You’re standing on the platform at Union Station in New London, the salt air is hitting your face, and you’re looking at your phone wondering if you should’ve just driven. Honestly? You made the right call. The drive down I-95 through Fairfield County is a special kind of hell that nobody deserves, especially on a Friday afternoon. Taking the new london to nyc train is basically a rite of passage for Southeast Connecticut locals and Pfizer employees, but if you haven't done it lately, the logistics have shifted a bit.
It isn't just one train. That’s the first mistake people make. You have options, and choosing the wrong one can mean the difference between a productive two-hour breeze and a three-hour slog where you're standing in the vestibule because the regional was oversold.
Amtrak vs. Shore Line East: The Great Connection Debate
Most travelers instinctively open the Amtrak app. It makes sense. Amtrak is the heavyweight here. The Northeast Regional pulls into New London pretty frequently, and it’s the only one that gives you that "one-seat ride" straight into the bowels of Pennsylvania Station in Manhattan. No transfers. No moving your bags. You just sit there, maybe grab a mediocre coffee from the cafe car, and wait for the Hell Gate Bridge to appear.
But here is what people miss: Shore Line East.
If you’re on a budget or Amtrak’s dynamic pricing has jacked the fare up to $150 for a last-minute ticket, Shore Line East is your backup. It’s a commuter service run by CTtransit. It doesn't go to NYC. It goes to New Haven. From New Haven, you hop on a Metro-North train to Grand Central Terminal.
Is it slower? Yeah, usually. But Metro-North is incredibly reliable, and sometimes you actually want to end up at Grand Central instead of Penn Station. If your final destination is the Upper East Side or Midtown East, the "slow" way might actually save you twenty minutes of subway transfers once you're in the city.
The Acela Secret (Or Why It Usually Isn't Worth It)
Let's talk about the Acela. It’s the "fast" train. People see the sleek nose and the business-class-only seating and think it’s the premium way to get from New London to the city.
Here’s the reality: Between New London and New Haven, the tracks are curvy. Like, really curvy. The Acela can’t actually go full tilt on this segment of the Northeast Corridor. It has to slow down for the movable bridges—Old Saybrook, Niantic, Mystic—those aging pieces of infrastructure that have to swing open for boats.
💡 You might also like: Finding Your Way: Why the Map of Japan Kobe Layout is So Refreshingly Simple
You might shave ten or fifteen minutes off your total travel time compared to a Regional, but you’re often paying double the price. Unless your company is footing the bill or you absolutely must have a reserved seat in a slightly quieter car, the Northeast Regional is the smarter play for this specific leg of the trip.
Navigating the New London Union Station Chaos
Union Station is beautiful. It’s a H.H. Richardson building, which means it has that heavy, Romanesque stone vibe that makes you feel like you’re in a 19th-century novel. But it’s also tiny.
The parking situation is the biggest hurdle. The Water Street Garage is right there, and it’s usually your best bet, but give yourself twenty minutes. Don't roll up five minutes before the train leaves. The walk from the garage, across the street, and through the station takes longer than you think, especially if there's a ferry arriving from Block Island or Long Island at the same time. The intersection becomes a swarm of tourists with rolling suitcases. It’s a mess.
Also, pay attention to the tracks. New London has a "low-level" platform for some tracks, which means you have to climb stairs up into the train. If you have mobility issues or a massive trunk, try to check the Amtrak app to see if your train is arriving on a high-level platform. It makes a world of difference.
What to Expect on the Ride Down
Once you leave New London, the first thirty minutes are stunning. This is arguably the most scenic stretch of train track in the entire United States. You are literally skimming the edge of the Long Island Sound. You'll see the Niantic River, the marshes of Old Lyme, and the backyards of some of the most expensive real estate in Connecticut.
- WiFi: It sucks. Don't plan a high-stakes Zoom call. Amtrak's "Connect" WiFi is basically a cellular hotspot shared by 400 people. It’ll cut out near Guilford and definitely when you hit the tunnels in NYC.
- Seating: If you’re on the Regional, it’s unassigned. To get the best view of the water, sit on the left side of the train when heading toward New York.
- Quiet Car: Usually the second or third car from the engine. If you speak above a whisper here, a regular commuter will probably glare at you with the intensity of a thousand suns.
The Moynihan Train Hall Factor
When you finally arrive in NYC, you aren't just dumped into the dark, dingy basement of old Penn Station anymore. Most Amtrak trains now arrive at the Moynihan Train Hall. It’s across 8th Avenue from the old station.
It’s gorgeous. High ceilings, actual sunlight, and high-end food vendors. But it’s a long walk to the 1/2/3 or A/C/E subway lines. If you’re used to the "old" way, you might find yourself disoriented. Just follow the signs for the "West End Concourse."
A Note on Ticket Pricing
If you buy your new london to nyc train ticket three weeks out, you can find them for $30 or $40. If you try to buy it on a Friday at 4:00 PM for a 5:30 PM departure? You’re looking at $120 minimum.
Amtrak uses airline-style bucket pricing. There is no "standard" fare. The moment the train starts filling up, the price jumps. If you see a cheap fare, buy it. You can usually cancel for a rail credit anyway.
Logistics and Moving Parts
There’s a weird quirk about the New London stop. Because the station is located on a curve and involves those aforementioned movable bridges, delays are common. It’s not unusual for a train to be held at the bridge for 10 minutes because a sailboat is passing through.
If you have a tight connection at Penn Station—maybe you’re headed to Newark Airport or taking the Long Island Rail Road—give yourself a 45-minute buffer. Seriously. One "bridge opening" or a signaling issue near Stamford can throw the whole schedule into a tailspin.
Actionable Steps for a Better Trip
- Download the Amtrak App: This is non-negotiable. It’s the only way to get real-time gate info and track your train’s actual location when the platform display inevitably glitches.
- Book "Value" or "Saber" Fares Early: These are the cheapest tiers. They sell out first.
- Check the Ferry Schedule: If the Cross Sound Ferry is letting out right when your train is supposed to arrive, expect the station to be packed. Move to the far end of the platform to avoid the initial crush of people.
- The New Haven Backup: If you miss your Amtrak, don't panic. Check the CTrail/Shore Line East schedule. You can almost always get to New York via a transfer in New Haven, even if Amtrak is sold out.
- Pack a Power Bank: While most Amtrak cars have outlets, the older Amfleet cars (the ones with the tubular bodies) sometimes have dead sockets. Don't rely on them to keep your laptop alive.
- Use Moynihan, Not Penn: If you're being picked up by an Uber or Lyft, set your pickup point to the Moynihan Train Hall entrances on 9th Avenue. It’s much less chaotic than the 7th or 8th Avenue sides of the main station.
Taking the train is better for the planet, better for your stress levels, and honestly, the bar car beats a gas station rest stop every time. Just know the nuances of the New London stop, and you’ll avoid the rookie mistakes that turn a fun trip into a headache.