It’s a heavy topic. People usually look away when the conversation turns to Staten Island suicide rates, but looking away hasn't solved anything. For years, this borough—often called the "forgotten borough"—has carried a weight that the rest of New York City doesn't quite seem to understand. While Manhattan glitters and Brooklyn gentrifies, Staten Island has consistently grappled with some of the highest suicide rates in the five boroughs. It’s not just a statistic. It’s families in Great Kills, South Beach, and Tottenville losing people they love.
The numbers are stark. According to data from the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, Staten Island has historically seen suicide rates that outpace the citywide average. In some years, the rate here has been nearly double what you’d find in a place like Queens. Why? There isn't one single "smoking gun," but a tangle of factors including the opioid epidemic, a lack of accessible mental health facilities compared to the other boroughs, and a deeply ingrained "tough it out" culture that makes asking for help feel like a weakness.
The Factors Driving Staten Island Suicide Rates
It’s complicated. You can’t talk about self-harm in this borough without talking about the drug crisis. For over a decade, Staten Island has been the epicenter of the city's opioid struggle. There is a direct, documented link between substance use disorders and suicidal ideation. When someone is struggling with addiction, the neurological and social fallout creates a perfect storm of hopelessness.
Isolation plays a huge role too. Staten Island is geographically cut off. If you don't have a car, getting to a high-quality mental health specialist can feel like an odyssey. You’re looking at two buses and a ferry ride just to see someone who might have an opening in three months. That barrier to entry is lethal. People give up before they even get to the waiting room.
🔗 Read more: That Mystery Compound in US Drinking Water: What Scientists Just Found
Then there's the demographic makeup. Staten Island has a high concentration of first responders—police officers, firefighters, and EMTs. These are jobs with incredibly high stress and high rates of PTSD. Yet, within these communities, there is often a stigma attached to mental health struggles. There’s a fear that admitting you're struggling might mean losing your badge or being seen as "unfit" by your peers. It’s a culture of silence that kills.
Misconceptions About the "Suburban" Safety Net
People think because Staten Island looks more suburban than the Bronx, life is somehow "easier" or less stressful. That’s a myth. The financial pressure of maintaining a middle-class life in New York City is immense. When you combine that with the highest rates of prescription drug use in the city, the "safety net" starts to look more like a spider web.
Identifying the Warning Signs in Our Neighborhoods
We need to be real about what this looks like on the ground. It’s not always a dramatic "cry for help." Sometimes it's a person in New Dorp suddenly giving away their belongings. Other times, it's a teenager in St. George becoming increasingly aggressive or withdrawing from their friend group entirely.
Experts like those at the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention (AFSP) point to specific behavioral shifts. You’re looking for:
- Talk of being a burden to others. This one is huge.
- Increased use of alcohol or drugs (which, as we’ve established, is already a major issue on the Island).
- Sleeping too much or too little.
- Extreme mood swings.
If you see someone who has been deeply depressed suddenly seem "calm" or "happy" for no apparent reason, that is actually a massive red flag. Often, that "peace" comes from having made a decision. It’s the time to lean in, not back off.
The Resource Gap and Who is Stepping Up
Staten Island has fewer psychiatric beds per capita than almost anywhere else in the city. That is a failure of policy. However, local organizations have stepped into the vacuum because they had to. Groups like the Staten Island Mental Health Society (now part of Richmond University Medical Center) and the South Beach Psychiatric Center are on the front lines, but they are often stretched thin.
There’s also the "Staten Island Strong" mentality. It’s a double-edged sword. It’s great for cleaning up after a hurricane, but it’s terrible for mental health. We need to shift that strength toward the courage it takes to speak up. Organizations like NAMI (National Alliance on Mental Illness) Staten Island offer support groups that are basically lifelines for families who don't know where else to turn.
Where to Go Right Now
If you are in crisis, or you know someone who is, you don't wait for a Monday morning appointment.
- 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline: Just call or text 988. It’s nationwide, but they can connect you to local NYC Well resources.
- Richmond University Medical Center (RUMC): They have a psychiatric emergency department. It’s on Castleton Ave.
- Statcare and Urgent Care: While not a long-term solution, they can provide immediate referrals in an emergency.
Breaking the Stigma in the Borough
Honestly, we have to stop treating mental health like a private shame. In a borough where everyone knows everyone, word travels fast. People are scared of being judged at the grocery store or the parish hall. But the reality is that almost everyone on the Island has been touched by this. Whether it’s a neighbor, a cousin, or a coworker, the "secret" isn't actually a secret. It’s a shared trauma.
We need more "Man Up" style campaigns that actually redefine what it means to be a man. Strength isn't carrying a heavy load until your back breaks; strength is knowing when to ask for a hand. This is especially true for our veteran and first responder populations.
Actionable Steps for Staten Island Residents
If you’re reading this and feeling overwhelmed, or if you’re worried about someone in your life, here is how you actually move forward. Don't just "keep an eye on them." Take a step.
Reach out directly. Don't use vague language. Ask the question: "Are you thinking about hurting yourself?" Research shows that asking this question does not "put the idea" in someone’s head. In fact, it often provides an immense sense of relief that the topic is finally out in the open.
Remove the means. This is a tough conversation in Staten Island, where many households have legally owned firearms or large supplies of prescription medications. If someone is in crisis, those things need to be out of the house. Period. No exceptions. Reducing access to lethal means is the single most effective way to prevent a suicide in the heat of a moment.
Connect with NAMI Staten Island. They provide free education and support groups. You don't have to be the one in crisis to go; they have groups for the families of those struggling. Understanding the biology of depression can take a lot of the "blame" out of the equation.
Advocate for better funding. Staten Island deserves the same level of mental health infrastructure as Manhattan. Write to your local council members. Demand that the city addresses the lack of specialized youth mental health services on the Island.
Save the 988 number in your phone. Do it right now. You might not need it for yourself, but you might need it for the person sitting next to you on the S78 bus.
We can't change the geography of the Island, and we can't change the past. But we can change the culture of silence. It starts by acknowledging that Staten Island suicide rates aren't just numbers on a spreadsheet—they are a call to action for every one of us who calls this borough home.