Look, if you ask a Philadelphia Eagles fan about February 12, 2023, you’re gonna get an earful. It’s been three years since State Farm Stadium in Glendale, Arizona, hosted one of the most statistically efficient yet controversial championship games in modern history. Super Bowl LVII had everything. We had the Kelce brothers facing off. We had Patrick Mahomes playing on one good ankle. We had Rihanna’s floating platforms.
But mostly, we had a very slippery grass field and a defensive holding call that still feels like a gut punch to the city of Philly.
The Kansas City Chiefs won 38-35. It was a high-scoring masterpiece, honestly. But the box score doesn't tell the whole story of how the game actually felt while it was happening. You had Jalen Hurts playing the game of his life, accounting for four touchdowns and looking every bit the MVP. Then you had Mahomes, who looked like he was walking on broken glass by the fourth quarter, somehow scrambling for 26 yards to set up the game-winning kick.
It was a clash of titans. It was also a mess.
The "Sodfather" and the Great Glendale Slip-and-Slide
One thing people forget about Super Bowl LVII is that the players couldn't stay on their feet. It was embarrassing for the NFL. This wasn't some high school field in the rain; it was a $800,000 turf project overseen by George Toma, the legendary "Sodfather" who had prepared the grass for every single Super Bowl up to that point.
The grass was Tahoma 31. It’s a hybrid bermudagrass meant to be tough. Instead, it was like an ice rink. You saw Haason Reddick and Josh Sweat—the guys who made the Eagles' pass rush legendary that season—sliding past Mahomes like they were on a slip-and-slide. Players were changing cleats mid-game. It neutralized the most dangerous part of the Eagles' defense.
✨ Don't miss: Nebraska Cornhuskers Women's Basketball: What Really Happened This Season
Toma eventually blamed the league’s "over-watering" and the fact that they rolled the field into the stadium too late, trapping moisture under a giant tarp for the halftime show rehearsals. It’s a weird, technical detail that actually decided the game. If the Eagles' pass rush can keep their footing, does Mahomes have time to find Travis Kelce in the end zone? Probably not.
James Bradberry and the Penalty Heard 'Round the World
We have to talk about the holding call. You know the one.
Third-and-8. Less than two minutes left. The game is tied 35-35. Mahomes throws an incomplete pass to JuJu Smith-Schuster. The Eagles think they’re getting the ball back with enough time for Hurts to march down the field for a legendary finish. Then, the yellow flag hits the turf.
Carl Cheffers’ officiating crew called defensive holding on James Bradberry. It gave the Chiefs a fresh set of downs, allowed them to bleed the clock, and set up Harrison Butker for a chip-shot field goal.
Was there a tug? Yeah. Bradberry actually admitted it after the game, which was incredibly classy of him. He said, "I pulled on his jersey. They called it. I was hoping they would let it ride." But "letting it ride" is exactly what fans expected in that moment. Throughout the entire game, the refs had been letting the secondary play physical. To call a "marginal" hold at that specific moment felt inconsistent with the rest of the game's flow. It felt like the air was sucked out of the building.
🔗 Read more: Nebraska Basketball Women's Schedule: What Actually Matters This Season
Mahomes, the High Ankle Sprain, and Pure Grit
Patrick Mahomes is a freak of nature. People take his greatness for granted now, but what he did in Super Bowl LVII was objectively insane. He re-injured his right high ankle sprain late in the second quarter. You could see him grimacing on the sidelines. He looked done.
Then he came out for the second half and went 13-of-14 passing.
The Chiefs' second-half drives were clinical:
- Touchdown (10 plays, 75 yards)
- Touchdown (9 plays, 75 yards)
- Touchdown (12 plays, 75 yards)
- Field Goal (the winner)
They didn't punt once in the second half. Not once. Andy Reid and Eric Bieniemy cooked up a masterpiece of play-calling, specifically those "corn dog" motions that left Kadarius Toney and Skyy Moore wide open for touchdowns. The Eagles' defense, which had been historic all year, looked completely lost against those jet sweep fakes.
The Hurts Performance We Shouldn't Forget
Usually, the losing quarterback gets lost in the shuffle. We shouldn't let that happen here. Jalen Hurts was the best player on the field for a lot of that night. He threw for 304 yards and ran for 70. He scored three rushing touchdowns, tying a Super Bowl record. He even converted a two-point conversion to tie the game late.
💡 You might also like: Missouri vs Alabama Football: What Really Happened at Faurot Field
There was that one fumble, though. He dropped the ball without being hit in the second quarter, and Nick Bolton scooped it up for a 36-yard touchdown. In a game decided by three points, that unforced error was the difference. It’s the cruel reality of the Super Bowl: you can play a 9.5 out of 10 game, but that 0.5 can kill you.
Why This Game Still Matters Three Years Later
Super Bowl LVII wasn't just another game. It was the moment the Chiefs officially became a "dynasty" in the eyes of the public, securing their second ring in four years. It also changed how we talk about officiating in big moments.
It also served as a massive lesson in roster construction. The Eagles had the better "on-paper" roster, but the Chiefs had the better "situational" execution. They exploited the Eagles' tendency to over-pursue. They used the slick field to their advantage by using quick, horizontal passes that didn't require Mahomes to plant his injured ankle for long-developing deep balls.
Critical Takeaways for Football Students
If you're looking back at this game to understand the modern NFL, look at the "Middle Eight." This is the four minutes before halftime and the four minutes after. The Eagles were leading 24-14 at half. They felt in control. But the Chiefs’ ability to score immediately after the break shifted the momentum entirely.
- Adaptability is king. Andy Reid didn't try to run the same offense in the second half. He saw the Eagles' pass rush was struggling with footing and started using misdirection.
- The "Tush Push" was born here. We saw the early dominance of the Eagles' short-yardage run game, which would go on to spark years of league-wide debate and attempted bans.
- Health is relative. Mahomes wasn't 100%, but he was 100% when the play broke down. High ankle sprains usually sideline players for a month; he won a ring on one in three weeks.
Looking back, Super Bowl LVII was a tragedy for Philly and a triumph for the Mahomes-Reid era. It was a game of inches, a game of slips, and a game that proved why you never, ever bet against Kansas City in the second half.
How to Apply These Insights Today
If you're analyzing current NFL trends or betting on upcoming seasons, use Super Bowl LVII as your case study for a few specific things. First, watch the turf reports. Since that game, teams and analysts pay much closer attention to the specific sod used in retractable-roof stadiums. Second, understand that "elite" defenses can be neutralized by specific motion schemes. The "Corn Dog" play wasn't a fluke; it was a schematic exploit of how modern defenses pass off receivers in the red zone. Finally, remember that in the Super Bowl, the team that makes fewer mistakes usually wins, regardless of who has more yards. Hurts had more total yardage, but Mahomes had zero turnovers. That is the only stat that really mattered when the confetti fell.