It is a long walk to the end of the world. Or at least, it feels that way when you're trekking down Conover Street toward the harbor, the wind whipping off the Upper New York Bay and smelling of salt, rust, and heavy industry. You pass the IKEA, you pass the Civil War-era warehouses, and eventually, you hit a small, unassuming spot that looks like it might have been forgotten by time.
Sunny’s Conover Street Brooklyn NY isn't just a bar. Honestly, calling it a "bar" feels a bit like calling the Grand Canyon a hole in the dirt.
It's a living room. It's a temple. It's a place where, if you sit long enough, the ghost of a longshoreman might buy you a beer, or a world-class jazz violinist might ask you to hold their bow while they adjust their tuner. It has been there since 1890. Think about that. When this place opened, people were still getting around on horses and the Brooklyn Bridge was basically brand new.
The Secret History of 253 Conover Street
You’ve probably heard the name Sunny Balzano. He was the man who made this place a legend. He was a painter, a beatnik, and a guy who seemed to have a gravitational pull that attracted every soul in search of something real.
Sunny didn't just inherit a family business; he curated a vibe that was impossible to replicate. Back in the day, the bar was known as John’s Restaurant and Bar. It served the men who worked the docks—stevedores and sailors who needed a stiff drink after a shift in the holds of massive cargo ships. But when the shipping industry moved to New Jersey, Red Hook started to crumble.
Sunny came back in the 80s and 90s to take care of his family. He eventually turned the place into something called the Red Hook Yacht and Kayak Club.
✨ Don't miss: Finding Real Counts Kustoms Cars for Sale Without Getting Scammed
That sounds fancy. It wasn't.
Basically, they didn't have a liquor license for a while, so it operated as a "social club." You’d walk in, put your name on a little index card with a maritime drawing on it, and make a "donation" for your drinks. Usually about three bucks. It was the best-kept secret in New York until, well, it wasn't. The city eventually caught on, but by then, the community was so invested that they helped the bar get legal and stay alive.
Why We Almost Lost It
If you want to understand the soul of Sunny’s Conover Street Brooklyn NY, you have to talk about the water. In 2012, Hurricane Sandy decided to remind Red Hook exactly how close it lives to the edge.
The surge sent feet of murky, oily harbor water into the bar. It destroyed the floors, the electrical, and decades of accumulated knick-knacks. For most places, that would have been the end. But the Red Hook community is different. They didn't just send "thoughts and prayers." They raised over $100,000. They showed up with mops and hammers.
Tone Balzano Johansen, Sunny’s widow and the current heartbeat of the place, led the charge. She didn't just want to rebuild a business; she wanted to save a sanctuary. Today, the bar is thriving. It’s been recognized as one of the most inspiring disaster comebacks in the city, and for good reason. You can still see the high-water marks if you know where to look, but the spirit of the place is bone-dry and stronger than ever.
🔗 Read more: Finding Obituaries in Kalamazoo MI: Where to Look When the News Moves Online
What to Expect on a Saturday Night
Don't go there looking for a craft cocktail with a sprig of artisanal lavender. Seriously, don't.
It’s cash only. The beer is cold. The lighting is low. And the back room is usually vibrating with the sound of Tone’s Bluegrass Jam.
One of the weirdest and most beautiful things about Sunny’s is the lack of a TV. Tone is pretty firm about this. If you want to watch the game, go home. If you want to talk to a stranger about their life, their art, or the way the light hits the cranes across the water, you’re in the right place.
- The Vibe: Dusty, cluttered, and incredibly warm.
- The Music: Bluegrass, Western Swing, and Jazz. It’s almost always live.
- The Crowd: A mix of local old-timers, artists who moved in twenty years ago, and tourists who look slightly lost but very happy.
The interior is like a museum of things that shouldn't matter but do. There are model ships in glass cases. There are paintings by Sunny himself hanging on the walls. There's a little headless horse painting that has become part of the bar's lore. It’s the kind of place where you feel like you’ve been before, even if it’s your first time.
Is it Still "Hidden" in 2026?
Look, the "secret" has been out for a long time. There are documentaries being made about it, and there was even an immersive play called The Wind and the Rain that staged performances on a barge nearby recently.
💡 You might also like: Finding MAC Cool Toned Lipsticks That Don’t Turn Orange on You
But somehow, Sunny’s manages to stay authentic. It’s too far from the subway for casual "scenestealers" to bother with it most of the time. You have to want to be at Sunny's. You have to commit to the trip.
Whether you’re coming for Smokey’s Roundup on a Wednesday or just a quiet afternoon pint on a Tuesday, the bar remains a testament to what makes Brooklyn actually special. It’s not the expensive condos or the $15 lattes. It’s the persistence of a 130-year-old floorboard that refuses to stop creaking.
Tips for Your Visit
- Bring Cash: Seriously. They don't want to see your Apple Pay.
- Check the Calendar: The music is a huge part of the experience. Check their site before you trek out there.
- Respect the Space: It’s a neighborhood anchor. Be cool.
- Explore Red Hook: Since you're already at the end of the world, walk over to the Waterfront Museum or grab some food at the Red Hook Tavern nearby.
If you’re planning to visit, your best bet is to take the B61 bus or just grab a car service if you’re coming from further out. Most drivers know exactly where it is. Once you’re there, turn your phone off. Put it in your pocket. Order a drink, find a corner, and just listen. That’s how you actually experience Sunny’s.
You should start by checking their official calendar for the next live bluegrass session, as those nights offer the most authentic glimpse into the bar's community spirit.