So, your back hurts. You’ve probably tried the stretches, the yoga, maybe even those weird vibrating massage guns. Nothing really stuck. Then you stumbled upon the name Stuart McGill. Specifically, his famous "Big 3."
Honestly, most people treat these exercises like a grocery list. They do a few reps, check the box, and wonder why their spine still feels like a dry twig ready to snap. But Dr. Stuart McGill, who spent basically forty years in a lab at the University of Waterloo poking at spines, didn’t design these to be "just another workout."
They are about stiffness. Not the "I can't move my neck" kind of stiffness, but the "armored car" kind. The goal is to build enough endurance so your spine doesn't buckle under the weight of everyday life. If you’ve been doing them and they aren’t working, you’re likely missing the nuance.
Why the Stuart McGill Big 3 Actually Works (and Sit-ups Don't)
Most of us were raised on a diet of sit-ups and crunches. We thought that to protect the back, you had to "flex" it. McGill’s research turned that on its head. He found that every time you pull your spine into that C-shape during a sit-up, you’re basically "flossing" your spinal discs with high amounts of compression. Do that enough times, and you’re just asking for a herniation.
The Stuart McGill Big 3—the Modified Curl-up, the Side Bridge, and the Bird Dog—are different. They create "total-body stiffness." Think of it like a guy-wire system on a radio tower. If the wires are loose, the tower falls. If they’re tight, the tower stays upright during a storm.
What’s cool is that these movements don’t actually move the spine. They teach the muscles around the spine to stay still while the limbs move. This is what McGill calls "proximal stiffness for distal mobility." Essentially, if your core is a rock, your shoulders and hips can be the whips.
The Modified Curl-Up: It’s Not a Crunch
Let’s get one thing straight: if your head is coming six inches off the floor, you’re doing it wrong.
The Modified Curl-up is subtle. You lie on your back. One leg is straight, one is bent. Why? Because it keeps your pelvis in a neutral position so your lower back doesn't flatten into the floor. You slide your hands under the small of your back to act as "sensors." If you feel your back pressing down into your hands, you’ve lost the neutral spine.
🔗 Read more: That Time a Doctor With Measles Treating Kids Sparked a Massive Health Crisis
You just barely lift your head and shoulders. Imagine your neck and upper back are a single unit, like they're fused. You aren't "curling" the spine; you’re lifting the unit.
"The goal isn't to feel a 'burn' in your six-pack. It's to hold that bridge-like tension for 10 seconds." — A common McGill-ism.
Hold for 10 seconds. Breathe normally. Do not hold your breath. If you hold your breath, you’re using internal pressure rather than muscle tension. That’s cheating.
The Side Bridge: The Quadratus Lumborum's Best Friend
Most people ignore the sides of their core. Big mistake. The side bridge targets the quadratus lumborum (QL), a deep muscle that’s basically a stabilizer for your spine.
If you’re a beginner, start on your knees. Lie on your side, propped up on your elbow. Make sure your elbow is directly under your shoulder. If it's too far out, you’ll wreck your rotator cuff. Lift your hips until you’re a straight line from your head to your knees.
As you get stronger, move to your feet. But here's the McGill secret: don't stack your feet. Place the top foot in front of the bottom foot. This gives you a much wider base and allows for better hip stabilization.
Hold for 10 seconds. Drop. Repeat.
💡 You might also like: Dr. Sharon Vila Wright: What You Should Know About the Houston OB-GYN
The Bird Dog: Coordination is Key
The Bird Dog looks easy. It's not. It’s a balance of tension.
You start on all fours. Hands under shoulders, knees under hips. You extend the opposite arm and leg. Now, here is where everyone messes up: they reach for the sky. If your leg is high in the air, your back is arching. If your back is arching, you’re compressing the very joints you’re trying to save.
Keep your leg and arm parallel to the floor. Imagine there’s a bowl of water on your lower back and you can’t spill a drop. To make it harder, McGill suggests "drawing a square" with your hand and foot once they’re extended, or "sweeping" the floor with your hand and knee between reps without letting them rest.
The Repetition Scheme: The Descent
McGill doesn’t like the "3 sets of 10" approach. He prefers a "Descending Pyramid."
Why? Because fatigue leads to bad form. Bad form leads to injury.
- Set 1: 6 reps (10-second holds)
- Set 2: 4 reps (10-second holds)
- Set 3: 2 reps (10-second holds)
This way, you’re doing your hardest work when you’re the freshest.
Common Misconceptions That Stunt Progress
People think the Big 3 is the "McGill Method." It's not. Brian Carroll, a world-record powerlifter who literally "fixed" his broken back using McGill’s work, often points this out. The Big 3 is just the stability portion.
📖 Related: Why Meditation for Emotional Numbness is Harder (and Better) Than You Think
If you do the Big 3 in the morning but then spend the rest of your day slouching in a chair or bending over with a rounded back to pick up your kids, the exercises won't save you. You have to "stop the picking." If you have a scab and you keep picking it, it won't heal. Back pain is the same. The Big 3 builds the capacity, but your daily movement habits determine the outcome.
Also, some people find the Big 3 makes them feel worse. If that’s you, you’re likely in an "acute" phase. Sometimes the spine is so sensitized that even these "safe" exercises are too much. In that case, you need to find your "pain-free" wind-down first—usually through tummy lying or very gentle walking—before you start the bracing work.
Actionable Next Steps for a Resilient Spine
If you’re ready to actually try the Stuart McGill Big 3, don't just jump in. Start slow.
- Find Your Neutral: Lie on the floor. Tilt your pelvis back and forth until you find the "middle" spot. That’s your home base.
- The 10-Second Rule: Never hold a rep for more than 10 seconds. McGill found that oxygen levels in the muscle drop after 10 seconds, which leads to fatigue and "form creep."
- Audit Your Day: Notice how you tie your shoes or brush your teeth. If you're "hinging" at your spine instead of your hips, the Big 3 can't help you.
- Frequency over Intensity: Do these every single day. They are "brushing your teeth" for your back. Consistency beats a 2-hour gym session once a week.
The magic isn't in the movement itself. It's in the precision of the hold and the discipline of the daily routine. Stick to the pyramid, keep your spine neutral, and stop trying to "stretch" your way out of a stability problem.
Your back will thank you eventually.
Practical Next Step: Tomorrow morning, before you do anything else, try just one set of the modified curl-up. Focus entirely on the "sensor" hands under your back. If you can do 5 reps without feeling your spine move against your fingers, you’ve mastered the hardest part of the McGill philosophy.