If you’ve ever tried to track down Sullivan County NY obituaries, you know it’s not always as simple as a quick Google search. Honestly, the Catskills are a bit of a patchwork quilt when it comes to record-keeping. One minute you’re looking for a relative from Liberty, and the next you realize the local paper from 1985 hasn’t been digitized yet. It's frustrating.
Sullivan County has a deep, complex history. From the heyday of the Borscht Belt to the quiet riverside towns like Narrowsburg and Callicoon, people here have stories. But finding those stories—those final tributes—requires knowing exactly where the local gatekeepers keep the files.
The Digital Gap in Local Records
Most people assume everything is on Legacy.com. It's not. While many modern funeral homes like VanInwegen-Kenny in Monticello or Colonial Family of Funeral Homes in Woodbourne post directly to their websites, older records are a different beast entirely.
If someone passed away in the 1970s or 80s in a small hamlet like Grahamsville, their obituary might only exist in a physical archive. You’ve basically got to go to the source. The Sullivan County Democrat, founded back in 1891, is the heavyweight champion here. They’ve been the paper of record for over a century. If an obituary was published in this county, there is a 90% chance it’s in their archives.
👉 See also: How Often Does the Government Shut Down? What Most People Get Wrong
But here is the catch: their online search tool is great for recent years, but for the "deep cuts," you often have to email their "Down the Decade" or obituaries department directly. It’s a very human process.
Where to Look When Google Fails
Sometimes a name just doesn’t pop up. Maybe the spelling was botched in the original print, or the person lived in Roscoe but the service was in Ulster County.
The Newspaper Titans
- Sullivan County Democrat: Based in Callicoon, they publish twice weekly. They are the most consistent source for local death notices.
- The River Reporter: This is the go-to for the western side of the county and the Delaware River corridor. They focus heavily on Narrowsburg, Tusten, and Cochecton.
- The Times Herald-Record: While based in Middletown (Orange County), they cover Sullivan extensively. Often, more prominent residents or those with ties to the broader Hudson Valley will appear here.
The Funeral Home Loophole
Often, funeral homes maintain their own "Obituary Walls" that are more detailed than the newspaper snippets.
- Harris Funeral Home in Liberty is a staple for that area.
- Joseph N. Garlick Funeral Home handles many services in Monticello and has a searchable online database.
- Stewart-Murphy Funeral Home covers Callicoon and Jeffersonville.
Why the Sullivan County Historical Society is Your Secret Weapon
Let’s say you’re doing genealogy. You aren't just looking for someone who passed last week; you're looking for a great-grandfather from the 1920s. This is where the Sullivan County Historical Society in Hurleyville comes in.
They are located in the old 1912 schoolhouse. It’s a vibe. They have microfilm of newspapers that no longer exist. They have vertical files filled with "clippings." Honestly, if you can’t find a record of a death through the usual digital channels, a trip to Hurleyville is basically mandatory. They have marriage and death records that pre-date modern state requirements.
Common Mistakes in the Search
People often search for the town they think the person lived in, but Sullivan County is "hamlet-heavy." Someone might say they lived in Monticello, but they actually lived in the Town of Thompson. Or they lived in Swan Lake, but the obituary is listed under Liberty.
Pro tip: Search by the county level first, then narrow it down. Also, check the surrounding counties. Because Sullivan sits right on the edge of Orange, Delaware, and Ulster—and even Wayne County, PA—people frequently crossed borders for medical care. If a resident died at Garnet Health in Middletown, the obituary might be categorized under Orange County records instead.
How to Place an Obituary Today
If you’re on the other side of things and need to submit one, the process is pretty straightforward but can be pricey. The Sullivan County Democrat accepts submissions via email. Most people let the funeral director handle this because they have established accounts with the papers.
Be aware that "death notices" (just the facts) are often cheaper or sometimes free, while "obituaries" (the life story and photo) are charged by the inch or word count.
Actionable Steps for Your Search
- Start with the Funeral Home: Even if the death was years ago, many local homes keep digital archives that pre-date Google's indexing.
- Check the Library: The Ethelbert B. Crawford Public Library in Monticello and the Liberty Public Library have local history rooms. They often have volunteers who know the local family trees by heart.
- Use the "Site:" Search: If you're looking on a specific newspaper site, use Google's advanced search. Type
site:scdemocratonline.com "Name"to bypass clunky on-site search engines. - Contact the Town Clerk: For official death certificates (which aren't obituaries but contain the same vital stats), you need the clerk of the specific municipality where the death occurred, not just the county.
Finding Sullivan County NY obituaries is about persistence. Whether you're looking for a friend or tracing a family lineage through the Catskill mountains, the information is usually there—you just have to know which drawer to pull open.