Lightning doesn't usually strike the same place twice, especially in the NFL. But on February 5, 2012, at Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis, it did. The New York Giants pulled off another heist. They beat the New England Patriots 21-17. It was basically a repeat of their 2008 shocker, and honestly, it cemented Eli Manning as the ultimate kryptonite for the Tom Brady-Bill Belichick dynasty.
Most people remember the "accidental" touchdown at the end. Or maybe that wild sideline catch. But the Super Bowl XLVI winner wasn't decided by luck. It was a weird, grinding game where the Giants’ defensive line harassed Brady just enough to keep the door open for Eli’s late-game magic.
The Weirdest Start in Super Bowl History
You’ve probably seen some strange opening plays, but this was something else. On the Patriots' very first offensive snap, Tom Brady dropped back into his own end zone. Pressure from Justin Tuck was immediate. Brady, panicking a bit, heaved the ball deep down the middle. There wasn't a receiver within 20 yards.
The officials didn't hesitate. Intentional grounding. Since he was in the end zone, that’s an automatic safety.
The Giants took a 2-0 lead without even touching the ball on offense. It felt like a bad omen for New England from the jump. New York capitalized on the momentum, with Eli Manning connecting with Victor Cruz for a 2-yard touchdown later in the first quarter. Suddenly, it was 9-0. The Patriots looked rattled, but you can never count out a team coached by Belichick.
Tom Brady’s Response and the Middle-Game Grind
New England didn't just roll over. Far from it. Brady eventually found his rhythm and went on a tear, completing a Super Bowl record 16 consecutive passes at one point. He led a massive 96-yard drive right before halftime, hitting Danny Woodhead for a touchdown to take a 10-9 lead.
💡 You might also like: NFL Pick 'em Predictions: Why You're Probably Overthinking the Divisional Round
When the second half started, the Patriots kept pouring it on. Aaron Hernandez caught a 12-yard touchdown pass, and it looked like the rout was on at 17-9.
The Giants' defense, led by Jason Pierre-Paul and Osi Umenyiora, was bending but not quite breaking. They forced the Patriots to settle for punts or turnovers later in the game. Chase Blackburn—a linebacker who was literally teaching middle school math a few weeks prior before being re-signed—made a leaping interception on a deep ball intended for Rob Gronkowski. That play changed everything. It kept the Giants within striking distance while their offense struggled to find the end zone, settling for two Lawrence Tynes field goals to make it 17-15.
The Manningham Catch: "The Throw" Nobody Talks About Enough
Everyone remembers David Tyree’s Helmet Catch from 2008. It was miraculous and lucky. But in 2012, Eli Manning made a throw that was pure, unadulterated skill.
With 3:46 left and the Giants pinned at their own 12-yard line, Eli looked deep down the left sideline. Mario Manningham was streaking toward the boundary. Eli let go of a ball that traveled nearly 40 yards in the air, dropping it into a bucket over Manningham’s shoulder. Two Patriots defenders were draped all over him.
Manningham managed to keep both feet in bounds. Belichick challenged it, but the replay showed the catch was perfect.
📖 Related: Why the Marlins Won World Series Titles Twice and Then Disappeared
That 38-yard gain flipped the field. It was the moment the Patriots' sideline knew they were in trouble. Eli was 10-of-14 for 118 yards in that fourth quarter alone. He was cold-blooded.
The Touchdown Ahmad Bradshaw Didn't Want to Score
This is where the game gets truly bizarre. The Giants marched down to the New England 6-yard line with about a minute left. The Patriots had almost no timeouts.
Bill Belichick made a high-stakes coaching decision: he told his defense to let the Giants score. Why? Because if the Giants ran the clock down and kicked a field goal with 3 seconds left, Brady would never get the ball back. By letting them score, Brady would at least have a minute to try for a comeback.
Ahmad Bradshaw took the handoff and realized halfway through the run that the middle of the field was a vacuum. He tried to stop. He literally tried to sit down at the one-yard line. But his momentum carried him, and he tumbled backward into the end zone.
Giants lead 21-17. The two-point conversion failed.
👉 See also: Why Funny Fantasy Football Names Actually Win Leagues
Brady had 57 seconds. He got them to midfield. On the final play, he launched a Hail Mary into a crowded end zone. The ball was tipped. It hovered in the air for what felt like an eternity before falling just inches away from a diving Rob Gronkowski.
Game over. Giants win.
Why Super Bowl XLVI Still Matters Today
The Super Bowl XLVI winner New York Giants finished the regular season 9-7. They are still the only team to win a Super Bowl after winning fewer than 10 games in a 16-game season. It’s a testament to the "just get in" philosophy of the NFL playoffs.
Eli Manning became one of only five players at the time to win multiple Super Bowl MVPs. He proved that his first win wasn't a fluke. For the Patriots, it was a bitter pill. It remains one of the few times the "Patriot Way" was solved by a team that simply refused to be intimidated by the stage.
Actionable Insights for Football Fans
- Watch the Manningham Catch again: If you want to understand elite quarterbacking, ignore the Helmet Catch and watch the Manningham throw. It’s a masterclass in ball placement.
- Study the 2011 Giants' Path: They were 7-7 at one point. It’s the best evidence ever that a hot defense in January matters more than a dominant record in October.
- Analyze the "Let Them Score" Strategy: Coaches still debate Belichick’s choice to give up the TD. It was mathematically sound, but it’s a reminder that in the Super Bowl, you’re often choosing between two bad options.
The Giants proved that a relentless pass rush and a calm quarterback are the ultimate equalizers against any dynasty.