You've probably been there. You are standing on Yo'ster Isle, the music is upbeat, and that smug red Yoshi is staring you down. You press the buttons. You think you're in the rhythm. Then, suddenly, Boshi pulls ahead by a mile and you're left wondering if your controller is broken or if you just suck at rhythm games. Honestly, the Super Mario RPG Yoshi race is one of those mini-games that feels incredibly simple until it isn't. It’s a literal bottleneck for players trying to 100% the game or just get those sweet, sweet Yoshi Cookies.
Most people mess this up because they treat it like a button-masher. It’s not. If you mash, you lose. If you panic, you lose. It’s about a very specific, somewhat clunky 1996 rhythm that persists even in the 2023 Nintendo Switch remake.
The Brutal Reality of Yo'ster Isle
Yo'ster Isle is a vibe, but the Mushroom Derby is a headache. When you first arrive after getting through Pipe Vault, the stakes feel low. You just want to help the green Yoshi take down Boshi, the "boss" Yoshi wearing sunglasses and a bad attitude. But the game doesn't give you a traditional tutorial. It gives you a beat.
The Super Mario RPG Yoshi race depends entirely on the alternating presses of the A and B buttons (or B and A depending on your layout). You have to hit them exactly on the beat of the background music. If you've ever played a rhythm game like Hi-Fi Rush or Ritual of the Necromancer, you might think you have an edge. You don't. The latency in Super Mario RPG—even the remake—has a specific "swing" to it.
📖 Related: Why the Dreki in God of War Ragnarok is Actually a Nightmare to Fight
Boshi is fast. He doesn't make many mistakes. To beat him the first time, you have to be near-perfect. This isn't just about speed; it's about staying "in the pocket" of the track. If you go too fast, Yoshi stumbles. If you go too slow, Boshi eats your dust.
Cracking the Rhythm of the Super Mario RPG Yoshi Race
Let’s get technical for a second. The music is a 4/4 beat. You are looking to press A on the first beat and B on the second. A-B, A-B, A-B.
I’ve seen people try to look at the visual cues. Don't do that. The visual of Yoshi moving is actually slightly decoupled from the rhythmic input required. If you watch Yoshi's feet, you’ll likely drift off-beat and lose your momentum. Instead, close your eyes—or at least blur them—and focus entirely on the percussion.
Using Cookies Effectively
You have a "boost" mechanic in the form of Yoshi Cookies. You start with a few, and you can earn more. When you use a cookie during the Super Mario RPG Yoshi race, Yoshi gets a massive burst of speed.
But here is where most players fail: they use the cookie when they are already behind.
In racing theory, using a boost to "catch up" is often less efficient than using a boost to "extend a lead." If you use a cookie while your rhythm is broken, you basically waste the speed. You need to establish the A-B rhythm first, get Yoshi moving at his base top speed, and then eat the cookie to redline the engine.
The Nintendo Switch Remake Differences
Is it easier on the Switch? Sorta. The 2023 version of Super Mario RPG added a visual metronome. There’s a little musical note icon that pulses. For some, this is a godsend. For others, it’s a distraction.
The remake also feels a bit "snappier" regarding input lag, especially if you're playing in handheld mode. If you're playing on a TV with high post-processing (like a standard Cinema mode), the input lag will absolutely destroy your chances in the Super Mario RPG Yoshi race. Switch your TV to "Game Mode" immediately. Those few milliseconds of delay are the difference between Yoshi leaping forward and Yoshi doing a pathetic little stumble.
Why Does Boshi Keep Winning?
Boshi is a cheater. Not literally, but his AI is programmed to maintain a very consistent pace that scales slightly based on how well you are doing.
The secret to the first race against him is to stay neck-and-neck until the very last stretch. If you blow all your cookies in the first three seconds, Boshi will often "catch up" through rubber-banding logic. Save at least one cookie for the final 25% of the track.
Also, let's talk about the gambling aspect. Once you beat Boshi, the race changes. It becomes a way to farm Yoshi Cookies, which are actually incredible in combat. They let you summon Yoshi to turn an enemy into an item. If you're struggling with some of the harder post-game bosses in the remake (like the 3D Culex fight), having a stockpile of cookies is a legitimate strategy.
Advanced Tactics for Constant Success
If you're looking to grind the Super Mario RPG Yoshi race for rewards, you need to master the "off-beat" recovery.
Sometimes you’ll hit the button a fraction of a second too early. You'll hear a specific "thud" sound instead of the crisp "ding" of a successful step. Most people keep trying to mash back into rhythm. Stop.
Take a half-second pause. Let the beat reset in your head. It is better to lose two steps of progress to regain your rhythm than to spend the next five seconds fumbling and moving at 10% speed.
- Tip 1: Tap your foot. Physical movement helps sync your brain to the internal clock of the game.
- Tip 2: Ignore the other Yoshis. Their animations are meant to distract you. Focus on your lane.
- Tip 3: Listen for the whistle. The start of the race is where most people lose because they start the A-B sequence too early. Wait for the "Go!" signal.
The Economic Impact of Yo'ster Isle
In the grand scheme of Super Mario RPG, the Yoshi race is the primary source of Yoshi Cookies and, by extension, the Red Essence (which makes a character invincible for 3 turns).
If you bet on the races later in the game, you can turn a small investment into a massive hoard of items. It’s essentially the game’s version of a stock market, but with more dinosaurs. If you're playing the original SNES version, the rewards are slightly stingier, but the principle remains. You want to win not just for pride, but for the tactical advantage those cookies provide in Smithy's Factory.
The odds change. Pay attention to what the NPCs say. Sometimes a certain Yoshi is "feeling it" today. While the rhythm game is skill-based, the betting side is pure data gathering.
Common Misconceptions
People think you can win by just hitting A and B simultaneously. You can't. The game specifically checks for alternating inputs.
Another myth is that certain controllers make it easier. While a D-pad is irrelevant here, the travel distance of your face buttons matters. If you're using a controller with "mushy" buttons, you might find it harder to keep the tempo than on a mechanical controller or the standard Joy-Cons.
Honestly, the Super Mario RPG Yoshi race isn't about how fast your fingers move. It’s about how well you can keep a cool head while a catchy, repetitive song tries to distract you.
How to Handle the "Boshi Depression"
Losing to Boshi feels bad. He’s mean, he wears a collar, and he won't let the other Yoshis race. If you're stuck, leave the island. Go grind some levels in the Land's End or go talk to the Chancellor.
Coming back with a fresh set of ears is often the best way to beat a rhythm-based roadblock. The "muscle memory" of failing can actually hinder you. You start subconsciously expecting to fail at the same spot every time. Break the cycle.
Step-by-Step Execution for your Next Attempt
- Check your settings: Ensure your TV is in Game Mode. If on Switch, handheld is often more responsive for rhythm.
- The Start: Do not press anything during the countdown. Wait for the "GO".
- The Rhythm: Start a steady A, B, A, B. Think of it like a heartbeat. Thump-thump, thump-thump.
- The Mid-Race: If Boshi pulls ahead, do not panic. Stay in the rhythm.
- The Boost: When you have about a third of the track left, and you are firmly in the rhythm, spam the "Eat Cookie" button (usually Y) while maintaining the A-B alternation.
- The Finish: Keep the rhythm all the way across the line. Do not stop until the camera cuts.
Winning the Super Mario RPG Yoshi race unlocks the ability to ride Yoshi around the island, which is mostly a cosmetic flex, but it also opens up the "Fat Yoshi" side quest where you feed a baby Yoshi enough cookies to get rare items.
The real prize isn't the race itself; it's what the race allows you to do. You’re becoming a part of the Yo'ster Isle ecosystem. You're helping the community. And most importantly, you're shutting Boshi up.
Actionable Insights for the Derby
To truly master this, you need to practice away from the stakes.
Go to the race track and just practice the A-B rhythm without betting anything. Get to the point where you can hold the rhythm for 30 seconds straight without a single stumble.
Once the mechanical skill is second nature, the "pressure" of the race disappears. You'll find that Boshi isn't actually that fast; you were just slowing yourself down.
Grab your controller. Head back to the island. Listen to the beat. You’ve got this.