The vibe around Busch Stadium right now is... complicated. Honestly, it’s a weird time to be a fan. For decades, "St. Louis Cardinals baseball" was synonymous with October. You just expected the redbirds to be there, grinding out 90-win seasons and making deep runs with a roster full of gritty veterans and future Hall of Famers.
But look at the gates. Attendance at the corner of Clark and Broadway took a massive hit last year, dipping toward levels we haven't seen since the early 80s. People are frustrated. And who can blame them? Watching Nolan Arenado get shipped off to the Diamondbacks just a few days ago (Jan 13, 2026) for a pitching prospect named Jack Martinez was a gut punch, even if we all knew it was coming.
It feels like the end of an era because it literally is. John Mozeliak has officially stepped aside. Chaim Bloom is now the man at the helm of baseball operations. The "Cardinal Way" is being rewritten in real-time, and while it’s painful to watch the star power evaporate, there’s a sneaky good foundation being built under the surface.
St. Louis Cardinals Baseball: What Most People Get Wrong
Most fans think the team is just "getting cheap." That’s the loudest narrative on talk radio. While the payroll is definitely dropping—Mozeliak himself admitted as much before he retired—this isn't just about saving money for Bill DeWitt Jr. It’s a total philosophical pivot.
For years, the Cardinals tried to "thread the needle." They’d sign a mid-tier veteran like Miles Mikolas or trade for a guy like Sonny Gray to stay competitive while refusing to truly rebuild. It resulted in a lot of 78-to-82 win seasons and zero playoff wins since 2019. That middle-ground approach is dead.
📖 Related: Louisiana vs Wake Forest: What Most People Get Wrong About This Matchup
The team is finally leaning into the youth movement. We’re talking about a roster that’s going to be incredibly young and, frankly, a bit volatile in 2026.
The Rotation Void
Let’s be real: the starting rotation is a giant question mark. With Gray, Mikolas, and Fedde out of the picture, the Cardinals have to replace over 50% of their starts from last season. It’s terrifying.
The plan right now is a "Six-Pack" of internal arms. We’re looking at guys like Andre Pallante, Matthew Liberatore, and Michael McGreevy fighting for spots. Bernie Miklasz recently pointed out that this projected rotation might average only about 35 career starts per man. That is a staggering lack of experience.
But there’s upside here. Keep an eye on Quinn Mathews. The lefty is basically the crown jewel of the new pitching pipeline. He’s got the "it" factor and could be a mainstay by the All-Star break.
👉 See also: Lo que nadie te cuenta sobre los próximos partidos de selección de fútbol de jamaica
The JJ Wetherholt Era Begins
If you want a reason to actually buy a ticket this summer, look at the infield. JJ Wetherholt is the truth. The 2024 first-round pick tore up Double-A and Triple-A last year, nearly putting up a 20-20 season with an OPS north of .900.
He’s the guy this rebuild is built around. Wetherholt’s plate discipline is elite—we’re talking about an 18% chase rate in Triple-A. That doesn't happen by accident. He’s likely to start at second base, though with Arenado gone, the hot corner is technically open.
Who Else is Stepping Up?
- Masyn Winn: He’s already established himself as a defensive wizard at short, but the bat needs to find another gear.
- Iván Herrera: Honestly, if he stays healthy, he’s the breakout pick of the year. He might end up being the full-time DH just to keep his bat in the lineup.
- Jordan Walker: The 2025 season was another rollercoaster for him. At some point, the "potential" has to turn into 25+ homers. 2026 is his make-or-break year.
The Chaim Bloom Effect
Bloom isn't here to win the 2026 World Series. He’s here to make sure the 2028-2032 Cardinals are a juggernaut. His focus is entirely on the "arms race" of player development.
The team just signed a bunch of international prospects on January 15th, including a highly-touted outfielder from the Dominican Republic. This is where the game is won now—scouting, data, and lab-grown pitching.
✨ Don't miss: Listen to Dodger Game: How to Catch Every Pitch Without a Cable Bill
The trade of Arenado for Jack Martinez is the perfect example of the new strategy. Martinez is a high-strikeout righty who dominated in the Sun Devils' rotation. He’s an "intriguing pitching prospect," which is exactly what Bloom craves. It’s a move for three years from now, not three months from now.
What to Expect in 2026
If you’re expecting a division title, you’re going to be disappointed. Most early projections have the Cardinals winning somewhere between 73 and 76 games. It’s going to be a year of "answers, not comfort."
You’ll see a lot of growing pains. You’ll see Victor Scott II trying to figure out how to get on base so he can actually use that elite speed. You’ll see a rotation that occasionally gets shelled because they’re learning on the job.
But you’ll also see the fastest, most athletic Cardinals team in a generation.
Actionable Steps for Fans
If you want to track the future of St. Louis Cardinals baseball this year, stop looking at the MLB standings and start looking at these three things:
- K/BB Ratios in Memphis: Watch the young pitchers like Cooper Hjerpe and Tink Hence. If they can limit walks, the rotation will stabilize sooner than you think.
- JJ Wetherholt’s Hard-Hit Rate: If he’s consistently barreling up MLB fastballs by June, he’s the real deal.
- The All-Star Break Pivot: Watch for more veteran trades. If the team moves Willson Contreras or Steven Matz by the deadline, you’ll know the rebuild is in its final, aggressive phase.
The "Cardinal Way" isn't gone; it’s just being rebuilt from the ground up. It’s going to be a long summer, but for the first time in years, the organization actually has a clear, un-muddled direction.