One minute and thirty-six seconds. That is all it took for Maurice Williams to change music history. Most modern pop songs spend more time on the intro alone than the entirety of the song Stay. It’s the shortest track to ever hit number one on the Billboard Hot 100, a record that has stood for over sixty-five years. Honestly, it probably won’t ever be broken.
The story behind this doo-wop masterpiece isn’t some corporate marketing scheme. It was born from a frustrating date night in 1953. Maurice was only 15 years old. He was hanging out with a girl, trying to convince her to ignore her 10 p.m. curfew. Her brother showed up to pick her up, and Maurice, desperate for a few more minutes, pleaded for her to stay. She didn't. She went home.
The rejection stung. But as he later told interviewers, the words just flooded into his head. He wrote the song in about thirty minutes. He actually threw it away initially. Imagine that. One of the most covered songs in history almost ended up in a trash can because a teenager didn't think it was worth much.
👉 See also: Why Highway to Heaven Season 1 Still Feels Like a Warm Hug in a Cold World
The Sound That Defied the Producers
When Maurice Williams and the Zodiacs finally got into a studio years later, the industry wasn’t exactly begging for this track. They recorded it in a Quonset hut on Shakespeare Road in Columbia, South Carolina. It was basically a metal shed. The demo was rough.
When they took it to Al Silver at Herald Records, he liked the vibe but hated the technical quality. The recording levels were too low. He also had a problem with the lyrics. One line originally said, "Let's have another smoke." In 1960, that was a big "no" for radio play. They had to cut it.
That Famous Falsetto
You know the part. That piercing, glass-shattering "Ohhhhhhh" that kicks in near the end. That wasn't Maurice. That was Henry Gaston. Gaston’s falsetto is arguably the reason the song became a global phenomenon. It was unexpected. It was raw.
A weird detail: the group only decided to record the song because of an eight-year-old girl. She was the sister of Maurice’s girlfriend at the time. She heard the demo and obsessed over the "high voice." Maurice figured if a kid that age liked it, the record-buying public would too. He was right.
The Curious Second Life of "Stay"
If you weren't around in 1960, you probably know the song from a different decade. In 1987, Dirty Dancing happened. When that soundtrack dropped, featuring the original Zodiacs version, the song exploded all over again. It ended up selling more copies in the late 80s than it did when it was first released.
But the song is a shape-shifter.
- The Hollies took it to the UK Top 10 in 1963.
- The Four Seasons gave it a polished, Frankie Valli-style makeover that hit number 16.
- Jackson Browne reimagined it in 1977 as a road-weary anthem for his Running on Empty tour.
Browne's version is particularly interesting because it changes the context. Instead of a teenager begging a girl to stay past curfew, it’s a rock star begging the audience to stay for one more encore. He even kept the high-pitched part, handed off to David Lindley, who delivered it with a hilarious, gritty intensity that makes the live recording legendary.
Why it Still Works
The song Stay works because it is fundamentally relatable. We’ve all been in that position—not wanting a good night to end. It’s a plea. It’s vulnerable.
Maurice Williams passed away in August 2024 at the age of 86. He spent decades performing on the "beach music" circuit in the Carolinas. To those fans, he wasn't just a one-hit wonder. He was the king of a specific, soulful sound that defined their summers.
People often overlook how difficult it is to write a song that is less than two minutes long but feels like a complete story. There is no filler. No long bridges. Just the hook, the plea, and that incredible high note.
👉 See also: California King Bed Song Lyrics: Why We Still Feel That 10,000 Mile Gap
Actionable Takeaways for Music Lovers
If you want to truly appreciate the legacy of this track, don't just stick to the radio edits.
- Listen to the original 1960 mono recording. You can hear the room. You can hear the lack of digital polish. It feels like a moment frozen in time.
- Compare the falsettos. Listen to Henry Gaston’s original 1960 version, then jump to David Lindley’s performance on Jackson Browne’s live track. It shows how the same "joke" or vocal trick can feel completely different depending on the era.
- Check out the Beach Music scene. Maurice Williams was a legend in South Carolina. Look up "Shag dancing" videos on YouTube set to this song. It gives you a sense of the cultural footprint the song has outside of the Billboard charts.
Next time you’re in a rush, remember that Maurice Williams built a lifelong career and a million-dollar legacy on just 96 seconds of music. Sometimes, brevity really is the soul of a hit.