Ever get a late-night craving for a Frisco Melt and think, "Man, I should really own a piece of this place"? You're not alone. But if you head over to Robinhood or E*TRADE and type in "Steak n Shake stock," you're going to hit a wall. It’s not there. Seriously.
The company isn't public in the way most people think. You can't just buy a share of "Steak n Shake" and call it a day. Instead, you have to look at Biglari Holdings Inc. (BH). That's the parent company. It's run by Sardar Biglari, a guy who basically treats the company like his own personal version of Berkshire Hathaway. He’s a fan of Warren Buffett, and it shows in how the business is structured, though the results have been... well, controversial.
If you’re looking to invest, you’re not just buying into burgers and milkshakes. You’re buying into a weird, complex conglomerate that owns insurance companies, a media brand, and even an oil company. It's a lot.
The Biglari Era: How the Stock Became Part of a Conglomerate
Back in the day, Steak n Shake was a struggling chain. It was bleeding cash. Then came Sardar Biglari in 2008. He took control through a proxy fight that was, honestly, pretty legendary in the fast-food world. He saved the company from the brink of bankruptcy, mostly by slashing prices and simplifying the menu.
But then things got complicated.
The company went through a massive corporate restructuring. It wasn't just a restaurant anymore. In 2010, the ticker changed. The focus shifted. Biglari started using the cash generated from those steakburgers to buy other stuff. He bought Maxim magazine. He bought Western Sizzlin. He even bought FirstPRO, an insurance company.
📖 Related: Neiman Marcus in Manhattan New York: What Really Happened to the Hudson Yards Giant
Investors who thought they were getting a pure-play restaurant stock suddenly found themselves holding shares in a mini-conglomerate. This is the biggest hurdle for people researching Steak n Shake stock today. You aren't just betting on whether people still like $4 meals; you're betting on Biglari’s ability to allocate capital across totally unrelated industries.
Why the Stock Price Doesn't Always Match the Restaurant's Success
Usually, if a restaurant has a huge year, the stock goes up. Simple, right? Not here. Because Biglari Holdings owns so many different things, the performance of Steak n Shake can be overshadowed by losses in the insurance sector or a dip in oil prices.
Also, the share structure is weird. There are two classes of stock: BH and BH.A.
- BH.A shares are the "expensive" ones, often trading for thousands of dollars.
- BH shares (Class B) are more accessible but have less voting power.
This dual-class structure is a classic move for founders who want to keep absolute control. It means that as a retail investor, you have basically zero say in how the company is run. If you don't like the fact that they spent millions on Maxim, there’s not much you can do about it.
The restaurant itself has struggled lately, too. For a while, they were closing locations and moving away from the classic "table service" model. They switched to a kiosk-heavy, self-service counter model. It saved on labor costs, sure. But it also changed the vibe. Some loyalists hated it. The financials reflected that friction for a few years, though recent reports suggest the transition to a franchise-heavy model is finally starting to stabilize the bottom line.
👉 See also: Rough Tax Return Calculator: How to Estimate Your Refund Without Losing Your Mind
Understanding the "Biglari Discount"
There is a concept in the investing world called the "Conglomerate Discount." It's the idea that a group of businesses owned together is worth less than the sum of its parts. With Biglari Holdings, some call it the "Sardar Discount."
Investors are often wary of "key man risk." If something happens to Sardar Biglari, what happens to the company? He is so deeply involved in every decision—down to the marketing and the aesthetic of the restaurants—that the stock often trades at a lower valuation than it might if it were just a transparent, standalone burger chain.
Check out the SEC filings. They are dense. Unlike a tech startup that talks about "disruption" and "synergy," Biglari’s annual letters are often philosophical. They talk about intrinsic value and long-term compounding. It’s very old-school. But for the average person who just wants to invest in a burger joint, it can feel like a lot of unnecessary noise.
Is It Still a Good Way to Play the Fast Food Market?
Honestly? It depends on what you're looking for. If you want a safe, predictable dividend payer like McDonald's (MCD), this isn't it. Biglari Holdings doesn't pay a regular dividend. They want to reinvest that cash into new acquisitions.
However, if you like the idea of a "value play" where the assets might be worth more than the current stock price, there's an argument to be made. The company owns a massive stake in Cracker Barrel (CBRL). That alone is worth a huge chunk of change. When you add up the real estate, the insurance floats, and the brand value of Steak n Shake, some analysts argue the stock is perennially undervalued.
✨ Don't miss: Replacement Walk In Cooler Doors: What Most People Get Wrong About Efficiency
But you have to have a stomach for volatility. And you have to be okay with the fact that the company operates with a level of opacity that frustrates Wall Street.
The Shift to Franchising
One thing that has actually improved the outlook for the Steak n Shake component of the stock is the "Partner-Manager" program. Instead of corporate-owned stores, they are selling the rights to operate a location for a very low entry price—sometimes as low as $10,000.
The catch? The operator doesn't "own" the real estate; they just earn a share of the profits. This has allowed the company to offload the headache of daily operations while still keeping a steady stream of income flowing back to the parent company. It turned Steak n Shake from a capital-intensive business into a cash-flow machine. This is the kind of detail that doesn't show up in a 5-second glance at a stock chart, but it's vital for understanding where the money is actually coming from.
Actionable Steps for Potential Investors
If you’re serious about getting involved with Steak n Shake through Biglari Holdings, don't just click "buy." You need a plan because this isn't a normal stock.
- Read the Annual Letter: Go to the Biglari Holdings website and read the last three years of letters to shareholders. If you don't like Sardar Biglari's tone or his investment philosophy, stay away. He is the company.
- Look at the Cracker Barrel Stake: Since a huge portion of BH's value is tied up in shares of Cracker Barrel, you're effectively investing in two restaurant chains at once. See how CBRL is performing before you pull the trigger.
- Choose the Right Share Class: If you’re a smaller investor, stick to the Class B (BH) shares. They are much more liquid and don't require you to shell out the price of a used car for a single share.
- Monitor the Restaurant Count: Keep an eye on how many "Partner-Manager" locations are opening versus closing. If the number of locations starts to shrink again, it means the turnaround is hitting a wall.
- Check the "Float": Understand that Biglari owns a massive percentage of the shares himself. This means the "float" (the number of shares available to the public) is relatively small, which can lead to big price swings on very little news.
Investing here is a bet on a person, not just a burger. Make sure you're comfortable with the driver before you get in the car. It’s been a wild ride since 2008, and there’s no sign of it smoothing out anytime soon.