If you walked into Busch Stadium right now, the air would feel different. It’s not just the winter chill or the construction hum from Roger Dean Stadium. It’s the silence where icons used to be.
Nolan Arenado is gone. Just a few days ago, the unthinkable became reality when the Cardinals shipped their cornerstone third baseman to the Arizona Diamondbacks. It wasn't a blockbuster for a haul of stars; it was a salary dump, plain and simple, with St. Louis eating $31 million just to move on. If you needed a sign that the "Cardinal Way" has taken a sharp turn into a construction zone, that was it.
St. Louis Cardinals rumors trades are no longer about "adding that one piece" to win the NL Central. Honestly, we’re in the Chaim Bloom era now. John Mozeliak has stepped back, and the new President of Baseball Operations is tearing the house down to the studs.
The Arenado Aftermath and the "For Sale" Sign
The trade that sent Arenado to the desert in exchange for minor-league righty Jack Martinez was a gut punch to fans, but it’s just the beginning. The roster is a revolving door. Earlier this winter, Sonny Gray and Willson Contreras—the big "win-now" signings of yesteryear—were sent packing.
Why? Because the math didn't work anymore.
You’ve probably heard the whispers about Brendan Donovan. He’s basically the last "high-value" trade chip left who isn't a prospect. The Seattle Mariners have been sniffing around, desperate for his versatility and gold-glove caliber utility play. There’s even talk of a swap with Boston for Wilyer Abreu or Ceddanne Rafaela, though the Red Sox are lefty-heavy enough as it is. Bloom knows Donovan could fetch a legitimate pitching prospect, and in 2026, pitching is the only currency that matters in St. Louis.
✨ Don't miss: The Division 2 National Championship Game: How Ferris State Just Redrew the Record Books
Who is Actually Left to Pitch?
Let's talk about the rotation. It’s... thin. Calling it a "work in progress" is being generous.
With Gray, Mikolas, and Fedde out of the picture, the Cardinals have a massive void. They recently signed Dustin May to a one-year, $12 million deal. It’s a classic Bloom "home run swing." May has the stuff of an ace but the health record of a glass vase. He missed 2024 with an esophageal tear (from a piece of lettuce, no joke) and has two Tommy Johns under his belt.
Beyond May, the rotation looks like a 2026 science experiment:
- Michael McGreevy: He's the only lock. He earned his spot last summer and isn't going anywhere.
- Matthew Liberatore: Still trying to prove he’s a starter and not a high-leverage reliever.
- Griffin Canning: The latest rumors have the Cardinals and Mets fighting over him. He’s a free agent coming off an Achilles tear, which fits the current St. Louis mold: high upside, high risk, low cost.
- Kyle Leahy: A dark horse to move from the pen to the rotation after a solid 3.07 ERA in 2025.
It’s a "transition" staff. Bloom is basically hoping two of these guys stick so the team can bridge the gap to Quinn Mathews and Cooper Hjerpe, the kids actually expected to lead the next great Cards team.
The JoJo Romero Market is On Fire
If you want to know which player rival GMs are actually calling about, it’s JoJo Romero.
🔗 Read more: Por qué los partidos de Primera B de Chile son más entretenidos que la división de honor
His 2025 season was lights out. A 2.07 ERA and a slider that made Shohei Ohtani look human. He’s under team control through 2026, which makes him incredibly valuable. The Cardinals are at a crossroads here. Do you keep a shutdown lefty for a team that might lose 90 games? Probably not.
Expect Romero to be the centerpiece of a February trade if a contender loses a reliever to a spring training injury. He’s the type of asset that gets you two "Top 15" organization prospects. In a rebuild, you take that deal every single time.
The Right-Handed Outfield Gap
During the Winter Warm-up this past weekend, Bloom admitted the team has "room" for a right-handed outfielder.
The fans immediately started chanting for a Harrison Bader reunion. Bloom didn't say no. Bader is 31 and fits the defensive profile the Cardinals lost when they traded Siani and shifted Nootbaar.
But is a reunion realistic? Bader’s market has been quiet, but he might still be too expensive for a team trying to slash payroll. Other names floating around the rumor mill include:
💡 You might also like: South Carolina women's basketball schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
- Randal Grichuk: Another "old friend" who would be cheaper.
- Tommy Pham: If he hasn't burned too many bridges, he's a gritty one-year option.
- Austin Hays: A steady veteran presence for a very young locker room.
Honestly, the most likely outcome is a "jobber" signing—a veteran on a minor league deal who can platoon with Victor Scott II in center field.
The JJ Wetherholt Era Begins
Here is the silver lining. The only reason the Cardinals were comfortable moving Arenado is because of the kids.
JJ Wetherholt is the real deal. Scouts are already picking him as a 2026 Rookie of the Year favorite. He shredded Double-A and Triple-A last year, and with Donovan potentially on the move and Arenado gone, the infield dirt is wide open.
Wetherholt at second, Masyn Winn at short, and Nolan Gorman at third. That’s the vision. It’s going to be messy. There will be strikeouts. There will be growing pains. But for the first time in five years, the Cardinals have a clear direction, even if that direction involves a few losing seasons first.
Actionable Insights for Fans
If you’re trying to keep up with the flurry of St. Louis Cardinals rumors trades, here is how to read the tea leaves:
- Watch the 40-man roster: The Cardinals are currently sitting at a full 40. Any new signing, like a Griffin Canning or Harrison Bader, requires someone to be DFA’d. If you see a young arm like Andre Pallante or a depth piece like Ivan Herrera being discussed in trades, it’s to clear space for Bloom’s hand-picked guys.
- Ignore the "Contender" Talk: This is a rebuild. When the front office talks about being "competitive," they mean "playing meaningful games in August," not winning the World Series. Adjust your expectations.
- The July Deadline is the Real Goal: Every veteran signing right now (May, Stanek, potentially Bader) is a "flip candidate." If they play well, they will be traded in July for more prospects.
- Focus on the Memphis-to-St. Louis Pipeline: Keep an eye on Quinn Mathews and Thomas Saggese. Their arrival in the majors will signal the end of the "rumor" phase and the beginning of the next era.
The days of the Cardinals being "boring" are over. They might not be good in 2026, but with Chaim Bloom at the helm, they’re going to be the most active team on the trade market for the foreseeable future. Get used to the turnover; it’s the only way back to the top.
Check the waiver wire and spring training invites over the next two weeks. That’s where the final pieces of this 2026 puzzle will fall into place.