The Super Bowl isn't just about the halftime show or the $7 million commercials. For most of us, it’s about that crinkled piece of poster board taped to the breakroom wall or the digital grid lighting up our group chats. You know the one. A hundred squares. Ten numbers across. Ten numbers down. A Super Bowl game board is basically the pulse of the party. It turns people who don’t know a tight end from a tailback into screaming fanatics because they suddenly need the kicker to miss an extra point so the score ends in a four and a seven.
It's gambling, sure. But it’s the "socially acceptable" kind that bridges the gap between die-hard fans and people who are just there for the seven-layer dip.
The Math Behind the Madness
Most people think every square on a Super Bowl game board has an equal shot. They’re wrong. Dead wrong. If you’ve ever drawn a 2 and a 5, you might as well just set your entry fee on fire. Football scoring happens in chunks—seven for a touchdown and PAT, three for a field goal. Because of that, certain number combinations are statistical gold mines.
Data from decades of NFL games shows that 0, 3, and 7 are the holy trinity of squares. Think about it. Games often end 17-10, 24-17, or 20-13. If you land the 7-0 square, you are sitting on a premium piece of real estate. On the flip side, numbers like 2, 5, and 8 are the "dead zones" of the grid. To get an 8, you usually need a missed extra point, a weird two-point conversion, or a safety. Safeties are rare. Like, "happened only nine times in Super Bowl history" rare.
The most common final digit for a winning team? Seven. It has appeared in roughly 20% of all Super Bowl quarters. Zero is right behind it. If you’re playing in a "scratch-off" style board where you pick your squares before the numbers are drawn, you’re essentially praying to the gods of probability.
Setting Up Your Super Bowl Game Board Without the Drama
If you’re the one running the pool this year, don't overcomplicate it. You need a 10x10 grid. That gives you 100 squares. You sell them for a set price—five bucks, twenty bucks, whatever your friends can afford without getting salty.
Once the squares are filled, and only then, do you draw the numbers.
Take ten pieces of paper. Write 0 through 9 on them. Shake them up in a hat (or a Solo cup, let's be real). Draw them one by one to fill the top row, which represents the AFC team. Do it again for the side column for the NFC team.
✨ Don't miss: Red Sox vs Yankees: What Most People Get Wrong About Baseball's Biggest Feud
Pro tip: Don't let people pick their own numbers. That’s how you end up with a fistfight over who gets the 7-3 square. Randomize it. It’s the only way to keep things fair.
Different Ways to Pay Out
There isn't just one way to win. Most boards pay out at the end of the first, second, and third quarters, with the biggest chunk of the pot going to the final score.
Some people like to do "touches." This is a bit more chaotic. In a "touch" system, you pay out every time the score changes. It keeps people glued to the screen, but it’s a nightmare for the person holding the money. Honestly, stick to the quarter-by-quarter payouts. It’s cleaner.
Another variation is the "Reverse" win. If the score is 14-7, the person with 4-7 wins the main pot, but maybe the person with 7-4 gets their five dollars back. It’s a nice way to keep more people involved so they don't tune out by halftime when the score is a blowout.
Why the "Bad" Numbers Aren't Always a Death Sentence
The NFL has changed. It's not the 1970s anymore. Kickers are missing more extra points because the league moved the line back in 2015. Coaches are going for two-point conversions way more often, driven by "analytics" and aggressive play-calling.
What does that mean for your Super Bowl game board?
It means the "bad" numbers like 2, 5, and 8 are actually becoming more viable. A missed PAT turns a 7 into a 6. A successful two-point conversion turns a 7 into an 8. Suddenly, those garbage squares have life. In Super Bowl LVII, the Chiefs beat the Eagles 38-35. Look at those digits. An 8 and a 5. Twenty years ago, people would have laughed at that square. Now? It’s a winning ticket.
🔗 Read more: OU Football Depth Chart 2025: Why Most Fans Are Getting the Roster Wrong
Avoiding the "Legal" Headaches
We have to talk about the elephant in the room. Is this legal?
In most states, "social gambling" is a gray area but generally ignored as long as the person running the board isn't taking a "rake." That’s gambling lingo for taking a cut of the money for themselves. If $500 goes in, $100% of that $500 should go back out to the winners. If you start charging a "hosting fee," you’ve moved from a friendly office pool to an illegal sportsbook operation. Don't be that person. Keep it 100% payout, and you’re usually fine under the social gambling carve-outs in places like Iowa, Illinois, and several other states.
But hey, I'm a writer, not your lawyer. Check your local statutes if you’re worried about the feds knocking down your door over a $20 square.
The Strategy of Square Selection
If you are in a league where you actually get to pick your physical square location before numbers are assigned, where should you go?
Statistically, it shouldn't matter if the numbers are drawn randomly later. However, humans are weird. We have "lucky" spots. Many people gravitate toward the corners or the exact center. If you want to be different, pick the edges.
If you are playing in a "weighted" board—where you pay more for better numbers—you have to do a cost-benefit analysis. Is the 7-7 square worth five times the price of the 2-2 square? Usually, no. The value is often found in the "middle" numbers like 4 and 1. They hit more often than people realize, especially with the weird scoring of the modern game.
Logistics Matter
Don't use a whiteboard. Someone will lean against it, and the 4 will turn into a smudge, and by the fourth quarter, you’ll have two people claiming they own the same square. Use a permanent marker on poster board. Better yet, use one of the dozens of digital Super Bowl game board apps. They track everything, handle the random number generation, and send notifications to everyone's phone. It saves a lot of "Who has the 7?" yelling.
💡 You might also like: NL Rookie of the Year 2025: Why Drake Baldwin Actually Deserved the Hardware
Common Misconceptions About the Grid
One of the biggest myths is that you want the numbers of the team you're rooting for. No. You want the numbers that happen. If you’re a 49ers fan but you have the Chiefs' score as a 0 and the Niners as a 3, you should be rooting for a very specific, perhaps frustrating, scoreline. It creates this weird cognitive dissonance where you’re cheering against your own team's touchdown because it would ruin your "7" and turn it into a "4."
That’s the beauty of it. It creates drama where there shouldn't be any.
Also, the final score isn't always the "End of 4th Quarter" score. If the game goes into overtime, the final score is the one that matters for the big payout. This is crucial. Some people try to argue that the "4th Quarter" winner and the "Final Score" winner are two different things. Usually, the "Final Score" replaces the 4th quarter payout. Make sure you clarify this before the kickoff. Ambiguity is the enemy of fun.
The Social Aspect
I’ve seen Super Bowl game boards save parties. We've all been to those Super Bowls where one team is up by 30 points and everyone is just waiting for the Rihanna or Usher or whoever is performing to finish so they can go home. But if you have the 8-3 square and the score is 35-10, you are one garbage-time safety away from a windfall. You stay engaged. You scream at the TV during a meaningless punt.
It makes the game's "dead time" actually matter.
Final Steps for a Perfect Game Day
If you want to run this right, you need to move fast. The closer we get to kickoff, the harder it is to fill 100 squares.
- Print your grid early. Don't wait until Sunday morning.
- Set a hard deadline. All squares must be paid for by Saturday night. Nothing kills the vibe like chasing down "Dave from Accounting" for ten bucks while the national anthem is playing.
- Take a photo. Once the numbers are drawn and written down, take a photo and text it to every single person in the pool. This prevents any "adjustments" to the board later in the night.
The goal here is simple: fun. The Super Bowl game board is a tradition because it works. It’s a low-stakes way to add high-stakes energy to the biggest sporting event of the year. Get your grid, find a Sharpie, and pray you don't end up with a 5 and a 2. Even in the modern NFL, that’s a tough hill to climb.
Make sure you have a clear plan for what happens if a square isn't sold. Usually, the "house" (the pot) keeps it. If an unsold square wins, the money can either roll over to the next quarter or be donated to charity. Decide that now, not when the winning touchdown is scored. It keeps the vibes high and the arguments low. Now go find some poster board.