You’re staring at your paystub. It’s depressing. Between federal withholdings, FICA, and that pesky line item for state tax, a huge chunk of your hard-earned cash vanishes before it even hits your bank account. Naturally, you start googling. You find out that a handful of states just... don't do that. No state income tax. It sounds like a cheat code for life. If you move from California to Texas, you’re basically giving yourself a 10% raise, right?
Well, sort of. But also, not really.
The dream of states with no income tax is powerful. It’s why people are flocking to places like Florida and Tennessee. But here’s the thing: states are like businesses. They have bills to pay. They have roads to pave, schools to fund, and police departments to run. If they aren't taking that money from your paycheck, they are absolutely getting it from somewhere else.
Honestly, it’s a shell game. You’ve got to look at the total tax burden, not just one line on a tax return.
The Current Map: Where the Tax Man Doesn't Knock
As of right now, there are nine states that don't have a traditional individual income tax. These are Alaska, Florida, Nevada, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Washington, and Wyoming. New Hampshire is the weird one—it doesn't tax earned income (your salary), but it has been phasing out its tax on interest and dividends, aiming to be fully income-tax-free by 2025.
Washington is also a bit of a special case lately. They don't have a personal income tax, but they recently implemented a 7% capital gains tax on high-earners. If you’re selling a massive amount of stock, the "no tax" label starts to feel a bit like a technicality.
Each of these places has a different "vibe" and a different way of keeping the lights on. Alaska has oil. Florida has tourists. Texas has... well, a lot of everything and some of the highest property taxes you’ll ever see in your life.
How Do They Pay for Stuff?
This is the part most people ignore until they get their first property tax bill or walk into a grocery store and see the total.
Texas is the classic example here. You don’t pay a dime in state income tax. Great! But Texas has some of the highest property tax rates in the entire country. According to the Tax Foundation, Texas ranks near the top for property tax collections as a percentage of owner-occupied housing value. If you buy a $500,000 home in a nice suburb of Austin or Dallas, you might be looking at $10,000 to $15,000 a year in property taxes. In a state like Hawaii, which has a high income tax, that same house might only cost you $1,500 in property taxes.
✨ Don't miss: Williams Sonoma Deer Park IL: What Most People Get Wrong About This Kitchen Icon
You’re paying the piper. You’re just choosing which instrument he plays.
Then there’s the sales tax. Tennessee has one of the highest combined state and local sales tax rates in the nation, often hovering around 9.5% or even 10% in some jurisdictions. Think about that. Every time you buy a shirt, a toaster, or a new TV, you’re handing over a tenth of the price to the state. Over a year, that adds up. If you’re a high spender, a high sales tax environment might actually hurt you more than a modest income tax would.
The "Tourist Tax" Strategy
Florida and Nevada are the masters of making other people pay for their residents' lifestyles. If you’ve ever stayed in a hotel in Las Vegas or rented a car in Orlando, you’ve seen those "occupancy taxes" and "resort fees."
A huge portion of Florida’s revenue comes from sales taxes fueled by the millions of people visiting Disney World or the beaches. Because tourists are pouring billions into the economy, the state can afford to leave the residents' paychecks alone. It’s a brilliant setup if you live there, but it also means the state’s budget is incredibly sensitive to the economy. When people stop vacationing—like during a recession or a pandemic—those states feel the squeeze much faster than states with a steady stream of income tax.
Alaska is the True Outlier
Alaska is basically the only state that truly "pays" you to live there. Thanks to the Permanent Fund Dividend, residents actually receive a check most years just for existing in the state. This is funded by oil wealth.
But let’s be real. You’re living in Alaska. The cost of living is sky-high because almost everything has to be shipped in. A gallon of milk or a head of lettuce in a remote part of Alaska will make a New Yorker wince. So, while you aren't paying income tax, you are paying a "geography tax" on every single thing you consume.
The Hidden Costs: Schools and Infrastructure
When a state has no income tax, something usually suffers. Or, at the very least, things are funded differently.
In some tax-free states, you might find that public services are "leaner." This isn't always a bad thing—it depends on your political leanings and what you value. But it’s common to see more toll roads in these states. Florida is famous for its SunPass system. You aren't paying an income tax to maintain the highways; you’re paying $2.50 every time you drive to work.
🔗 Read more: Finding the most affordable way to live when everything feels too expensive
Fees are the silent killer. Car registration fees, professional licensing fees, even fees for park entry. When the "big" tax is gone, the "little" fees tend to multiply. It’s death by a thousand papercuts.
Is Moving Worth It?
If you’re a high-earner, yes. Usually.
If you’re making $500,000 a year and living in New York City, you are losing a massive amount of money to state and city income taxes. Moving to Miami is a life-changing financial move. The "savings" on income tax will far outweigh the increased costs of insurance or sales tax.
But if you’re making $50,000? The math gets fuzzy.
By the time you factor in the cost of moving, potentially higher rent or property taxes, and the increased cost of goods in a high-sales-tax state, you might actually end up with less disposable income. It's kinda counter-intuitive. People see the "0%" and stop thinking. Don't be that person.
The Remote Work Revolution
The rise of remote work has changed the game for states with no income tax. It used to be that if you wanted a Texas tax rate, you had to find a job in Texas. Now, you can keep your Silicon Valley salary and live in a cabin in South Dakota.
But be careful. States are getting aggressive about "convenience of the employer" rules. If your company is based in New York and you’re working from your basement in Florida, New York might still try to claim a piece of your income. They are literally fighting court battles over this right now. Always talk to a CPA before you assume you’re in the clear just because you changed your mailing address.
What Most People Get Wrong About "Tax Burden"
Economists use a term called "Total Tax Burden." This is the only number that actually matters. It combines income tax, property tax, and sales and excise taxes.
💡 You might also like: Executive desk with drawers: Why your home office setup is probably failing you
According to data from WalletHub and the Tax Foundation, states like Washington (no income tax) actually have a higher total tax burden for the average citizen than some states with an income tax. It sounds wild, but it’s true. If you don't own a home, Texas is great. If you own a big house and spend a lot of money, Oregon (which has high income tax but zero sales tax) might actually be cheaper for you.
You have to look at your own spending habits. Are you a saver? A spender? A homeowner? A renter?
Practical Steps for Evaluating a Move
Don't just look at a map. Do the math.
- Calculate your current "Tax Leakage." Look at your tax return from last year. How much did you actually pay in state and local income taxes? That’s your target number.
- Estimate your new property tax. Look up the "millage rate" in the specific county you're moving to. Don't trust Zillow's estimates; they are often based on the previous owner's locked-in rate.
- Factor in Insurance. This is huge. Florida and Texas are currently facing an insurance crisis. Homeowners' insurance in Florida can be triple or quadruple what it is in the Midwest. That "tax saving" can disappear into an insurance premium real fast.
- Check the Sales Tax on Big Purchases. If you plan on buying a $70,000 truck, a 9% sales tax vs. a 3% sales tax is a $4,200 difference.
- Account for Tolls and Fees. Look at your daily commute. If it involves $10 in tolls every day, that's $2,500 a year.
The Nuance of Retirement
For retirees, the math changes again. Some states tax Social Security; others don't. Some states tax pension income; others don't. A state might have a high income tax for workers but be a "tax haven" for seniors.
For example, Pennsylvania has a flat income tax, but it’s famously friendly to retirees because it doesn't tax most retirement distributions. If you're 65, Pennsylvania might be cheaper than a "no income tax" state that has high property taxes on your forever home.
Final Reality Check
Living in a state with no income tax is a legitimate strategy for building wealth, but it isn't a magic wand. It works best for people with high incomes, high liquid assets, and the ability to control their spending.
If you're moving just for the tax break, make sure you actually like the place. No amount of tax savings can make up for living somewhere that makes you miserable. Honestly, the best way to "save" on taxes is to live a life that you enjoy, in a place that fits your budget holistically—not just on one line of a 1040 form.
Next Steps for You:
- Use a "Total Tax Burden" calculator to compare your current city with your target city.
- Call an insurance agent in the new state to get a quote on a hypothetical home; this is the most common "hidden cost" people miss.
- Review your "Convenience of the Employer" status with your HR department if you are a remote worker to ensure you won't be double-taxed.