When CMT announced they were doing a scripted series about the birth of rock ‘n’ roll, people weren't exactly sure what to expect. This wasn't just another Elvis biopic. It was meant to be the sprawling, messy story of a specific moment in Memphis history. Basically, it’s the story of Sam Phillips and the "Million Dollar Quartet" before they were icons.
But when you look at the Sun Records TV series cast, you realize the producers took a massive gamble. Instead of stuffing the screen with A-list cameos, they went for a mix of established character actors and total unknowns who could actually play the instruments.
It worked. Sorta.
The show only lasted one season in 2017, but the casting remains one of the most interesting "what-ifs" in recent TV history.
The Man Who Made the Magic: Chad Michael Murray as Sam Phillips
Honestly, seeing Chad Michael Murray—the guy from One Tree Hill—playing a 1950s visionary was a bit of a shock at first. But Murray actually nailed the frantic, obsessive energy of Sam Phillips. He played Sam as a man constantly on the verge of either a nervous breakdown or a world-changing discovery.
Most people don’t realize how much the show leans on his performance. While the musicians are the "hooks," Phillips is the glue. Murray’s portrayal focused on Sam's affair with Marion Keisker and his struggle to keep a tiny independent label afloat in a segregated South.
He didn't play him like a hero. He played him like a hustler.
Finding the King: Drake Milligan as Elvis Presley
Casting Elvis is a nightmare. Do you go for a lookalike? An impressionist? A serious actor?
The show found Drake Milligan. At the time, Milligan was an 18-year-old from Texas who had mostly done Elvis tributes. He wasn't a "trained actor" in the traditional Hollywood sense, but he had the lip curl and the vocal phrasing down to a science.
The Sun Records TV series cast needed someone who could show Elvis before the jumpsuits—the shy, awkward kid from Lauderdale Courts who was obsessed with the music coming out of the Black churches and clubs on Beale Street. Milligan’s performance was surprisingly grounded. He didn’t do the "Vegas caricature" that so many others fall into.
Funny enough, Milligan later went on to become a country star in his own right, even appearing on America's Got Talent. If you watch the show now, you’re basically seeing his origin story as a performer.
👉 See also: Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade: What Most People Get Wrong About the 100th Anniversary
The Rest of the Million Dollar Quartet
You can't have Sun Records without the other three legends. The show did a great job of making them feel like distinct humans rather than just faces on a Mount Rushmore of music.
- Kevin Fonteyne as Johnny Cash: Fonteyne had the tough job of following Joaquin Phoenix’s legendary turn as Cash. He played "J.R." during his Air Force days in Germany, showing the Man in Black before he actually wore black. It’s a softer, more uncertain version of Cash than we usually see.
- Christian Lees as Jerry Lee Lewis: This was probably the most energetic performance in the whole series. Christian Lees (and his twin brother Jonah, who played Jimmy Swaggart) brought that wild, Pentecostal-meets-profane energy that defined "The Killer."
- Dustin Ingram as Carl Perkins: Perkins is often the "forgotten" member of the quartet, but Ingram played him with a palpable sense of frustration. He was the guy who had the talent but kept seeing others—especially Elvis—get the spotlight he felt he deserved.
The Supporting Players You Forgot
While the "Big Four" get the headlines, the supporting Sun Records TV series cast is where the show’s texture really came from.
Billy Gardell, known for Mike & Molly, played Colonel Tom Parker. He was perfect as the predatory, carnival-barker version of the Colonel. He played him like a man who would sell his own soul if there was a 25% commission in it.
Then there’s Margaret Anne Florence as Marion Keisker. Most history books gloss over her, but she was arguably the person who actually "discovered" Elvis by pushing Sam to listen to his demo. The show puts her front and center, highlighting the complicated power dynamics at the studio.
And we have to mention Keir O'Donnell as Dewey Phillips. He was the DJ who first played "That's All Right" on the radio. O'Donnell played him with a high-speed, manic intensity that makes you understand why Memphis radio was so revolutionary at the time.
Why the Show Didn't Last
So, if the cast was so good, why did it get canceled after eight episodes?
It basically came down to branding and pacing. CMT was trying to pivot to "prestige" scripted drama, but the show moved a bit slowly for a general audience. It spent a lot of time on the historical context of the Civil Rights movement and the technical aspects of recording.
Some fans also felt the show took too many liberties with the timeline. For instance, the show depicts Sam Phillips having an affair with Marion Keisker almost immediately, which is a point of contention for music historians who prefer to focus on their professional partnership.
Despite the short run, the show remains a cult favorite for music nerds. It’s one of the few times a TV show actually tried to get the "sound" of the era right, using period-accurate equipment and live performances.
Where to See Them Now
If you want to dive deeper into the work of this cast, there are a few places to go.
- Watch the show: It’s often available on streaming platforms like Amazon Prime or the CMT app. It’s worth a watch just for the musical sequences.
- Follow Drake Milligan: His music career exploded after the show. He’s a legitimate country artist now, and you can hear the Elvis influence in his phrasing.
- Check out the real Sun Studio: If you’re ever in Memphis, you can tour the actual room at 706 Union Avenue where these people stood. It’s tiny. It’s cramped. And when you stand there, you realize how well the show's production design actually captured the space.
The Sun Records TV series cast did something difficult: they made icons feel like people. They showed the sweat, the mistakes, and the sheer luck that went into creating the music that changed the world. Even if we only got one season, it’s a pretty solid tribute to the Memphis sound.
To get the most out of your Sun Records deep dive, start by listening to the original "Million Dollar Quartet" recordings from December 4, 1956. Comparing those raw, spontaneous sessions to the dramatized versions in the show gives you a real appreciation for what these actors were trying to capture—the moment where country, gospel, and R&B collided to create something entirely new.