Ever tried reading a story to a preschooler and realized, halfway through, that the original ending is actually kind of a nightmare? Hans Christian Andersen wasn’t exactly writing for the Nick Jr. demographic. He had a darker vibe. But when the Storybrook Village gang tackles the classics, things change. Super Why and The Little Mermaid is one of those specific crossover moments where PBS Kids takes a heavy, bittersweet legend and turns it into a lesson about friendship and communication.
It’s weirdly nostalgic. If you grew up watching Wyatt, Pig, Red, and Princess Pea, you know the drill. They jump into books to solve "super big" problems. But why this story? Why the mermaid? Honestly, it’s because the Little Mermaid is the poster child for someone who has a lot to say but literally loses her voice. For a show built entirely on the power of reading and words, that’s a goldmine.
The Problem in Storybrook Village
The episode kicks off like most others. Someone in the real world—well, the "real" animated world—is having a communication breakdown. Usually, it’s Pig or Red feeling left out or misunderstood. They head to the Book Club, the transformation sequence happens (we all remember the "Power to Read!" catchphrase), and they dive into the book to find a solution.
In the case of Super Why and The Little Mermaid, the conflict centers on the idea of belonging and being heard. Princess Pea usually leads the charge on these fairy-tale-themed adventures. They aren't just visiting the Disney version, either. Super Why tends to lean closer to the traditional aesthetic of the 1837 folk tale, though obviously, they skip the part where her feet feel like they're walking on knives. That’s a bit much for a four-year-old eating Cheerios.
Why This Episode Hits Differently
Most kids' shows just tell you to "be yourself." Super Why actually breaks down the mechanics of how to do that using grammar. It’s pretty clever when you think about it. By using the "Super Duper Computer" to find the "Super Letters," the show gamifies literacy.
In the Little Mermaid episode, the stakes feel surprisingly high. You have a character who wants to bridge two different worlds—land and sea. That’s a massive metaphor for childhood. One minute you’re a toddler, the next you’re expected to act like a "big kid." It’s scary.
The Word Power Breakdown
Super Why (Wyatt) uses his pointer to change the sentences in the book. This is the core "hook" of the show. In this specific story, the Mermaid is struggling because she can't talk to the Prince.
💡 You might also like: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
- Alpha Pig handles the "Lickety-Letter" identification, building the physical tools needed in the scene.
- Wonder Red brings the rhyming. This is crucial for phonemic awareness. She’ll tackle words like "wish," "fish," and "dish" to help move the plot along.
- Princess Presto focuses on spelling. She’s the one who literally writes the words into existence.
- Super Why is the closer. He changes the "story" by swapping out key words in a sentence to fix the character's mistake.
Instead of the Mermaid trading her voice for legs in a shady deal with a sea witch, the Super Readers help her find a way to express herself without giving up who she is. It’s a complete rewrite of the source material's tragic ending.
Addressing the "Little Mermaid" Controversy
Let's be real. People get very protective over fairy tales. Whenever a new version of The Little Mermaid comes out—whether it's the 1989 Disney classic, the 2023 live-action film, or an educational cartoon—the internet has opinions.
Some purists argue that softening these stories takes away their "bite." They think kids should know the Mermaid turns into sea foam. But Super Why isn't trying to be a literary scholar. It’s an intervention. The show’s entire premise is that stories are fluid. You can change the ending. You can change the words. You have agency.
That’s a powerful message for a kid who feels like they don't have a say in their daily schedule.
The Educational Impact of Interactive Media
Does watching Super Why and The Little Mermaid actually help a child read? Research from organizations like PBS Kids and various literacy studies suggest that "active" viewing—where kids shout out letters or guess the next rhyme—is significantly more effective than passive watching.
It’s about "scaffolding." You start with a letter (Alpha Pig), move to a sound (Wonder Red), then a word (Princess Presto), and finally a sentence (Super Why). It mirrors the way we actually learn to process language.
📖 Related: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
Decoding the Vocabulary
In this episode, the vocabulary focuses on "communication" words. Words like tell, show, and speak are highlighted. The show creators, including Angela Santomero (who also gave us Blue’s Clues and Daniel Tiger’s Neighborhood), are experts at this. They know that if a child understands the structure of a sentence, they can predict what comes next.
Predictability breeds confidence. Confidence breeds a kid who isn't afraid to pick up a book.
What Most People Get Wrong About Super Why
A lot of parents think the show is just about rote memorization of letters. It's not. If you watch the Little Mermaid episode closely, it's actually about reading comprehension.
It’s one thing to know that C-A-T spells cat. It’s another thing to understand that if you change the sentence "The cat sat on the mat" to "The cat sat on the moon," the entire story changes. Super Why teaches kids that they are the masters of the narrative.
The Little Mermaid's dilemma is solved not by magic, but by a "Power Answer." This is the takeaway that kids are supposed to apply to their own lives. When the Super Readers "fly" back to the real world, the child in the story uses the lesson they learned from the Mermaid to solve their own playground dispute.
How to Use This Episode for Learning at Home
If your kid is obsessed with this specific episode, don't just let the credits roll and move on. You can actually turn it into a pretty solid teaching moment without being "extra."
👉 See also: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
- Play "Sentence Swapper": Write a simple sentence like "The dog is big." Ask your child to change one word to make it silly. "The dog is purple." This is exactly what Super Why does.
- Talk about feelings: Ask why the Mermaid was sad. Was it because she couldn't talk? How would they feel if they couldn't use their words?
- Compare versions: If they’re old enough, read a different version of The Little Mermaid and ask how the Super Readers changed it.
It’s basically "Baby’s First Literary Criticism."
The Lasting Legacy of Storybrook Village
Super Why has been around since 2007. That’s an eternity in "kid years." The reason it survives, and why episodes like the Little Mermaid one are still streamed millions of times, is because the formula works. It respects the intelligence of the audience.
It doesn't talk down to them. It assumes they can handle the "big" words. It assumes they want to help.
The Little Mermaid isn't just a girl with a tail in this version; she’s a peer. She’s someone who needs a hand, and the viewers at home are the only ones who can provide the "Super Letters" to save the day. That kind of empowerment is rare in children's media.
Moving Forward With Literacy
If you’re looking to dive deeper into the world of Super Why or want to find more episodes that tackle complex fairy tales, there are a few things you can do right now.
Check out the official PBS Kids website or app. They often have interactive games that directly tie into the Super Why and The Little Mermaid episode. These games allow kids to practice the specific "Wonder Red" rhyming sounds featured in the show.
Beyond the screen, look for "Easy Reader" versions of these fairy tales at your local library. Transitioning from the animated Wyatt to a physical book is the ultimate goal of the series. When a child realizes that the characters they love on TV actually live in the books on their shelf, something clicks. That’s when a "viewer" becomes a "reader."
Next time you’re watching the Super Readers fly into a book, pay attention to the logic. It’s a masterclass in early childhood education disguised as a colorful adventure. And maybe, just maybe, it’ll make the original Hans Christian Andersen version a little less traumatizing when they finally encounter it in middle school.