Honestly, if you scroll through a few centuries of St Mary Magdalene images, you’re going to notice something weird. One minute she’s this glamorous, red-headed rebel in a velvet dress. The next, she’s a skeletal hermit living in a cave, covered in nothing but her own hair. It's a bit of a mess.
You’ve probably seen the "Da Vinci Code" version or the "penitent prostitute" trope. But if you actually look at the history, most of what we think we know about her visual identity is basically a 1,500-year-old case of mistaken identity.
The Jar, the Hair, and the Big Mix-Up
Why is she always holding that little jar? That’s her "attribute." In art history speak, an attribute is like a superhero’s shield or a brand logo. It tells you exactly who you’re looking at in a crowded church painting. For Mary, it’s an alabaster jar of ointment.
But here’s the kicker. In the Bible, there are three different women who get blurred together into this one "Mary."
- Mary of Magdala: The one Jesus cast seven demons out of.
- Mary of Bethany: The sister of Martha and Lazarus.
- The Unnamed Sinner: The woman who washed Jesus' feet with her tears and dried them with her hair.
In 591 AD, Pope Gregory the Great gave a sermon where he basically said, "You know what? These are all the same person." Boom. Overnight, the independent woman from Magdala became a reformed "sinful woman." Artists loved it. It gave them an excuse to paint someone who was both "naughty" and "nice."
You'll see this in works like Titian’s Penitent Magdalene. She’s looking up at the sky, eyes full of tears, clutching a jar. She’s beautiful, but she’s sad. It’s the classic "sinner saved" aesthetic that dominated Europe for a thousand years.
Why Does She Look Like a Cavewoman Sometimes?
Then you’ve got the really wild St Mary Magdalene images. Ever seen Donatello’s wooden statue of her in Florence? It is terrifying.
She looks like she hasn’t eaten in three years. Her skin is leathery, her teeth are missing, and she’s wrapped in what looks like a pelt but is actually just her own overgrown hair. This version comes from a medieval legend called The Golden Legend.
The story goes that after Jesus ascended, Mary moved to a cave in the South of France (Sainte-Baume) to live as a hermit. For 30 years, she didn't eat food; she was supposedly lifted by angels seven times a day to hear heavenly music. Because she had no clothes, her hair grew long enough to cover her entire body.
Artists like Giotto and Donatello leaned into this hard. It was a way to show "true" repentance—the idea that she’d completely given up on her physical beauty to focus on the soul. It’s a far cry from the "sexy" Magdalene of the Renaissance.
The Skull and the Mirror: The "Goth" Phase
If you jump ahead to the 1600s, things get moody. Georges de La Tour is the king of this. In his Magdalene with the Smoking Flame, she’s sitting in a dark room with a single candle.
There’s a skull on her lap.
💡 You might also like: Krispy Kreme Nutrition Guide: What You’re Actually Eating (And How to Make It Work)
Why the skull? It’s called a memento mori—a reminder that we’re all going to die. In these St Mary Magdalene images, she’s usually staring into a mirror or at a candle. She’s not being vain; she’s reflecting on the "vanity" of life. It’s quiet, it’s psychological, and honestly, it’s kinda relatable. It’s the 17th-century version of a late-night existential crisis.
Don't Touch Me: The "Noli Me Tangere"
There is one specific scene that shows up in almost every famous artist's portfolio: the Noli Me Tangere. This is Latin for "Don't touch me" (or "Don't cling to me").
It’s the moment in the Garden after the Resurrection. Mary sees Jesus, thinks he’s the gardener, then realizes who he is and reaches out. Jesus holds up a hand.
In these paintings—like the ones by Fra Angelico or Correggio—you get a totally different Mary. She’s not the hermit or the sinner; she’s the "Apostle to the Apostles." She’s the first witness. This is the version that modern historians are trying to bring back.
Spotting the Real Magdalene
If you’re looking at old art and trying to figure out if it’s her, look for these specific clues:
- Red Hair: Often shown as reddish or strawberry blonde, though the Bible never mentions her hair color. Red was associated with "venereal" character or passion.
- The Color Red: She usually wears a red cloak, contrasting with the Virgin Mary’s blue.
- The Alabaster Box: Usually a small, ornate jar or vase.
- The Crucifix: In later "penitent" images, she’s often holding or looking at a small cross in her cave.
What This Means for Us Today
We’ve spent centuries looking at St Mary Magdalene images through a lens that was basically invented by a 6th-century Pope. Whether she was a "sinner" or a "leader" depends entirely on which century’s artist you’re looking at.
Today, scholars like Dr. Elizabeth Schrader Polczer are looking at old manuscripts and finding that Mary Magdalene might have been even more important than the art suggests. Some think she was the "Beloved Disciple" or that her role was intentionally downplayed to fit a patriarchal narrative.
📖 Related: Moon Phase for Today: Why Everyone is Looking Up Tonight (January 17, 2026)
So next time you see her in a museum, don't just see a "repentant woman." See a character that has been reshaped, reimagined, and reclaimed by every generation for the last two millennia.
Take a closer look at the "Noli Me Tangere" depictions vs the "Penitent" ones. You’ll start to see two completely different women. One is defined by her past mistakes; the other is defined by what she saw first. It's a fascinating look at how art doesn't just record history—it creates it.
Next Steps for Art Lovers
Check out the Dura-Europos house church frescoes (the earliest known Christian art) to see how Mary was depicted before the 6th-century "sinner" label took over. If you're ever in Florence, visit the Museo dell'Opera del Duomo to see Donatello’s Penitent Magdalene in person—the sheer texture of the wood makes the "haggard hermit" story feel much more real than a flat painting ever could.