Everyone thought the Florida Panthers were invincible. After a second straight parade through the streets of Sunrise in 2025, the narrative was simple: a three-peat was inevitable. But hockey has a funny way of punching you in the mouth.
As we hit the mid-point of January 2026, the Stanley Cup playoffs odds have undergone a massive, almost violent shift. If you haven't checked the board lately, you're in for a shock. The "Cats" are no longer the kings of the mountain.
The Avalanche are eating the league alive
Right now, the Colorado Avalanche are the betting favorites at +260. Some books, like BetMGM, have them as low as +210. Why? Because they are playing a different sport than everyone else.
They are currently sitting at 33-4-8. That is a 74-point pace in mid-January. They haven't lost a single game in regulation at home—they are 19-0-3 at Ball Arena. Nathan MacKinnon isn't just playing like an MVP; he’s playing like a man who wants to end the season in May.
Bettors have noticed. According to Christian Cipollini at BetMGM, the Avs are the most-bet-on team by almost double the next closest competitor. It's a massive liability for the house. Honestly, it's hard to blame the public. When you have Cale Makar and MacKinnon healthy, and the team is putting up a +79 goal differential, +260 feels like a gift.
What happened to the Panthers and Oilers?
The Florida Panthers opened the season as the +600 favorites to three-peat. Then, the wheels came off in October. Aleksander Barkov tore his ACL and MCL in a freak practice accident. He’s out for the year. Without their defensive heartbeat, Florida has slid down the standings. They are currently clinging to a Wild Card spot with 51 points. Their odds have ballooned to +850.
Then there's Edmonton. The Oilers are the ultimate "what if" team. They lost back-to-back Finals to Florida, and this year was supposed to be the "revenge tour." Connor McDavid signed a team-friendly extension to keep the window open. They even traded for Tristan Jarry to fix their perennial goaltending nightmare.
🔗 Read more: Por qué los próximos partidos de selección de fútbol de panamá podrían cambiarlo todo
But the scoring has dried up. McDavid had a bizarre goal drought early on, and the team is barely hovering above .500 in the Pacific. They’ve dropped to +975 at most sportsbooks. People are starting to ask if the window is actually slamming shut on the McDavid/Draisaitl era.
The Mitch Marner effect in Vegas
If you want to talk about a "glow up," look at the Vegas Golden Knights. They pulled off the heist of the decade by landing Mitch Marner from Toronto after his massive 8-year extension.
The fit has been seamless. Vegas is currently leading the Pacific Division, and their odds have narrowed to +800. Marner has brought a level of playmaking that Jack Eichel has feasted on. They look like the only team in the West capable of trading punches with Colorado in a seven-game series.
💡 You might also like: Why Tyrann Mathieu Is Still the Real Honey Badger NFL Fans Can't Stop Watching
Who are the real sleepers?
Betting on the favorites is boring. If you want real value, you have to look at the teams the "experts" are ignoring.
- The Minnesota Wild (+2250): They finally escaped the Parise/Suter buyout hell. They used that cap space to grab Quinn Hughes from Vancouver. Hughes and Kirill Kaprizov on the same roster? That's terrifying. They are currently third in the Central and look like a nightmare matchup.
- The Ottawa Senators (+4500): This is my favorite "long shot." The Eastern Conference is surprisingly wide open. While everyone focuses on Tampa (+700) and Carolina (+850), the Sens are quietly sitting second in the Atlantic. If Linus Ullmark can just be average, their offense is deep enough to make a deep run.
- The Detroit Red Wings (+7500): Nobody believes in them. Yet, they have 60 points and are second in the Atlantic. At +7500, the math says they are a 1% chance. My eyes say they are a lot better than that.
Why Canadian teams still can't have nice things
The "drought" is now 33 years. Edmonton (+975) is the best hope, but they look exhausted. Toronto (+6000) has basically fallen off a cliff since the Marner trade. Montreal is the surprise of the East at 59 points, but they are incredibly young.
The odds reflect a grim reality: the Cup is likely staying in the States. The "Winning Nation" odds have the USA at -400. Canada sits at +275. It sucks for the North, but the depth in the Western Conference—specifically Colorado and Vegas—is just too much.
What you should do next
If you're looking to place a bet on the Stanley Cup playoffs odds, don't just chase the "three-peat" narrative with Florida. The Barkov injury is a season-killer.
Instead, look at the Central Division. It is the powerhouse of the league. If you can find the Wild or even the Stars (+1900) at a decent price, take it. The Avalanche are the best team, but at +260, there isn't much "meat on the bone" for a bettor.
Keep an eye on the trade deadline. With the salary cap rising, we expect a few more blockbusters. A team like the Rangers (+7500) is currently underperforming but has the assets to make a massive move for a goalie or a top-pair defenseman. If they land a big name, those 75-to-1 odds will vanish overnight.
📖 Related: Why Leaving a Surfboard on a Beach is Actually Ruining Your Gear
Wait for the Olympic break in February. It's the first time NHL players are going back since 2014. Injuries in Milano Cortina 2026 will flip these odds on their head. If MacKinnon or Eichel goes down in Italy, the entire board resets. Smart money stays patient until the gold medal game is over.