You’ve probably seen the photos. Seven or eight sardines, their glassy eyes staring upward, poking out of a golden pastry crust as if they’re gasping for air. It’s haunting. It’s beautiful. To some, it’s a bit gross. But if you’re looking for a recipe for stargazy pie, you aren’t just looking for dinner; you’re looking for a piece of Cornish mythology that tastes like the sea and a 16th-century miracle.
Most people think the fish heads are just a gimmick. They aren't. While the aesthetic is definitely what makes it "Instagrammable" in a 2026 world, those heads serve a practical, culinary purpose. As the pie bakes, the oils from the sardine heads drain back down into the filling. This keeps the interior incredibly moist and intensifies the flavor in a way that fillets alone never could. Honestly, if you cut the heads off, you’re just making a standard fish pie, and you're missing the point entirely.
The Legend of Tom Bawcock
We can't talk about the recipe for stargazy pie without mentioning Mousehole. That’s a tiny, picturesque village in West Cornwall. Local legend says that one particularly brutal winter, the storms were so fierce that no fishing boats could leave the harbor. The village was starving. Then, a local fisherman named Tom Bawcock decided he’d had enough of watching his neighbors go hungry. He braved the gales, headed out into the Atlantic, and returned with seven types of fish.
The village celebrated by baking all the fish into one giant pie. They left the heads poking out to prove to everyone that there was actually fish inside. Today, Mousehole still celebrates "Tom Bawcock's Eve" every December 23rd. People crowd into The Ship Inn, pints of local ale in hand, to eat huge slabs of this stuff. It’s a riot.
What Actually Goes Into a Stargazy Pie?
Traditionalists will fight you over the ingredients. Some swear by a mix of sand eels, horse mackerel, and pilchards (which are basically just large sardines). Others say you need hard-boiled eggs to soak up the richness. In modern kitchens, most of us use sardines because they’re accessible and fit the "staring" aesthetic perfectly.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Siege of Vienna 1683 Still Echoes in European History Today
You'll need a good shortcrust pastry. Don't use puff. Puff pastry is too airy and will collapse under the weight of the fish heads. You want something sturdy. For the filling, a base of thick, mustardy white sauce or even a heavy cream reduction works wonders. You want it to be decadent.
The Essential Grocery List
First, get about 6 to 8 fresh sardines. Don't use canned ones; that would be a disaster. You need the whole fish, gutted but with the heads and tails still attached. You’ll also need about 500g of shortcrust pastry. For the "guts" of the pie, grab some streaky bacon, a large onion, a couple of hard-boiled eggs, and plenty of fresh parsley.
The bacon is non-negotiable. It adds a smoky saltiness that cuts right through the oily richness of the sardines. Chop it small. Fry it until it's just starting to crisp. Use that fat to sauté your onions. It’s a game-changer.
A Step-by-Step Recipe for Stargazy Pie
Start by preheating your oven to 200°C (about 400°F). While that’s heating up, deal with your fish. You want to clean the sardines thoroughly. If you’re squeamish, ask your fishmonger to gut them but leave the heads on.
🔗 Read more: Why the Blue Jordan 13 Retro Still Dominates the Streets
Roll out half of your pastry and line a deep pie dish. Blind bake this for about 10 minutes. This prevents the dreaded "soggy bottom." No one likes soggy pastry, especially when it's soaked in fish oil.
- Sauté your chopped bacon and onions in a pan until soft and golden.
- Stir in some chopped parsley and a splash of lemon juice. Some people add a bit of cider here—Cornish cider, obviously—to give it a bit of a zing.
- Spread this mixture over the bottom of your pre-baked crust.
- Slice your hard-boiled eggs into rounds and layer them over the bacon and onions.
- Now, the stars of the show. Arrange your sardines. They should be standing upright, heads pointing toward the sky (hence the name). Space them out evenly around the dish.
- Roll out the rest of your pastry. Cut small slits or holes for the fish heads to poke through.
- Gently drape the pastry over the fish, easing the heads through the holes. Press the edges down to seal the pie.
Brush the top with an egg wash. This gives it that deep, mahogany glow once it's baked. Slide it into the oven for about 30 to 40 minutes. You’re looking for the pastry to be crisp and the fish to be cooked through.
Misconceptions and Nuances
One big mistake people make is over-seasoning with salt. Remember, the bacon and the sardines are already quite salty. Be careful. Also, don't worry if a little bit of juice bubbles out of the head-holes. That’s normal. It’s part of the rustic charm.
There's also a debate about the tails. Some people poke the tails out of the center of the pie too. It creates a weird, spiked look. I personally think it’s overkill. The heads are the icons. Keep the tails inside or just let a few peek out if you’re feeling fancy.
💡 You might also like: Sleeping With Your Neighbor: Why It Is More Complicated Than You Think
The Texture Factor
The texture of a proper stargazy pie is unique. It’s creamy, crunchy, and flaky all at once. The hard-boiled eggs provide a firm bite against the soft, oily fish. If you find the idea of fish bones off-putting, you can butterfly the sardines from the underside to remove the spine, while keeping the head and tail attached to the skin. It’s a bit of extra work, but it makes the eating experience much smoother for those who aren't used to whole-fish cooking.
If you’re serving this to guests, warn them. It’s a polarizing dish. But usually, once they taste the combination of the buttery crust and the savory filling, they forget about the eyes staring back at them.
Actionable Steps for Your Cornish Feast
If you're ready to tackle this, don't just wing it.
- Source the Fish: Go to a real fishmonger. Frozen sardines often lose their structural integrity, and you need those heads to stay upright during the bake.
- Pastry Temperature: Keep your shortcrust cold. If it gets too warm while you’re trying to poke the fish heads through, it will tear and look like a mess.
- The Cider Pairing: Serve this with a dry Cornish cider like Rattler or something from Healeys. The acidity cuts the fat perfectly.
- Don't Overfill: If you put too much liquid sauce inside, the pastry won't cook properly around the fish heads, leaving you with a gummy texture.
The real secret to a perfect stargazy pie isn't just the recipe; it's the confidence to embrace the weirdness. It’s a celebration of survival and the sea. Even if you only make it once, it’s a kitchen story you’ll be telling for years.
To get the best result, start by chilling your pie dish in the fridge before you even begin rolling the dough. This small step helps the bottom crust stay crisp. When you’re ready to bake, place the dish on a preheated baking sheet to ensure the heat hits the bottom of the pie immediately. This is the most reliable way to avoid a raw middle. Once the pie comes out of the oven, let it sit for at least ten minutes. This allows the internal juices to settle so the pie holds its shape when you slice into it.