losing Mike Evans for a huge chunk of the season and seeing their secondary get shredded—Atlanta leaned into their young stars. Bijan Robinson is a problem. He’s not just a runner; he’s a matchup nightmare that forces linebackers like Lavonte David to play perfectly for 60 minutes.
The Falcons’ rookie edge rusher, James Pearce Jr., also looks like a terrifying addition to this rivalry. He sacked Mayfield twice in that December game. Atlanta has spent years failing to pressure the quarterback, but Pearce looks like the real deal.
The Division Standings Chaos
The result of that specific Buccaneers vs Atlanta Falcons matchup didn't just hurt Tampa’s pride; it effectively handed the division to the Carolina Panthers.
Imagine that.
Two teams beat each other up so badly that a third team just slides into the top spot. By the time Week 18 rolled around, the Bucs were fighting for their playoff lives, all because they couldn't hold a two-score lead against a Falcons team that committed nearly 20 penalties.
Strategy: How to Watch the Next Matchup
If you're betting on or just watching the next installment of this series, ignore the records. Seriously. These teams play each other differently than they play anyone else.
🔗 Read more: Heisman Trophy Nominees 2024: The Year the System Almost Broke
- Look at the Tight End Matchup: If the Bucs don't find a way to neutralize the hybrid threats in Atlanta's offense, they will keep losing these shootouts.
- Watch the "Creamsicle" Curse: Tampa Bay wore their throwback Creamsicle jerseys for the 48th anniversary of their first-ever franchise win during that December loss. They are now 1-something-ridiculous in those jerseys. Maybe leave them in the closet for a while?
- The Fourth Quarter Factor: Both teams have a weird habit of playing "precent" defense too early. Most of the games in the last three years have been decided by 5 points or less.
The rivalry is no longer about who has the better roster on paper. It’s about who blinks first in the final two minutes. Whether it’s Younghoe Koo or Zane Gonzalez kicking a game-winner, or Baker Mayfield trying to engineer a 60-second drill, these games are rarely decided by halftime.
Future Outlook
The Buccaneers are in a weird spot. They have the veterans—Evans, Godwin, Vea—but they are getting older. The Falcons are the "shiny new toy" with Penix Jr. waiting in the wings and a bunch of high-draft-pick skill players finally hitting their stride.
If you want to understand where the NFC South is going in 2026, don't look at the national power rankings. Look at the tape from the last time these two met. The Bucs are struggling to close doors, and the Falcons are learning how to kick them down.
To stay ahead of the curve for the next season, start tracking the defensive secondary depth for Tampa Bay. Their inability to handle "big" receivers and athletic tight ends is a recurring theme that Atlanta is clearly exploiting. On the flip side, watch the Falcons' offensive line discipline; if they don't clean up the holding calls, they'll keep letting teams like the Bucs stay in games they should have lost by twenty.
The 2025 season series proved one thing: the gap between the top and the bottom of this division is a razor-thin margin.
Check the injury reports for the next meeting. If Chris Godwin and Drake London are both healthy, expect another 500+ yard passing day between the two teams. This isn't the "three yards and a cloud of dust" football your grandfather watched. It's a track meet with pads on, and it's easily the most entertaining mess in the NFL right now.