You’re standing on a beach. To your left, someone is ordering a café au lait and a flaky croissant in a chic, quiet bistro. To your right, maybe a hundred yards away, the air smells like spicy ribs and the sound of a Dutch casino’s slot machines echoes faintly over the water. There’s no border wall. No passport control. Just a small, unassuming sign.
Welcome to the island of St Martin.
Most travelers think they know this place. They see the postcards of planes flying dangerously low over Maho Beach and figure it’s just another Caribbean tourist trap. Honestly? They’re missing the point. This 37-square-mile rock is the smallest landmass in the world shared by two nations—France and the Netherlands—and that weird, friction-less coexistence creates a vibe you literally cannot find anywhere else in the Antilles.
The Border That Isn’t Really There
The story goes that a Frenchman and a Dutchman stood back-to-back and started walking around the island in opposite directions to determine the boundary. The Frenchman, fueled by wine, supposedly walked faster, which is why the French side (Saint-Martin) is larger than the Dutch side (Sint Maarten).
Whether that’s true or just a local legend told to tourists over too many rum punches, the reality is fascinating.
Since the Treaty of Concordia in 1648, the two sides have lived in peace. Today, you can drive from the high-energy, duty-free shopping hubs of Philipsburg on the Dutch side to the gourmet "culinary capital" of Grand Case on the French side without ever showing an ID. It’s seamless. But the personality shift is jarring. The Dutch side is where the massive cruise ships dock; it’s loud, neon, and feels a bit like a tropical Las Vegas. The French side? It’s Mediterranean. It’s slower. The shutters on the houses are painted in pastels, and the law actually requires restaurants to meet certain European standards of excellence.
Why Maho Beach Is Overrated (And Where to Go Instead)
Everyone goes to Maho.
Yes, seeing a KLM Boeing 777 roar ten feet above your head is a rush. It’s loud. It’s sandy. It’s also incredibly crowded and, frankly, a bit dangerous if you stand too close to the jet blast. If you want the "Instagram shot," go for twenty minutes and then leave.
If you actually want to experience the island of St Martin, head to Loterie Farm. It’s tucked away on the slopes of Pic Paradis, the highest point on the island. It’s a nature reserve and sanctuary built on a former sugar plantation. Instead of jet fumes, you get lush tropical forests, zip-lining, and a pool area that feels like a private jungle club.
Then there’s Orient Bay.
It’s often called the "Saint-Tropez of the Caribbean." It’s a long, sweeping white-sand beach where the water is a bright, electric turquoise. The northern end is famous for being clothing-optional—a very French touch—while the rest of the beach is lined with high-end beach bars like Bikini Beach and Kontiki. You can spend a whole day here just watching the kite-surfers and eating fresh lobster.
The Culinary Identity Crisis
Food on the island is a serious business.
In Grand Case, a small fishing village on the northern coast, the density of world-class chefs is staggering. You have places like L'Auberge Gourmande, which serves classic French cuisine that would hold its own in Paris. We're talking escargot, duck confit, and wine lists that are terrifyingly deep.
But then, just down the street, you have the "lolos."
These are open-air local barbecue stands. Sky's the Limit and Cynthia’s Talk of the Town are the heavy hitters here. You sit on plastic chairs, the smoke from the grills gets in your hair, and you eat the best grilled snapper and ribs of your life for about fifteen dollars. This is the real heart of the island of St Martin. It’s that weird mix of high-brow European refinement and gritty, soul-filled Caribbean tradition.
The Reality of Recovery: Post-Irma Life
We have to talk about Hurricane Irma. In 2017, it absolutely leveled the island. It was a Category 5 monster that stayed over the land for hours.
For a few years, the "Friendly Island" looked like a war zone. But the recovery has been a testament to local grit. While you’ll still see the occasional skeletal remains of a hotel that hasn't been rebuilt, most of the infrastructure is now better than it was before the storm. The resorts are newer. The power grid is more resilient.
There’s a common misconception that the island is "ruined" or "under construction." Honestly, that’s just not true anymore. In fact, many locals feel the forced reset allowed them to move away from mass-market tourism toward something a bit more sustainable and boutique.
Logistics: The Stuff Nobody Tells You
- Currency Confusion: The Dutch side uses the Netherlands Antillean Guilder (ANG), though the US Dollar is accepted everywhere. The French side uses the Euro. However, many French restaurants offer a 1:1 exchange rate if you pay in cash (USD), which is a massive discount given the actual exchange rate. Always ask "Is the dollar equal to the euro today?"
- Driving is a Nightmare: There is basically one main road that circles the island. If there’s an accident or a drawbridge goes up near the Simpson Bay Lagoon, the whole island grinds to a halt. Rent a car, but don't expect to get anywhere in a hurry between 4:00 PM and 6:00 PM.
- The Airport: Princess Juliana International (SXM) is on the Dutch side. It’s the gateway to other islands like Anguilla and St. Barts. If you're staying on the French side, give yourself plenty of time to get through the bridge traffic and security.
- Language: Everyone speaks English. On the French side, they speak French and a local Creole. On the Dutch side, they speak Dutch and English. You won't struggle to communicate, but a "Bonjour" goes a long way in Marigot.
The Hidden Gem: Pinel Island
If you want to see what the Caribbean looked like fifty years ago, take the five-minute ferry from Cul-de-Sac to Pinel Island. It’s a tiny offshore cay. There are no cars. No hotels. Just two beach restaurants and a few iguanas.
The water is knee-deep for what feels like miles. You can grab a lounge chair at Karibuni, order a passion fruit mojito, and just... exist. It’s the ultimate antidote to the cruise ship chaos of the south. Most people forget Pinel exists because it’s tucked away in a marine reserve, but it’s arguably the most beautiful spot on the entire island of St Martin.
Making the Most of Your Trip
Don't stay at an all-inclusive.
The island of St Martin is too diverse to spend your whole time inside a resort fence. Rent a villa or stay in a boutique hotel in Grand Case or Orient Bay. Get out and explore.
✨ Don't miss: Why El Dorado Cantina - Las Vegas Strip Photos Always Look Better Than the Rest
- Day 1: Land at SXM, grab a rental car, and head straight to a lolo in Grand Case for ribs.
- Day 2: Take the ferry to Pinel Island for a day of doing absolutely nothing.
- Day 3: Hike up to Pic Paradis for the views, then cool off at the Loterie Farm pool.
- Day 4: Head to the Dutch side. Do some duty-free shopping in Philipsburg (electronics and jewelry are the big draws) and watch one plane land at Maho just to say you did it.
- Day 5: Take a day trip. The ferry to Anguilla or St. Barts is quick and easy, making St. Martin the perfect "hub" for island hopping.
The island isn't perfect. It's crowded in spots. The traffic can make you want to scream. But there is a soul here—a weird, bilingual, spicy, sophisticated soul—that you won't find on any other island in the Caribbean. It’s a place of contradictions that somehow works.
Actionable Next Steps:
Check your passport expiration date now; you’ll need at least six months of validity to enter. If you’re planning a winter trip, book your car rental at least three months in advance, as the island frequently runs out of vehicles during the peak December–February season. Finally, download an offline map of the island on Google Maps—cell service can be spotty when switching between the French and Dutch towers.