Sutton Foster Ted Griffin Wedding: What Really Happened to Broadway’s Favorite Couple

Sutton Foster Ted Griffin Wedding: What Really Happened to Broadway’s Favorite Couple

It was late October 2014 when the news finally broke. Sutton Foster—the woman who basically owns every Broadway stage she touches—had officially tied the knot with screenwriter Ted Griffin. For fans of the Younger star, it felt like a long-awaited "happily ever after" for someone who’d been incredibly candid about her struggles with love and family in the past.

They did it in Santa Barbara. It wasn’t some massive, televised gala. It was private. Intimate. The kind of wedding where you could actually hear the Pacific Ocean in the background. But looking back at the Sutton Foster Ted Griffin wedding today, it carries a lot more weight than just a celebrity ceremony. It represents a decade-long chapter that, as of early 2026, is finally, and somewhat painfully, closing.

A Secretive "Yes" to the Dress

Honestly, the way the world found out about the gown was sort of hilarious. Usually, celebrities guard their wedding dress details like state secrets. Sutton? She took a different route. She actually filmed an episode of TLC’s Say Yes to the Dress at Kleinfeld Bridal in Manhattan.

The episode aired shortly after the ceremony, giving us a rare look into her headspace. She wasn’t looking for something "theatrical" or "costume-like," which is ironic given her day job. Instead, she went for a classic, sleeveless gown with a tiered skirt. It was light. It was airy.

"I knew that it made me 'feel' different," she told People at the time. She tried on several, but the first one she put on was the one. Sometimes you just know.

Why the Sutton Foster Ted Griffin Wedding Felt Different

Before Ted, Sutton was married to fellow Broadway titan Christian Borle. They were the industry’s golden couple, but it didn't last. After that divorce in 2009, she dated Bobby Cannavale for a while, but it seemed like she was searching for something more grounded.

💡 You might also like: Danny DeVito Wife Height: What Most People Get Wrong

Enter Ted Griffin. He’s the guy who wrote Ocean’s Eleven. He’s not a "musical theater guy" in the traditional sense, though he definitely respects the craft. They met on a blind date, which is just so normal it’s almost weird for two high-profile people in Hollywood.

When they got engaged in August 2013, it felt like a shift. Sutton started talking about things she hadn't really prioritized before—like motherhood. She’s been quoted saying that being with Ted was the first time she actually "got it." She understood why people wanted families. That wedding in Santa Barbara wasn't just about a marriage certificate; it was about Sutton deciding she wanted to build a legacy off-stage.

The Santa Barbara Ceremony Details

  • Date: Saturday, October 25, 2014.
  • Location: A private estate in Santa Barbara, California.
  • The Vibe: Low-key, sophisticated, and very secluded.
  • The Guest List: Strictly friends and family (very few leaks to the press).

Building a Life Beyond the Spotlight

After the wedding, they didn't just disappear into the Hollywood hills. They moved into a beautiful home in Manhattan and later a dream house in the Hudson Valley. In 2017, their lives changed forever when they adopted their daughter, Emily Dale Griffin.

For years, this seemed like the blueprint for a "successful" celebrity marriage. They stayed out of the tabloids. They supported each other's careers—Ted doing his thing in the writer's room and Sutton becoming the face of the hit show Younger. They even weathered the pandemic together in their lake house, sitting down for family dinners and asking their daughter "How was your day?" as a ritual.

But as we now know in 2026, even the most solid-looking foundations can have cracks.

📖 Related: Mara Wilson and Ben Shapiro: The Family Feud Most People Get Wrong

The 2024 Filing and the "Dark Cloud"

It’s impossible to talk about the Sutton Foster Ted Griffin wedding without acknowledging how it ended. In October 2024, exactly ten years after they said their vows in Santa Barbara, Sutton filed for an uncontested divorce in the New York County Supreme Court.

The timing was... interesting, to say the least. It came right in the middle of a whirlwind of rumors regarding Sutton and her Music Man co-star, Hugh Jackman.

While the divorce was filed in late 2024, the legal process has been described by insiders as a "dark cloud" that has lingered well into 2026. Why? Because when you spend a decade building a life, co-parenting a child, and merging assets, you can't just walk away in a weekend.

Why the Split Shocked Fans

Many fans felt a sense of "betrayal" of the narrative. We were sold on the idea that Ted was the one who finally made Sutton feel "at home." To see that chapter end, especially with the high-profile nature of her new relationship with Jackman, has sparked a lot of debate in the Broadway community.

Some sources suggest the pair simply grew apart after the intense "bubble" of the pandemic eased. Others point to the undeniable chemistry she had with Jackman during their long run in The Music Man. Whatever the case, the divorce is a reminder that the person you are when you say "I do" in 2014 isn't always the person you are in 2024.

👉 See also: How Tall is Tim Curry? What Fans Often Get Wrong About the Legend's Height

Current Status: Where Do They Stand Now?

As of early January 2026, Sutton and Hugh Jackman are very much "official." They made their red carpet debut in late 2025 and were recently spotted on a romantic New Year's getaway in Costa Rica.

However, the divorce from Ted Griffin is reportedly still being finalized. There are assets to divide—like that $2 million dream home they sold shortly before the split—and, most importantly, the continued co-parenting of their daughter, Emily.

Ted has remained largely silent through all of this. He’s a writer; he lives behind the scenes, and he’s clearly keeping it that way.

What We Can Learn From the Foster-Griffin Era

So, what’s the takeaway here? If you're looking back at the Sutton Foster Ted Griffin wedding through the lens of today’s headlines, it’s easy to feel cynical. But that’s a mistake.

That wedding represented a very real, very transformative decade for Sutton Foster. It was the period where she became a mother. It was the period where she transitioned from a "Broadway darling" to a bona fide television star. Even if a marriage ends, it doesn't mean it wasn't a success for the time it existed.

Next steps for fans and followers:
If you want to keep up with the finalization of the divorce or Sutton’s new chapter, keep a close eye on the New York County Supreme Court filings, as they've been the most reliable source of truth amidst the tabloid noise. Additionally, Sutton’s memoir, Hooked: Stitching Together a Bargain Life, offers some of the best insights into her mindset during the years she was building her life with Ted—it’s worth a re-read to see the nuances she shared before the split.