Everything about Steven Universe usually feels bigger than life. We’re talking about sentient space rocks, intergalactic warfare, and the literal weight of a thousand-year-old legacy resting on a kid’s shoulders. But then you get to Steven Universe Season 5 Episode 5, an episode titled "Dewey Wins," and the show does something arguably scarier than a Diamond invasion. It forces us to look at the messy, unglamorous, and often disappointing reality of political accountability and personal growth.
It's a quiet episode. There aren't any flashy fusion battles here. Instead, we’re left with the fallout of the "Wanted" arc. Steven is back from Homeworld. He’s alive. But the town of Beach City is absolutely reeling from the fact that several of its citizens were abducted by aliens. People are terrified. And in the middle of this panic, Mayor Dewey is trying to do what he’s always done: spin the narrative.
The Political Reality of Beach City
Honestly, "Dewey Wins" is a bit of a misnomer. The title is a reference to the famous "Dewey Defeats Truman" newspaper error, and it sets the stage for a story about an election that goes sideways. For four seasons, Bill Dewey was the face of Beach City’s leadership—bumbling, slightly corrupt, but ultimately harmless. He was the guy who used the "emergency" siren to announce his own campaign.
In Steven Universe Season 5 Episode 5, the stakes change. Nanefua Pizza, the matriarch of the Pizza family, steps up to challenge him. Why? Because the people are tired of being told everything is "fine" when they're being kidnapped by Gem shards and Homeworld bounty hunters.
What makes this episode stand out is how it treats the voters. They aren't background noise. They are frustrated people who want transparency. Nanefua doesn't win by promising magical solutions. She wins by admitting she doesn't know everything but is willing to listen and organize. It’s a sharp contrast to Dewey’s "Trust me, I'm the Mayor" approach.
Why the Steven and Connie Conflict Hurts More Than the Election
While the election is the backdrop, the real emotional core of Steven Universe Season 5 Episode 5 is the devastating silence between Steven and Connie.
If you remember the end of "I Am My Mom," Steven gave himself up to Aquamarine. He thought he was being a hero. He thought he was saving his friends by sacrificing himself. But Connie? She didn't see it that way. To her, they were a team—Stevonnie. They had a pact to fight together. When Steven gave himself up, he didn't just save her; he abandoned her.
He left her behind to deal with the grief and the fear that he was never coming back.
📖 Related: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
When he returns in this episode, he expects things to go back to normal. He wants a "we did it!" moment. Instead, he gets the cold shoulder. It’s painful to watch. Steven tries to use the Dewey election as a distraction from his own guilt. He throws himself into helping Dewey’s campaign because he can’t handle the fact that his best friend is mad at him.
He keeps saying things like, "But I'm back now! Everything is fine!"
It isn't fine.
The Subversion of the Hero Archetype
Most shows would frame Steven’s sacrifice as purely noble. Rebecca Sugar and the writing team did something much more sophisticated here. They explored the ego involved in self-sacrifice.
Steven’s choice was unilateral. By deciding he was the only one who could solve the problem, he stripped Connie of her agency. This episode is the first time we see Steven really struggle with the idea that his "Gem destiny" can’t just override his human relationships. You can be a savior of the galaxy and still be a bad friend.
- Nanefua represents the power of community over the "Great Man" theory of leadership.
- Dewey’s eventual concession is one of the most dignified moments for a comic relief character in the series.
- The ending isn't a happy resolution; it’s Connie walking away while Steven stands alone on the sidewalk.
It's a heavy transition for the show. The "Wanted" arc felt like a season finale, but "Dewey Wins" proves that the aftermath of a war is just as complicated as the war itself.
Dewey’s Growth and the Loss of Status
Mayor Dewey actually has a really poignant realization in Steven Universe Season 5 Episode 5. He realizes he’s been pretending to have answers he doesn't have. For years, he’s been the buffer between the weird Gem stuff and the townspeople. He thought that by lying and keeping everyone "calm," he was doing his job.
👉 See also: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
When he sees Nanefua’s genuine connection with the crowd, he realizes he’s lost. Not because he’s a bad person, but because his style of leadership is obsolete. Beach City has changed. It’s no longer a sleepy tourist town; it’s the front line of an intergalactic conflict.
He drops out. He lets Nanefua take the lead. It’s a moment of surprising grace. It also sets up his later character arc where he ends up working at the Big Donut—a total fall from grace that he handles with a surprising amount of humor.
How "Dewey Wins" Fixed the Show’s Pacing Issues
A lot of fans at the time were frustrated with "townie" episodes. People wanted more Diamond lore. They wanted to see White Diamond. They wanted to know what happened to Lars in space.
But looking back, Steven Universe Season 5 Episode 5 was essential. It grounded the show. If we don't care about the people of Beach City, then why does it matter if the Diamonds destroy the Earth? By focusing on the Pizza family, the Frymans, and the Deweys, the show reminds us what Steven is actually fighting for.
It’s not just about "Earth" as a concept. It’s about the right to have a local election without being blown up by a laser.
The episode also serves as a necessary cooldown. After the high-octane escape from the Emerald and the tension of the Off-Colors' hideout, we needed to see the human consequences of those events. The show excels when it balances the "Cosmic" with the "Mundane."
The Visual Language of the Episode
Pay attention to the framing in the scenes between Steven and Connie. Usually, they are in the same shot, close together, or fused. In "Dewey Wins," they are separated by distance, by phone screens, and by silence.
✨ Don't miss: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
The color palette of the election night is also worth noting. It’s bright, patriotic, and loud, which contrasts sharply with the hollow feeling Steven has inside. He’s surrounded by people cheering for "victory," but he’s lost his most important connection.
Fact Check: What Actually Happened?
There's often confusion about the timeline here. This episode aired as part of a multi-episode "bomb" or event. It immediately follows the events of "Lars' Head."
- Steven returns to Earth via Lion's mane/Lars' hair.
- He meets Connie at the beach house.
- Connie leaves, upset that Steven didn't value their partnership.
- The election takes place over the course of the next few days.
- Nanefua Pizza becomes the new Mayor of Beach City.
The fallout of this episode lasts for a significant portion of Season 5. The "Connie and Steven rift" isn't solved in twenty minutes. It takes several more episodes—most notably "Kevin Party"—before they even start talking again. This kind of long-form emotional consequences is what made Steven Universe a landmark in Western animation.
Actionable Takeaways for Rewatching Season 5
If you're revisiting this arc, don't skip the townie episodes. They are the emotional glue.
Watch the way Steven tries to "fix" Dewey’s campaign. He’s using it as a proxy for his own life. He wants a win. He wants to feel like he can control an outcome because he couldn't control what happened on Homeworld. When Dewey loses, Steven has to face the fact that some things can't be spun into a positive.
Also, look at Nanefua’s policy. She immediately creates a crisis management team. This is a subtle nod to the fact that the Gems are no longer a secret. The town is finally acknowledging the danger they live in.
To get the most out of this specific narrative thread, you should watch this episode back-to-back with "Gem Harvest" and "Letters to Lars." It paints a complete picture of a town evolving from a collection of individuals into a unified community.
The series is about more than just Pink Diamond’s secret. It’s about how individuals handle trauma and change. Steven Universe Season 5 Episode 5 is the moment the show stopped being about a boy with a magic belly button and started being about the responsibility of being a person in a complicated world.
Next time you watch, pay attention to the silence at the end. No music. Just the sound of the ocean. It’s the sound of Steven finally growing up.