Music is weird. Sometimes, you see a guy who looks like he should be doing your taxes or managing a mid-level accounting firm in Birmingham, Alabama, and then he opens his mouth. Out comes a sound so primal, so drenched in the sweat of 1960s Muscle Shoals, that it feels like the floor is dropping out from under you. That’s the St. Paul and The Broken Bones experience. It’s jarring. It's beautiful. It's honestly a bit confusing the first time you see it.
The band didn't just appear out of nowhere, though it felt that way when Half the City dropped in 2014. They are the product of a very specific kind of Southern upbringing. Paul Janeway, the frontman with the glasses and the suits that scream "Sunday Best," grew up in the church. Not just any church—the kind where you’re groomed to be a preacher. You can hear that training in every high-octane yelp and every theatrical drop to his knees. It’s not an act. It’s muscle memory.
The Birmingham Sound That Conquered Glastonbury
People keep trying to put St. Paul and The Broken Bones into a box labeled "Retro Soul." That is a massive mistake. Sure, they have the horn section. Yes, they have the shimmering Otis Redding vibes. But if you listen to their later records, like Young Sick Camellia or The Alien Coast, you realize they’re actually a psychedelic art-rock band wearing a soul band’s skin. They’ve evolved.
The core of the band—Janeway and bassist Jesse Phillips—started as a "last hurrah" project. They were literally about to quit music. They figured they’d record one EP, play a few shows in Alabama, and go back to their day jobs. Then the internet happened. Then NPR’s Tiny Desk happened. Suddenly, they were opening for The Rolling Stones. Imagine being a kid from Chelsea, Alabama, and having Mick Jagger watch your soundcheck. That’s the kind of trajectory that breaks most bands, but these guys just got tighter.
Why Paul Janeway Isn't Just Another Blue-Eyed Soul Singer
There’s a lot of "blue-eyed soul" out there that feels like a costume. It feels like karaoke. What makes Janeway different is the genuine Pentecostal fervor. When he’s on stage, he’s not "performing" a song; he’s exorcising something. He’s mentioned in interviews that he doesn't even remember half of what he does on stage because he enters a sort of trance state.
It's the shoes, too. You have to talk about the shoes. The gold glitter boots, the high-fashion capes—it’s a visual representation of the band's internal tension. They are half grit, half glamour. They are the red clay of Alabama mixed with the neon lights of a sold-out London theater. This duality is why they rank so high among live acts today. You aren't just hearing a concert; you’re witnessing a transformation.
💡 You might also like: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
Breaking the "Retro" Curse with The Alien Coast
By the time The Alien Coast arrived in 2022, the band was bored. They could have written Half the City Part 2 and made a killing on the festival circuit. They didn't. Instead, they leaned into synthesizers, samples, and darker, more abstract lyricism. It was risky. Some fans wanted the "old" St. Paul. But as an artist, if you aren't moving, you're dying.
Janeway started pulling inspiration from 17th-century Italian paintings and Greek mythology. He was thinking about his heritage, his daughter, and the weirdness of the modern South. The music became denser. The horns were still there, but they were processed, jagged, and strange. It proved that St. Paul and The Broken Bones weren't just a nostalgia act. They were a living, breathing entity capable of reinvention.
The 2023 release Angels in Science Fiction took it even further. Written as a series of letters to his then-unborn daughter, Marigold, the album is stripped back. It’s haunting. It’s the sound of a man who has spent a decade screaming his lungs out finally whispering. It shows a level of vulnerability that most "soul" singers are too afraid to touch. They usually hide behind the volume. Janeway decided to stand naked in the quiet.
The Logistics of a Heavy Touring Machine
Running a band this size is a nightmare. You've got a full horn section, keys, guitars, drums, and a frontman who treats every stage like a marathon track. Most bands of this caliber eventually shrink their lineup to save on hotel rooms and flights. The Broken Bones haven't. They’ve maintained that big, wall-of-sound energy because they know that’s the secret sauce.
- The Horns: Browan Lollar and the brass section aren't just backing players; they are the rhythmic engine.
- The Evolution: From the lo-fi grit of their early EPs to the polished, cinematic textures of their recent work.
- The Live Show: This is where the money is made. They are a "must-see" band because no two shows are exactly the same.
You’ve got to respect the hustle. They spend months on the road, hitting everything from tiny clubs in the Midwest to massive European festivals. They’ve built a career on the back of sheer, unadulterated talent and a refusal to be boring.
📖 Related: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
What Most People Get Wrong About Alabama Music
There’s this stereotype that Alabama music is all Lynyrd Skynyrd or Jason Isbell. While those are great, St. Paul and The Broken Bones represent a different side of the state. They represent the urban, soulful, weird, and progressive side of Birmingham. They are part of a lineage that includes the legendary FAME Studios and Muscle Shoals Sound Studio, but they aren't stuck in 1968.
They’ve faced criticism from purists who think soul music should stay in a specific lane. To those people, I’d say: listen closer. Soul music has always been about pushing boundaries. It’s always been about the intersection of the sacred and the profane. When Janeway sings about ghosts and technology and fatherhood, he’s doing exactly what the greats did. He’s telling his truth.
Honestly, the band is a miracle. In an era where everything is autotuned and quantized to death, they play real instruments. They make mistakes. They play with dynamics. They understand that a song needs to breathe, to swell, and eventually, to explode.
How to Truly Experience St. Paul and The Broken Bones
If you’re new to the band, don’t just shuffle their top hits on Spotify. That’s the amateur move. You need to watch a live recording first. Go find their KEXP sessions or their performance at Glastonbury. You need to see the physical toll the music takes on Janeway to understand why the records sound the way they do.
Start with Half the City to get the foundation. It’s the "classic" sound. Then, jump straight to The Alien Coast. The contrast will give you whiplash, but it’s the only way to appreciate the scope of what they’ve accomplished. They aren't just a soul band; they are a document of a group of musicians refusing to stay still.
👉 See also: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery
Actionable Steps for the Modern Soul Fan
If you want to support the band and dive deeper into this scene, here is what you actually need to do. Don't just be a passive listener.
1. Go See Them Live: This isn't optional. St. Paul and The Broken Bones is a live entity first and a recording project second. Check their tour dates on their official site—they are almost always on the road.
2. Explore the Birmingham Scene: Use the band as a gateway. Check out other Alabama-connected artists like Brittany Howard (of Alabama Shakes) or The Red Clay Strays. There is a specific "grit" to Alabama musicians right now that you won't find in Nashville or LA.
3. Listen to the Influences: To understand Janeway, you have to understand his roots. Spend an afternoon with O.V. Wright, James Carr, and Otis Redding. Then, flip the script and listen to Radiohead’s In Rainbows. You’ll start to hear where the band's weird, atmospheric shifts come from.
4. Buy Physical Media: Their vinyl packaging is consistently some of the best in the business. Young Sick Camellia, in particular, was designed to be a cohesive visual and auditory experience.
St. Paul and The Broken Bones have survived the "hype" phase of their career. They aren't the "new shiny thing" anymore—they are the veterans. They’ve proven they have the staying power to outlast trends because they aren't chasing them. They are just making the music that keeps them from losing their minds, and luckily for us, it sounds incredible.