He didn't walk out of prison with a master plan to take over the world. Honestly, that’s the first thing you have to wrap your head around if you want to understand the Michael Cudlitz version of the character. This wasn't the suave, billionaire-of-the-month Lex we usually see in the movies. This guy was a wrecking ball. He spent seventeen years in Blackgate for a crime he didn’t even commit, and when he finally stepped into the Smallville sun, he didn't want money. He wanted blood. Specifically, he wanted to ruin the woman who put him there: Lois Lane.
The Superman and Lois Lex is a Different Kind of Monster
Most versions of Luthor are defined by their ego or their jealousy of a "god" among men. But in Superman & Lois, the vendetta is way more personal and, frankly, much dirtier. We’re talking about a man who was framed by Bruno Mannheim and then essentially forgotten by the system. While Clark Kent was raising teenagers and Lois was winning Pulitzers, Lex was rotting.
When he finally gets out, he doesn't go back to a high-rise in Metropolis right away. He moves into a local farm. He walks around in a leather jacket with a grizzly beard, looking more like a guy who’d start a bar fight than a guy who owns a tech conglomerate.
Why the "Biker" Look Actually Mattered
A lot of fans were annoyed by the beard initially. They wanted the suit. They wanted the "classic" vibe. But the show was making a point: prison stripped away the polish. You’ve got to realize that this Lex is a hammer, not a scalpel. He eventually shaves and puts on the three-piece suit in the episode "Sharp Dressed Man," but even then, it’s a mask. He’s using the "reformed businessman" image to manipulate the public and gaslight Lois Lane on national television. It’s brilliant because it plays on our own expectations of what Lex Luthor is "supposed" to look like.
The Doomsday Connection: A Twisted Masterstroke
The way this show handled Doomsday was honestly kind of heartbreaking. Instead of some random space monster or a General Zod clone, Lex took Bizarro—the tragic, broken version of Superman from another world—and tortured him. He killed him over and over again. Every time Bizarro came back, he was stronger, uglier, and less human.
Lex didn't just want a monster; he wanted to turn Superman’s own face into the thing that killed him. That is a level of petty you just don't see in other adaptations. It wasn't about science for the sake of science. It was about making Clark and Lois suffer.
- The Heart Incident: In Season 4, Lex literally gets his hands on Clark’s heart after Doomsday kills him. He doesn't just keep it; he stomps on it in front of the boys.
- The Red Sun Trap: Later, he turns the streetlights of Smallville red. He strips Clark of his powers just so he can try to beat him to death with his bare hands in the rain.
It’s brutal. It’s grounded. It makes Jesse Eisenberg’s Lex look like a cartoon character.
👉 See also: Perry the band songs: Why this indie project is actually worth your time
What Happened in the Finale?
The series finale really threw people for a loop. After decades of fighting, the show jumps thirty years into the future. We see Clark and Lois old, gray, and still in love. But what about Lex?
Basically, Lex ended up back where he started: in a cell. He spent his final years sharing a space with Bruno Mannheim. By the time Clark is facing his own mortality, Lex is already gone. But the show did something interesting with the "afterlife" or "vision" sequence. Clark sees an avatar of Lex—a version of the man who represents all the hate and trauma he had to overcome.
In a moment that defines why Tyler Hoechlin’s Superman is so special, he forgives him.
👉 See also: Who was the host on Family Feud? The legends and the short-lived runs
Lex was an addict of revenge. He had chances to walk away. His daughter, Elizabeth, begged him to let it go. He couldn't. He chose the "price" over his own family, and that's the real tragedy of this version. He won some battles—he killed Superman, for a while at least—but he lost the only thing that actually mattered.
Why This Version Ranks So High
If you look at the history of Lex Luthor on screen, Michael Rosenbaum is usually the gold standard for TV. He gave us the "descent into darkness." But Michael Cudlitz gave us the "darkness unleashed."
This Lex felt dangerous because he had nothing left to lose. He wasn't trying to be President. He wasn't trying to "save humanity" from an alien. He was just a hurt, angry man with enough money to make everyone else hurt too.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Writers:
If you're looking to dive deeper into this specific lore or perhaps writing your own analysis, keep these specific themes in mind:
- Watch the Flashbacks: Pay attention to how Lex acted before prison in the flashbacks. He was always a bully, but he had "finesse." The contrast shows exactly what those seventeen years did to his psyche.
- The Milton Fine Factor: This Lex isn't a tech genius. He relies on Milton Fine (a nod to Brainiac) for the gadgets. Understanding that Lex is the will and Milton is the brain changes how you view their "master plans."
- The Lois/Lex Dynamic: Most people focus on the Superman rivalry. In this show, Lex is Lois's villain first. Their debate on "The Godfrey Show" is just as intense as any physical fight with Doomsday.
The Superman and Lois Lex isn't just a villain; he's a cautionary tale about what happens when you let a grudge become your entire personality. He’s the most intimidating version of the character we’ve seen in years because he feels like someone you could actually meet in a dark alley—and that’s way scarier than a guy with a giant green rock.
💡 You might also like: Why Before and After 600 lb Life Updates Are Rarely What You Expect
To fully appreciate the arc, go back and re-watch the Season 3 finale alongside the first two episodes of Season 4. The transition from the "grizzled prisoner" to the "man who broke the Man of Steel" is one of the best-paced character evolutions in modern superhero TV.