Before she was writing about the frozen tundra of Alaska in The Great Alone or the harrowing French resistance in The Nightingale, Kristin Hannah was already the queen of making people cry in public. Honestly, if you haven’t sat in a coffee shop with a Hannah book feeling that weird prickle in your eyes, you’re probably made of stone. Summer Island is one of those early-2000s gems that often gets overshadowed by her more recent, massive historical epics. But it shouldn't be.
It’s messy. It’s loud. It’s kinda heartbreaking.
Basically, the story centers on Nora Bridge and her daughter, Ruby. Nora is a high-profile advice columnist—think a mix of Dr. Laura and Oprah—who built a career on being "the moral compass" of America. But here’s the kicker: she has a past that’s about as clean as a mud puddle. Years ago, Nora walked out on her husband and two daughters. She just left. No note, no explanation, just a gaping hole where a mother used to be. When a scandal involving a former lover and some explicit photos breaks, Nora’s perfect life implodes.
She flees to Summer Island, a fictional but vivid spot in Washington’s San Juan Islands.
Ruby, her youngest daughter, is a struggling stand-up comedian in L.A. who uses her "mommy issues" as her entire act. When she gets offered a fat paycheck by a tabloid to write a "Mommy Dearest" tell-all, she takes it. She heads to the island under the guise of nursing her mother back to health after a car accident. But, as you’ve probably guessed, things get complicated when the "villain" in your head turns out to be a real human being.
Why the Summer Island Backstory Hits Different
Most people think this is just another beach read because of the title. It's not.
🔗 Read more: The Name of This Band Is Talking Heads: Why This Live Album Still Beats the Studio Records
The San Juan Islands are real, and Kristin Hannah paints them with this lush, salt-air atmosphere that makes you want to pack a bag immediately. But the story itself is heavy. We’re talking about abandonment, terminal illness, and the toxic nature of secrets. One of the best characters isn't even a Bridge; it’s Eric, the brother of Ruby’s first love, Dean. Eric is a gay man facing the end of his life, and his subplot brings a groundedness to the book that balances out the high-drama mother-daughter feuding.
The Problem With the "Perfect" Ending
Critics and readers often argue about the ending of Summer Island. Some say it’s too neat. You know the type—where years of trauma are suddenly solved because of a nice sunset and a few honest conversations.
- The Pro-Forgiveness Side: They argue that the book shows how time and perspective change things. Ruby sees Nora not just as "Mom," but as a woman who made mistakes.
- The Cynic’s View: Some readers feel Ruby lets Nora off the hook too easily. Leaving your kids for over a decade isn’t something a few weeks on an island can fix.
Honestly, both are right. Hannah is superb at "delineating nuances of feeling," as the Washington Post once put it. She doesn't necessarily say what Nora did was okay; she just shows that staying angry forever is a lot of work.
Breaking Down the Ruby and Nora Dynamic
Ruby is... a lot. She dyes her hair black, wears too much eyeliner, and hides behind sarcasm. It’s a classic defense mechanism. If she’s the one making the jokes, nobody can hurt her. Nora, on the other hand, is polished. She’s the "Advice Queen." The friction between them is the engine of the book.
One of the most intense parts of Summer Island by Kristin Hannah is the realization that Ruby’s career is built on her hatred of her mother. If she forgives Nora, does she lose her comedy career? Does she lose her identity? It’s a fascinating look at how we cling to our trauma because it’s the only thing that feels certain.
💡 You might also like: Wrong Address: Why This Nigerian Drama Is Still Sparking Conversations
Real Places, Fictional Names
While Summer Island isn't a real place on the map, it’s clearly modeled after Orcas Island or San Juan Island. The ferry rides, the rocky shores, and the sense of isolation are very "Pacific Northwest." If you’ve ever been to Seattle or the surrounding islands, you’ll recognize the vibe immediately. It’s the kind of place where you can actually feel the silence, which is exactly what these characters need to hear each other.
How Summer Island Fits Into the Hannah Multiverse
If you look at her later work, you can see the seeds of her genius here. Summer Island was published in 2001. That’s years before the world went crazy for her historical fiction.
In this book, she’s experimenting with the "two-POV" structure that she later perfected. You get into Nora’s head, and you get into Ruby’s. You see the same events from two totally different angles. It’s a reminder that there is no such thing as "the truth"—there’s only your version and mine.
Also, let’s talk about the romance. Dean Sloan, the "one who got away," is back in the picture. It’s a classic trope, but Hannah makes it feel earned. Dean is dealing with his own family tragedy, which keeps the romance from feeling like a shallow distraction. It’s two broken people trying to figure out if they can fit together again.
What Most Reviews Miss
A lot of reviews focus purely on the "forgiveness" aspect. But honestly? The most interesting part of the book is the critique of celebrity culture.
📖 Related: Who was the voice of Yoda? The real story behind the Jedi Master
Nora Bridge represents that pre-social media era where you could curate a perfect public image. The moment that image cracks, the public turns on her with a ferocity that feels very modern. It’s a cautionary tale about living a "moral" life for an audience while your personal life is a wreck. Ruby’s plan to write the tell-all is basically the 2001 version of a "cancel culture" Twitter thread.
Actionable Steps for Readers
If you’re thinking about picking this up, keep a few things in mind to get the most out of the experience.
Read it as a time capsule. This was written before smartphones and social media. The "scandal" feels very early-2000s. Enjoy the nostalgia of a world where secrets took longer to travel.
Pay attention to the secondary characters. Eric’s story is arguably more moving than the main plot. His journey with Dean is what ultimately pushes Ruby to change her perspective on her own family.
Don't expect a thriller. This is a slow burn. It’s a character study. If you’re looking for high-octane action, you’re in the wrong place. But if you want a book that makes you want to call your mom (or at least understand why you don't want to call her), this is it.
Compare it to her newer books. If you’ve read The Women or The Nightingale, reading Summer Island is like seeing an artist’s early sketches. You can see the themes of female resilience and complicated families starting to take shape.
The book remains a staple for book clubs for a reason. It sparks debates. It makes people angry. It makes people cry. That’s the Kristin Hannah brand in a nutshell. Whether you find the ending satisfying or "too sappy," the journey through the San Juan fog is worth the trip. Just make sure you have some tissues nearby, because the "impurity of the heart" that Nora Bridge talks about is something we all deal with.